Discovery of High-momentum Nucleon Correlations in Nuclei — an Early History
L.Frankfurt a,b, M.Strikman b, · 2025
Read Discovery of High-momentum Nucleon Correlations in Nuclei — an Early History by L.Frankfurt a,b, M.Strikman b, (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-09337.txt.
Introduction
Leonid Frankfurt and Mark Strikman give a short history of how physicists found tight links between high-momentum nucleons inside atomic nuclei. Their 2025 paper looks back at the early steps in that search. The story is told as a summary rather than a new experiment.
The authors explain why light-cone mechanics became the right frame for describing high-energy nuclear processes. They then trace the steps that led researchers to the discovery of these close, fast-moving pairs. Readers new to the field get a compact map of the reasoning and the turning points. The piece serves as a guide to how a major idea in nuclear physics took shape.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | L.Frankfurt a,b, M.Strikman b, |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 27 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-09337
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Discovery of High-momentum Nucleon Correlations in Nuclei — an Early History L.Frankfurt a,b, M.Strikman b, Abstract We summarize the reasons for using the light-cone mechanics of nuclei for description of high-energy nuclear processes and describe the steps, which have led to the discovery of high-momentum correlations in nuclei. \headtitle Discovery of High-momentum Nucleon Correlations in Nuclei … \headauthor L. Frankfurt, M. Strikman 1 Preface Some personal memories of M.S. I first met Mitya in the fall of 1966 at the Leningrad University soon after we started our undergraduate studies in the Physics Department. We graduated in the spring of 1972 and were admitted to the “aspirantura” in April (my appointment started two weeks after Mitya due to some bureaucratic clearance games). Perhaps our most intensive interactions were during working on translation of Richard Feynman’s book Photon–Hadron Interactions . Vladimir Shechter managed to get a copy of the book a few days earlier than people from the Moscow institution and we got the contract. While doing the translation, we discussed the Feynman picture a lot. My interests focused more and more on high-momentum effects in the description of nuclei, while Mitya first worked on topics in perturbative high-energy QCD and proclaimed after the first data from the CERN p\bar{p} collider that nothing of importance could come from this direction of research. I guess that his opinion about the study of nuclei was even more pessimistic (it was shared practically by all theorists studying strong interactions). Mitya’s attitude started to change in the mid-2000s — he agreed that the discussion of the nuclear structure at the resolution scale of sponta- neously broken chiral symmetry is important, and he explored the structure of nuclear matter in a chiral model with an explicit inclusion of {\Delta} isobars in the modeling of nuclear matter. Some personal memories of L.F. By the end of the 1960s, it became evident to me that a deep puzzle exists in particle physics. On the one hand, the quark model explained many static properties of hadrons and their interactions. On the other hand, this hypothesis is inconsistent with what existed at the time of preQCD quantum field theories: due to the Landau nullification of the running coupling constant. The heavy nucleus looked as a good testing ground, especially due to high matter densities in configurations where nucleons come close to each other. So, I became interested in how these phenomena manifest themselves in high-energy processes, especially since it became evident that the theoretical method used in nuclear physics contradicted the Feynman parton model. Hence, we decided that it would be beneficial for readers to have a brief summary of theoretical and experimental discoveries of nucleons with high momenta and correlations between such nucleons. We do not discuss spacial correlations between nucleons, which are much more difficult (practically impossible) to observe [ 1 ] . However, we use the same name for both of them — short-range correlations. Our presentation will be mostly chronological — step by step. 2 Steps toward theoretical description and experimental observation of SRC 2.1 Step 0. Pre-1974 world In 1974, quarks were considered by most as merely a convenient approach to deep inelastic scattering with little connection to hadronic physics (a notable exception were relations between meson–baryon and baryon–baryon total cross sections [ 2 ] ). It was suggested for some time that to resolve the microscopic structure of nuclei, one needs to study scattering at a sufficiently large momentum transfer. Nuclei were considered in nuclear physics as best described by quasiparticle approaches [ 3 ] , in which short-range correlations (SRC) could be 20% or 50% — it does not matter for observables. Interaction between nucleons was due to meson exchanges for nuclear model practitioners, and ill-defined starting at distances 1/m_{\pi} for groups with high-energy physics background. What helped a bit in our interactions with several people about quark-related topics was the November revolution of 1974 — the discovery of J/\psi,{\psi}^{\prime} , dynamics of final states in e^{+}e^{-} annihilation into hadrons. (For some time L.F. spent more of his time on the charm/charmonium physics than on physics described here). A good illustration of this common thinking was our experience with submission to Physics Letters B a paper in which we suggested determining the origin of nuclear forces by means of neutrino–nucleus scattering. The referee stated that the authors suggest yet another way to observe meson currents and that it would be unfair to encourage experimentalists to spend time on such experiments. When we told James Bjorken during his visit to Leningrad in the spring of 1975 that the quark exchange was probably more realistic than the meson exchange, he responded — what is the difference? Our response was that there would be extra antiquarks in nuclei. He was happy and was telling people that this was one of the most interesting things he had learned during the visit to our institute. It took another 25 years to check experimentally using the Drell–Yan process that antiquarks are not enhanced in the relevant x\sim 0.1 –0.2 range [ 4 ] . Principle questions we were interested in included : (i) Could short-range structure of deuteron and heavier nuclei be more complicated than a collection of nucleons? It looked like there was no reason to think of a proton and a neutron coming close together as two nucleons since quarks could knead into compact configurations. We suggested to name such configurations as the “kneaded state” — later on, several groups started to refer to such configurations as six-quark states. (ii) Do meson exchanges provide an adequate framework for description of nuclear forces? (iii) How to test the hypothesis that nuclear forces are due to meson exchanges? (iv) What is the dynamics of nuclear forces at internucleon distances \leq 1 fm, where the wave functions of two nucleons overlap significantly. 2.2 Step 1. The starting point of the time line is 1974 It was clear that to resolve such configurations in nuclei, one needs to study processes with energy-momentum scales much larger than the typical mass difference between two nucleon and six-quark states. Also, we suggested half jokingly that asymptotic freedom prevents collectivization of quarks in line with our everyday experience. The effectiveness of this logic was confirmed by a series of experiments at BNL and JLab, which directly observed short-range correlations (SRC) in a series of nuclei, and established similarity of the SRC in the deuteron and heavier nuclei with pn correlations giving dominant contribution. In the fall of 1975, we came across the paper of West [ 5 ] , which stated that there exists a correction to the impulse approximation for the scattering off a deuteron. Such a correction would imply presence in the deuteron of hidden (unobservable) configurations 1 1 1 Several groups reproduced our result [ 6 ] and one or two were asking for our comments. In response to one of the letters in addition to the discussion of the calculation, M.S. cooked up a story that in our department, there is a saying “Whatever way you calculate a Feynman diagram, if you do it correctly the answer would be the same.” A member of our department, whose public service was to serve