Where Does Academic Database Research Go From Here?

Eugene Wu, Raul Castro Fernandez · 2025

Read Where Does Academic Database Research Go From Here? by Eugene Wu, Raul Castro Fernandez (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-08948.txt.

Introduction

Academic database research stands at a crossroads shaped by industry and by artificial intelligence. This 2025 panel proposal by Eugene Wu and Raul Castro Fernandez sets out to debate the field's future in an open forum. The document gathers summaries of earlier panels on the same question, plus position statements from the invited panelists. Views sampled from the wider data management community round out the brief. The proposal is a conversation starter rather than a study, meant to frame where database research should head next.

Catalog record

CREATOREugene Wu, Raul Castro Fernandez
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE20 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-08948

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Where Does Academic Database Research Go From Here? Eugene Wu, Raul Castro Fernandez Abstract . An open forum to discuss and debate the future of database research in the context of industry, other research communities, and AI. 1. Introduction We can informally define an academic community as a group of people who jointly contribute to advancing knowledge within a specific discipline, with common research questions and shared methodologies. Communities are brought together due to the importance and impact – broadly defined – of the questions that the communities pursue. The world, of course, is not sentimental. The fortunes of a community ebb and wane based on its competitive advantage as compared to the rest of the world. Historically, alchemy faded in prominence and was replaced by more effective methods, namely chemistry and the scientific method. Similarly, humoralism was replaced by evidence-based medicine, and behaviorism was replaced by cognitive psychology and neuroscience. In engineering, cybernetics grew out of war efforts and appeared poised to take over the world, but ultimately evolved into the pragmatic and engineering-oriented discipline of control theory. In computer science, “machine learning” research as repeatedly evolved from the 50s (logic-based), the 70s (expert systems), to today’s deep neural networks and LLMs that have taken center stage due to the massive potential that automated intelligence can bring. Closer to our hearts, database systems have grown in prominence over the past 50 years due to the demands of accounting, logistics, the Internet, and digitization. Yet, the data management success does not guarantee future success; that is up to us—the community—to chart our place in the AI era. A recent SIGMOD blog post ( Wu 2024 ) reflected on the state of academic research from this perspective of competitive advantage as compared to startups, industry, and other research communities. It argued that much of the success of the data management community is tied to the commercial success of relational database management systems (RDBMS). Yet, this success has transformed RDBMSes into a commodity that sits on the plateau of the technology S-curve, and continued investment provides marginal gains that cannot compete with industry. At the same time, the article asked what advantage academic database research has in AI. If this argument is true, it shakes the foundation of our academic community. We must answer what our role is and how the problems we solve are relevant not only to the researchers associated with our community but also to the outside world. On the other hand, many members of the community have objected to this characterization, and argue that our community is healthy, relevant, and simply poorly marketed to the outside world. This naturally sets the stage for a debate, and it is in this context that we have organized a panel of six members of the database community to debate the direction of the academic database community and where we should be going to maintain a competitive edge. Our goal is to identify directions and tangible action items to help ensure our community continues to be relevant in the age of AI and beyond. The panel will be structured around the following themes: What is the competitive advantage of the academic database community over the next decades? What is needed to keep it relevant? What specific interventions can we implement? What is our place in the current AI revolution? This Document: The published ACM SIGMOD panel proposal document should be considered a snapshot as of mid-April 2025. An up-to-date version of this document with comments from across the community can be found on ArXiv under the same title. 2. Panel Composition and Format To compose this panel, we solicited positions from 15-20 members of the community across different geographies, positions, seniority, and research topics. We then chose six panelists that provided balance in terms of academia and industry, applied and theoretical research, and that represented positions that vary from “stay the course” to “AGI will make everything irrelevant.” Each panelist will present a 1-minute thesis, followed by a 1.5-hour moderated panel discussion with interactive inputs from the audience. The panelists are, in no particular order: • Dan Suciu , Microsoft Endowed Professor in Computer Science and Engineering at the University of Washington. • Sihem Amer-Yahia , Research Director, CNRS, LIG; Vice President of VLDB Endowment. • Yannis Ioannidis , Professor of Informatics & Telecom at the University of Athens, President of the Association for Computing Machinery. • Ippokratis Pandis , VP/Distinguished Engineer at AWS. • Jens Dittrich , Professor of Computer Science at Saarland University; 3x CIDR gong show winner. 3. Self-Reflection Through the Ages The data management community has a history of self-reflection. Roughly every 5 years, a select group of senior academics convenes a closed-door meeting to discuss trends, opportunities, and challenges for the database community and issues a report ( Bernstein et al. 1998 ; Abadi et al. 2016 ; Silberschatz and Zdonik 1996 ; Abadi et al. 2020 ) . In contrast, this panel is an open forum for the SIGMOD community to participate in the discussion. Members of the community have spoken out on threats to the community, including Dewitt’s 1995 keynote ( Dewitt 1995 ) and Stonebraker’s 2018 Ten Fears talk ( Stonebraker 2018 ) . 4. Panelist Positions Below are short positions from each panelist. Dan Suciu Our community has a lot to offer to computer science in general. But we are not doing a great job at advertising our techniques beyond the success of relational databases. (Perhaps we can debate what we should do about this.) Yet, the people who need us, they know where to find us: the top database systems PhDs are hired with insane compensation packages, researchers from other areas increasingly borrow techniques developed by the DB community, and (to my pleasant surprise) even database theory has seen increased interest recently. Sihem Amer-Yahia My position is to reach out to colleagues in other disciplines who find themselves solving data-intensive problems the best they can, and help them better understand the mapping between their needs and data and the multiplicity of approaches out there. Why us? because we care about data models and because our ability to separate the what from the how and the why will help them better apprehend their questions. In other words, we are the best positioned to structure the data science that powers multi-, inter-, cross-, and trans-disciplinary research (Figure below). Can we rethink database design to enable these different ways of conducting science? Multi-disciplinary research involves several academic disciplines working in parallel on a common goal, yet following their individual disciplinary precepts and approaches. As an example, large-scale hypothesis testing requires to understand statistics and algorithms separately. The key point is that scientists exchange knowledge, but do not aim to cross subject boundaries to create new, integrated knowledge and theory. In inter-disciplinary research , boundaries between disciplines are crossed. Social Computing, for instance, is a new body of knowledge that resulted from integrating data management, web science, machine learning, and social science theories. The key point is that scientists pool their approaches and modify them so that they are better suited to the questions at hand. Cross-disciplinary research allows researchers to combine different perspectives and methods

Read the complete text