An Inverse Method for the Design of Freeform Double-Reflector Imaging Systems
Sanjana Verma, Lisa Kusch, Martijn J.H. Anthonissen, Jan H.M. ten Thije Boonkkamp, Wilbert L. IJzerman · 2025
Read An Inverse Method for the Design of Freeform Double-Reflector Imaging Systems by Sanjana Verma, Lisa Kusch, Martijn J.H. Anthonissen, Jan H.M. ten Thije Boonkkamp, Wilbert L. IJzerman (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-08929.txt.
Introduction
Sanjana Verma and co-authors wrote this 2025 paper on designing imaging systems with two curved mirrors. Instead of shaping mirrors by trial, they use an inverse method: start from where light must go, then solve for the mirror shapes. Their system takes parallel light in and focuses it to a point, with freeform mirrors that need not be round.
To judge the design, they compare it with the classical Schwarzschild telescope, long prized for low blur. A ray tracer checks spot sizes for light on the axis and off it. The freeform design gives smaller spots, which means sharper images, and the authors present the math that makes the method work.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Sanjana Verma, Lisa Kusch, Martijn J.H. Anthonissen, Jan H.M. ten Thije Boonkkamp, Wilbert L. IJzerman |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 41 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-08929
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
An Inverse Method for the Design of Freeform Double-Reflector Imaging Systems Sanjana Verma, Lisa Kusch, Martijn J.H. Anthonissen, Jan H.M. ten Thije Boonkkamp, Wilbert L. IJzerman Abstract We propose an inverse method to design two-dimensional freeform imaging systems. We present the mathematical model to design a parallel-to-point double-reflector imaging system using inverse methods from nonimaging optics. We impose an imaging condition on the energy distributions at the source and target of the optical system. Our freeform design is compared to the classical Schwarzschild telescope, which is well-known for minimizing third-order aberrations. A raytracer using quasi-interpolation is employed to test the performance of both designs by comparing the spot sizes corresponding to on-axis and off-axis light rays. We show that the inverse freeform design outperforms the classical design. 1 Introduction Freeform imaging systems are increasingly utilized in a broad range of applications enabled by high-performing compact designs [ 1 , 2 ] . Advanced fabrication techniques have bridged the gap between the design and manufacturing of freeform optical systems [ 1 , 3 , 2 ] . For designing imaging systems, the goal is to form an ideal image of an object, which means that all light rays from a point in the object plane must converge to exactly one point in the image plane. However, in reality, optical aberrations, i.e., deviations from an ideal image, are inevitable. Therefore, imaging design aims at minimizing aberrations. Traditional imaging design methods are the so-called forward methods like the Simultaneous Multiple Surfaces (SMS) method, achieving favorable designs using aberration theory, and optimization methods for aberration compensation which minimize a merit function dependent on the design parameters of the optical system. [ 4 , 2 , 5 , 6 ] . Recent direct freeform imaging design strategies include approaches based on nodal aberration theory and the “first time right” design method in which the optical surfaces are calculated by solving differential equations based on Fermat’s principle and user-defined conditions like minimal aberrations [ 7 , 2 ] . In practice, commercial optical design software containing numerous local and global optimization algorithms is employed for efficient and accurate system design. The optimization algorithms are iterative and inherently pose challenges like the requirement of a good starting guess and the presence of many local minima without a well-defined global minimum [ 6 , 8 ] . Forward methods like AI-assisted optimization methods in which the solution space of local minima is analyzed to obtain optimal designs and evolutionary algorithms effectively mitigate the challenges mentioned above [ 9 , 10 ] . Alternatively, we aim to develop inverse methods for the design of freeform imaging systems. For reflective optical systems, inverse methods in nonimaging optics are used to compute the shapes and locations of the freeform reflectors by finding an optical map that converts a given source distribution to a desired target distribution [ 11 ] . In [ 12 ] , we demonstrated that imaging systems can be designed using inverse nonimaging methods by optimizing the ratio of energy distributions at the source and target. In this paper, we show that the optical map for an aberration-free optical system can be utilized to establish a relation between the energy distributions of an imaging system. Using this relation, inverse methods from nonimaging optics can be adapted to design imaging optical systems. We will refer to the object and image planes of an imaging system as the source and target planes, respectively, as this terminology is commonly used in inverse methods for nonimaging topics. In nonimaging optics, inverse methods are based on determining an optical map by combining the principles of geometrical optics with the law of conservation of energy. On the other hand, in imaging optics, optical design depends on the optical map that produces minimal aberrations. In this paper, we impose the aforementioned optical map and combine it with energy conservation to determine the ratio of energy distributions at the source and target. We then employ inverse methods from nonimaging optics to calculate the shapes of the reflectors. We verify our design with raytracing that relies on a high-order local interpolation method called quasi-interpolation. A local method ensures computational efficiency and a high-order interpolation is required to avoid the dominance of numerical errors in the raytracer. This paper is organized as follows. In Sect. 2 , the optical Hamiltonian and the condition for the optical map to produce images with zero aberrations are described. In Sect. 3 , the mathematical model for the design of a two-dimensional (2D) parallel-to-point double-reflector imaging system is presented. Utilizing the classical Schwarzschild telescope, we present the design procedure and the verification method in Sect. 4 - 5 . The performance of the inverse freeform design is compared to the Schwarzschild design in Sect. 6 , followed by some conclusions and proposed extensions in Sect. 7 . 2 Imaging condition Let the z -axis be the optical axis and let the z -coordinate be the evolution coordinate as a light ray propagates through an optical system. In the framework of geometrical optics, the so-called phase-space coordinates q=q(z) and p=p(z) , completely describe the ray. The position q and momentum p coordinates are the projections of the position vector and the unit direction vector of the ray (multiplied by n , which is the refractive index of the medium) on a line z=\rm{constant}, respectively. In a 2D optical system, as a ray propagates along the z -axis, the rates of change of q and p are given by the Hamiltonian system \displaystyle q^{\prime}=\frac{\partial H}{\partial p},\quad p^{\prime}=-\frac{\partial H}{\partial q}, (1a) \displaystyle H(q,p)=-\sigma\sqrt{n^{2}-p^{2}}, (1b) where H is the optical Hamiltonian, p=n\sin\theta , and \theta is the angle of the tangent vector to the ray with respect to the optical axis (see Fig. 1 ). The variable \sigma , corresponds to forward (\sigma=1) and backward (\sigma=-1) propagation of the rays. Since, we consider a reflective optical system, n=1 in the sequel. \phantom{0}z q q n\dfrac{dq}{ds} p {\color[rgb]{0,0,1}\theta} Figure 1 : An illustration of the phase-space coordinates (q,p) on a line z=\rm{constant} , where s denotes the arc-length. Let us denote the phase-space coordinates of the incoming and outgoing rays by \bm{\omega}_{\rm{s}}=(q_{\rm{s}},p_{\rm{s}})^{\rm{T}} and \bm{\omega}_{\rm{t}}=(q_{\rm{t}},p_{\rm{t}})^{\rm{T}} , where subscripts \rm{s} and \rm{t} denote the source and target, respectively. The phase-space coordinates at the target are connected to the source coordinates by the optical map \mathcal{M}:\bm{\omega}_{\rm{s}}\mapsto\bm{\omega}_{\rm{t}} i.e., \begin{pmatrix}q_{\rm{t}}\\ p_{\rm{t}}\end{pmatrix}=\mathcal{M}\begin{pmatrix}q_{\rm{s}}\\ p_{\rm{s}}\end{pmatrix}=\begin{pmatrix}M_{1}(q_{\rm{s}},p_{\rm{s}})\\ M_{2}(q_{\rm{s}},p_{\rm{s}})\end{pmatrix}. (2) Let M denote the Jacobian matrix of the optical map \mathcal{M} . The optical map \mathcal{M} is governed by the Hamiltonian system in Eq. ( 1 ) and therefore M satisfies [ 13 , p. 164] MJM^{\rm{T}}=J, (3a) where J is the antisymmetric matrix J=\begin{bmatrix}0&1\\ -1&0\end{bmatrix}, (3b) with properties J^{-1}=-J , J^{2}=-I, J^{\rm{T}}=-J, and \det(J)=1 . Eq. ( 3a ) is the condition for M to be a symplectic matrix and consequently \det(M)=1 [ 14 ] . This implies that the phase-space optical map \mathcal{M} is symplectic. Symplectic maps are area-preserving [ 15 , p. 564] . This means that as a light beam propagates through the optical system, the area it occupies in phase space, also called étendue \text{d}U=n\,\text{d}q\,\text{d}p=\text{d}q\,\text{d}p , is conserved. We are interested in designing an optical system with minimum aberrations. So, we identify the