Observability of Acausal and Uncorrelated Optical-Quasar Pairs for Quantum-Mechanical Experiments
Eric Steinbring · 2025
Read Observability of Acausal and Uncorrelated Optical-Quasar Pairs for Quantum-Mechanical Experiments by Eric Steinbring (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-08928.txt.
Introduction
Eric Steinbring studies in 2025 whether pairs of quasars on near opposite sides of the sky can serve quantum tests that need true randomness. Light travel time says the photons from such a pair cannot have influenced each other. Those photons could flip switches at two telescopes, which would run a quantum test with settings no hidden signal could have rigged.
Past work used distant quasars, but the pairs were not fully beyond each other's reach. Such perfect pairs are also hard to view at once from one site on the ground. In visible light the sources are faint, so large telescopes are needed to catch them at fast camera rates without gaps that force assumptions. Steinbring works through what a ground setup would need. The paper is a survey of the observing problem, aimed at teams that design loophole free quantum tests.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Eric Steinbring |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 45 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-08928
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Observability of Acausal and Uncorrelated Optical-Quasar Pairs for Quantum-Mechanical Experiments Eric Steinbring Abstract Viewing high-redshift sources at near-opposite directions on the sky can assure, by light-travel-time arguments, acausality between their emitted photons. One utility would be true random-number generation, by sensing these via two independent telescopes that each flip a switch based on those latest-arrived colours; for example, to autonomously control a quantum-mechanical (QM) experiment. Although demonstrated with distant quasars, those were not fully acausal pairs, which are restricted in simultaneous view from the ground at any single observatory. In optical light such faint sources also require large telescope aperture to avoid sampling assumptions when imaged at fast camera framerates: either unsensed intrinsic correlations between them or equivalently-correlated noise may ruin the expectation of pure randomness. One such case which could spoil a QM test is considered. Based on that, allowed geometries and instrumental limits are modelled for any two ground-based sites, and their data simulated. To compare, an analysis of photometry from the Gemini twin 8-m telescopes is presented, using archival data of well-separated bright stars, obtained with the instruments ‘Alopeke (on Gemini-North in Hawai’i) and Zorro (on Gemini-South in Chile) simultaneously in two bands (centred at 562 nm 562~{\rm nm} and 832 nm 832~{\rm nm} ) with 17 Hz framerate. No flux correlation is found, calibrating an analytic model, predicting where a search at signal-to-noise over 50 at 50 Hz with the same instrumentation can be made. Finally, the software PDQ (Predict Different Quasars) is presented which searches a large catalogue of known quasars, reporting those with brightness and visibility suitable to verify acausal, uncorrelated photons at those limits. keywords quantum mechanics; cosmology; astronomy † † firstpage: 1 † † volume: 1 † † issue: 1 † † articlenumber: 0 † † year: 2024 † † copyright-year: 2024 † † hreflink: https://doi.org/ † † titlecitation: Observability of Acausal and Uncorrelated Optical-Quasar Pairs for a Quantum-Mechanical Experiment † † authornames: Eric Steinbring † † authorcitation: Steinbring, E. † † address: National Research Council Canada, Herzberg Astronomy and Astrophysics, Victoria, BC V9E 2E7, Canada; [email protected] † † reftitle: References 1 Introduction That quantum mechanics (QM) must be incomplete, allowing “spooky” outcomes requiring either super-luminal signals or hidden variables - essentially, unsensed influences on the outcome - was posited by Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen (1935) . Bell showed, however, that correlations in a QM experiment could allow tests against such hidden-variable theories Bell (1964) . Repeated Bell-theorem tests have since routinely found QM is correct through tightly and simultaneously restricting the necessary conditions on measurements (e.g. Rosenfeld et al. (2017) and references therein), including the influence of experimenter interaction: the so-called ”freedom-of-choice” loophole. One route to this has been to set experimental parameters via photons from astronomical sources ( Friedman, Kaiser and Gallicchio, 2013 ; Gallicchio, Friedman and Kaiser, 2014 ) , requiring that interference in such settings had somehow been orchestrated between distant sources and the Earth-based observer. Proof-of-concept tests using stars within the Milky Way were achieved Handsteiner et al. (2017) forcing any collusion in the outcome back hundreds of years. And extension to quasars ( Wu et al., 2017 ; Leung, 2018 ; Rauch et al., 2018 ) pushed this to \sim~{\rm Gyrs} , combining high redshift z with large angular separation on the sky to increasingly place these outside each others’ light cone; where 180^{\circ} apart that would be complete if both sources have z\geq 3.65 ( Friedman, Kaiser and Gallicchio, 2013 ) . Smaller separations could be compensated by higher source redshifts, although possibly at the cost of the objects being fainter. The motivation to reach this limit is independence of settings triggered via those photons, which are unspoiled by communication. But that is true only if no correlated errors are introduced via scattered photons from the sky or otherwise via optical inefficiencies and detector electronics; and so corrupt their unsychronized fluxes just prior to detection. To outline the timescales and error-limits necessary to meet, in order that the flux of two quasars can be known truly acausal and also measured as sufficiently uncorrelated, consider the one quasar-based Bell test undertaken so far by Rauch et al. Rauch et al. (2018) . It followed the methodology of Clauser Clauser et al. (1969) where an entangled pair of photons emitted from a central source are split between two optical arms and their polarizations detected at receivers. While those entangled photons were in flight, a switching mechanism at each receiver (also co-located with a telescope) selected between two polarization measurements at pre-fixed relative angles, chosen to test the maximum potentially observable difference from QM. That switch was set via the colour of the most recently detected quasar photon: a dichroic splitting flux into two broad colour-bands that did not systematically favour either selection. Bright pairs were viewed separately via two 4-m class telescopes from Observatorio del Roque de los Muchachos on La Palma. One quasar pair was separated by 73^{\circ} on the sky, having z=0.27 and 3.91 ; another pair 84^{\circ} apart with z=0.96 and 3.91 . Both quasar fluxes (in {\rm photons}~{\rm s}^{-1} ) were brighter than sky-background ( {\rm photons}~{\rm s}^{-1}~{\rm arcsec}^{-2} ) and a relative polarization measurement was retained only if both quasar photons arrived within the microseconds while the entangled photons were in flight. Fair sampling was assumed, that is, thousands of individual trials were obtained non-continuously (achieving a duty-cycle up to several seconds apart; a cadence \sim 1~{\rm Hz} ) during runs lasting 12 and 17 minutes, and so each quasar-photon sample initiating a switch was considered independent, providing no information which could be exploited to predict the next outcome. This tolerates at least one in four correlated switching photons being needed to spoil a Bell test, although possibly as little as 14% is enough Friedman et al. (2019) . Analysis showed that neither the colours of the two quasars nor the background noise against their detection (i.e. sky-line fluctuation) were correlated among all trials beyond such measurement-error margins. Optical or near-infrared (NIR) photometry from any single observatory site hinders such a QM-test experimental cadence fast enough to remove the fair-sampling assumption for quasars separated by more than 90^{\circ} where both have z\geq 3.65 . That is due to the two switching telescopes being at most kilometers apart, and 1~{\rm km} is 3~\mu{\rm s} in light travel time, i.e. \sim 1~{\rm MHz} rates. However, a typical z=4 quasar has a V-band AB-magnitude of about 20 Flesch (2023) (roughly the same as dark sky in {\rm mag}~{\rm arcsec}^{-2} ) and similar out to 1 micron, which even for an idealized unobstructed 8-m class telescope with perfect throughput (and splitting light into two bandpasses) gives a fluence less than 18 photons in 10 milliseconds under photometric skies but low elevation, at a reasonable observing limit \leq 1~{\rm mag} of extinction. Despite good seeing of 0.8~{\rm arcsec} this would be 17.5~{\rm photons}~{\rm s}^{-1}~{\rm arcsec}^{-2} against a background just below 2 photons, so an individual exposure signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) over 10 for each quasar. A sampling cadence of 100~{\rm Hz} would then already be the fastest possible retaining sufficient SNR against the sky background flux for simultaneous two-band photometry of both