Interaction-Required Suggestions for Control, Ownership, and Awareness in Human-AI Co-Writing
Kenneth C. Arnold, Jiho Kim · 2025
Read Interaction-Required Suggestions for Control, Ownership, and Awareness in Human-AI Co-Writing by Kenneth C. Arnold, Jiho Kim (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-08726.txt.
Introduction
Kenneth Arnold and Jiho Kim design writing aids that require human input in a 2025 paper. Many AI writing tools hand over finished text, which can dull thought and control. The authors argue for interfaces that keep people engaged through the whole generation step. Two techniques are built and studied in a text revision case.
One makes the user type out the assistant's reply with predictive text support. The other highlights spots in a draft where edits could be made. Both reveal the range of writing choices and give fine control, they show. The paper draws lessons for future human and AI writing partnerships.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Kenneth C. Arnold, Jiho Kim |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 18 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-08726
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Interaction-Required Suggestions for Control, Ownership, and Awareness in Human-AI Co-Writing Kenneth C. Arnold, Jiho Kim Abstract This paper explores interaction designs for generative AI interfaces that necessitate human involvement throughout the generation process. We argue that such interfaces can promote cognitive engagement, agency, and thoughtful decision-making. Through a case study in text revision, we present and analyze two interaction techniques: (1) using a predictive-text interaction to type the assistant’s response to a revision request, and (2) highlighting potential edit opportunities in a document. Our implementations demonstrate how these approaches reveal the landscape of writing possibilities and enable fine-grained control. We discuss implications for human-AI writing partnerships and future interaction design directions. 1 Introduction Current chatbot interfaces for large language models like ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini limit interaction to a turn-taking conversation, even though the underlying models could support more versatile interactions, especially for writing tasks. In this paper, we begin to explore the design space of interactions that people can have with model outputs, focusing on the potential opportunities presented by interactions where human initiative is required for completing a task. Although these interactions are, by construction, less efficient at producing plausible outputs, we aim to explore the potential benefits they might offer in control, ownership, visibility of the solution space, and feedback for model tuning. We present two interaction techniques for revision in writing: predictive-text and opportunity highlighting. The first technique adapts the familiar predictive-text interaction (top- k suggestions or free typing) found on mobile devices to allow people to type the assistant’s response word by word. The second technique visualizes alternative (and sometimes divergent) choices for revising text according to a writer-specified goal. Figure 1: Predictive text interaction repurposed to type the assistant’s response Figure 2: Highlighting opportunities for divergent choices 2 Design Principles AI support for writing has evolved primarily along two interaction paradigms: conversational exchanges with an assistant (as in modern chatbots) and editorial feedback systems (like inline markup in Grammarly or reflection tools like Impressona Benharrak et al. 2024 and Textfocals Kim et al. 2024 . While these paradigms have proven useful, they both place the AI in a position of either generating content or evaluating it, with humans primarily reacting to AI output. We propose interaction-required approaches that fundamentally shift this dynamic by necessitating ongoing human involvement throughout the generation process. Our approach is guided by three design principles that emphasize cognitive partnership between humans and AI systems: Prioritize cognitive engagement over efficiency Although AI assistance can speed task completion, using it without cognitive engagement can lead to overconfidence Fernandes et al. 2025 , errors Dakhel et al. 2023 , and skill stagnation Gajos and Mamykina 2022 . Interactions can instead be designed to encourage writers’ thoughtful participation rather than optimizing solely for speed or ease. This principle addresses how AI systems can support authentic self-expression, ownership, and accountability in writing, which many writers desire Biermann et al. 2022 ; Hwang et al. 2024 . The literature on explainable AI systems for decision-making suggests cognitive engagement as valuable goal Datta and Dickerson 2023 . Enable granular control Rather than offering only coarse accept/reject options for completed AI outputs, interfaces could instead allow writers to influence the progress of generation. Granularity could enable just-in-time feedback that shapes the direction of AI assistance, providing a way for users to clarify their goals without having to engage in prompt refinement or writing examples. Reveal the landscape of possibilities Interactions should make visible the alternatives available at each decision point, helping writers understand the range of options and make more informed choices. Prior work has explored contextual suggestions of alternative words or phrases at targeted points (e.g., Reza et al. 2023 ; Gero and Chilton 2019 ), but some authors have explored interfaces for navigating through the tree of suggestions in a narrative generation context Reynolds and McDonell 2021 . 2.1 Interaction-Required Suggestions The degree to which a writing support interface requires interaction can be measured, in principle, by an amplification ratio , the ratio of the entropy of system output (new text or edits) to the entropy of user input. For example, asking a chatbot to write a complete essay or make overall edits has a high amplification ratio since the input entropy is confined to the prompt. Accepting grammar suggestions also has high amplification ratio, since the user often only needs to click "Accept". We conjecture that LLM-powered interfaces with a low amplification ratio can be designed according to these design principles to assist writers at various points in the writing process. 3 A Case Study in Revision We will present two interaction designs that embody these design principles for the purpose of revision. As a running hypothetical example, suppose Alex is a Wikipedia editor who wants to revise the introduction section for the article on "Six Thinking Hats", as it was on 2025-02-25: “Six Thinking Hats was written by Dr. Edward de Bono. "Six Thinking Hats" and the associated idea of parallel thinking provide a means for groups to plan thinking processes in a detailed and cohesive way, and in doing so to think together more effectively.” We will use a revision instruction generated by Claude.ai: “Rewrite this document to be more comprehensive, structured, and engaging.” 3.1 Typing the Assistant’s Response with Predictive Text Alex starts a chatbot conversation in the now-customary way, asking for a revision according to her goals 1 . She now sees the assistant’s response being formed—but instead of seeing the assistant type its response, Alex sees an editable text box, which starts empty except for the now-familiar buttons of predictive text. Alex starts by ignoring the prediction buttons because she realizes it would be clearer to start with “The book”, so she starts by typing that phrase. Afterwards the predictions give the title of the book, followed by the author, which Alex readily accepts with a few taps. After that, the top 3 suggestions are “revolutionized”, “presents”, and “is”; she take “presents”, an active verb that avoids exaggeration. The next suggestions are “a revolutionary”, “an innovative”, and “a groundbreaking”, which exhibit the same problem of exaggeration as before. These suggestions were probably due to Alex’s prompt of “engaging”, but the vacuous exaggeration of the suggestions indicates to Alex that she needs to consider what exactly should be engaging about this introduction. So she pauses to read the rest of the article and concludes that the most important aspect is that the book provides a structured approach to thinking in individual and group settings. She needed to type “a structured”, but then the predictions offered acceptable remaining words with only a bit of guidance: “approach to thinking, both individually and collectively.” Takeaways This interaction leverages the familiarity of the predictive-text interaction that is ubiquitous on smartphones, but the simple extension of this familiar interface to the context of typing the assistant’s response to a revision request yields several unique kinds of uses: • The system sometimes helps with routine tasks, like typing a book name (functioning like an adaptive copy-and-paste). • The same interaction can suggest alternative wordings for phrases, using the natural 3– or 5–option button interface. • Unlike a chat interface, the writer can exert granular, just-in-time control over