Possible bound states in the triple- η c \eta_{c} and triple- J / ψ J/\psi systems
Guo-Feng Xu 1, Xu-Liang Chen 1, Jin-Peng Zhang 1, Ning Li 1, Wei Chen 1, 2 · 2025
Read Possible bound states in the triple- η c \eta_{c} and triple- J / ψ J/\psi systems by Guo-Feng Xu 1, Xu-Liang Chen 1, Jin-Peng Zhang 1, Ning Li 1, Wei Chen 1, 2 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-08665.txt.
Introduction
Experiments at the LHC have spotted particles made of four charm quarks bound together, which hints that three-body charm systems might also bind. Guo-Feng Xu and co-authors test that hint in a 2025 theory paper. They study triples of two charm-heavy particles, the eta-c and the J/psi.
Their tool is QCD sum rules, which read particle masses out of correlation functions in the theory of the strong force. A new iterative method tamed the five-loop integrals that such three-body sums demand. The masses they found sit below the breakup threshold for both systems. That placement supports the case that triple-charmonium bound states exist and could be hunted in future data.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Guo-Feng Xu 1, Xu-Liang Chen 1, Jin-Peng Zhang 1, Ning Li 1, Wei Chen 1, 2 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 20 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-08665
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Possible bound states in the triple- η c \eta_{c} and triple- J / ψ J/\psi systems Guo-Feng Xu 1, Xu-Liang Chen 1, Jin-Peng Zhang 1, Ning Li 1, Wei Chen 1, 2 Abstract The observations of fully-charm tetraquark states in the LHCb, CMS and ATLAS experiments suggested the existence of the hadronic molecules of two-charmonium states, which may also imply bound states in the three-charmonium systems. In this work, we study the possible bound states in the triple- η c \eta_{c} and triple- J / ψ J/\psi systems with J P C = 0 − + J^{PC}=0^{-+} and 1 − − 1^{--} , respectively. In QCD sum rules, we calculate the two-point correlation functions and spectral functions up to the dimension-four gluon condensate. We use the iterative dispersion relation approach to deal with the five-loop banana integrals, which significantly improves the computational efficiency. Our results show that the masses of triple- η c \eta_{c} and triple- J / ψ J/\psi states lie below the corresponding mass thresholds, supporting the existence of such three-body bound states. Introduction. — Over the past half-century, the search for multiquark states has always been a very intriguing research topic in hadron physics. Since 2003, there has been a resurgence of such investigations following the observation of numerous good candidates, such as the hidden-charm pentaquarks P_{c}/P_{cs} ,the doubly-charm tetraquark T_{cc}^{+} , the fully-charm tetraquark X(6900) , and so on ParticleDataGroup:2024cfk ; Chen:2016qju ; Guo:2017jvc ; Liu:2019zoy ; Brambilla:2019esw ; Guo:2019twa ; Chen:2022asf ; Liu:2024uxn ; Zhu:2024swp ; Wang:2025sic . In 2020, the LHCb Collaboration reported the X(6900) state and a broad structure between 6.2-6.8 GeV in the J/\psi J/\psi invariant mass spectrum LHCb:2020bwg . Three years later, the ATLAS and CMS Collaborations confirmed the existence of X(6900) in the same channel ATLAS:2023bft ; CMS:2023owd . In addition, ATLAS also reported structures X(6400) and X(6600) ATLAS:2023bft , while CMS reported X(6600) and X(7200) in the J/\psi J/\psi invariant mass spectrum CMS:2023owd . Meanwhile, the existence of X(6900) and X(7200) was also confirmed by ATLAS in the J/\psi\psi(2S) final states ATLAS:2023bft . Observed in the J/\psi J/\psi and J/\psi\psi(2S) channels, these resonance structures have been extensively considered as good candidates for the fully-charm tetraquark states Chen:2016jxd ; Bedolla:2019zwg ; Albuquerque:2020hio ; Giron:2020wpx ; Guo:2020pvt ; Karliner:2020dta ; Liu:2019zuc ; Wang:2018poa ; Wang:2019rdo ; Yang:2020rih ; Yang:2020wkh ; Zhang:2020xtb ; Zhu:2020xni ; Cao:2020gul ; Albuquerque:2021erv ; Wang:2021mma ; Wang:2021taf ; Yang:2021zrc ; An:2022qpt ; Wu:2022qwd ; Kuang:2022vdy ; Lu:2023ccs ; Feng:2023agq ; Yang:2021hrb ; Galkin:2023wox ; Wu:2024euj ; Chen:2024bpz ; Chen:2022sbf ; Biloshytskyi:2022pdl ; Sang:2023ncm ; Anwar:2023fbp ; Agaev:2023rpj ; Wang:2020gmd ; Feng:2020qee ; Maciula:2020wri ; Ma:2020kwb ; Wang:2020tpt ; Gong:2020bmg ; Feng:2023ghc ; Yan:2023lvm ; Yu:2022lak ; Ke:2021iyh ; Yu:2022lak ; Niu:2022cug ; Zhou:2022xpd ; Kuang:2023vac ; Liu:2021rtn ; Lu:2023aal , including the hadronic molecules composed of two charmonia Agaev:2023rpj ; Lu:2023ccs ; Lu:2023aal . In Refs. Dong:2020nwy ; Nefediev:2021pww ; Dong:2021lkh ; Agaev:2023ruu ; Song:2024ykq , the X(6200) structure was predicted to exist as a bound/virtual state near the J/\psi J/\psi threshold. If two charmonia can form a bound state, one may expect the existence of a three-charmonium state such as those in the triple- \eta_{c} and triple- J/\psi systems. In Ref. Pan:2024ple , the possible bound states and the Efimov effect Efimov:1970zz ; Naidon:2016dpf of the triple- J/\psi system were investigated by employing the Gaussian expansion method. They found a shallow bound triple- J/\psi state even in the case that the attractive interaction between two J/\psi mesons is weak. Recently, the CMS Collaboration observed the simultaneous production of three J/\psi mesons in proton-proton collisions and measured the inclusive fiducial cross section CMS:2021qsn , which shed light on the production of such a three-body bound state. Moreover, there have been numerous studies on fully heavy hexaquark systems in both the hadronic molecule and compact state configurations LQCD1 ; LQCD2 ; LQCD3 ; LQCD4 ; QM1 ; QM2 ; QM3 ; QM4 ; QM5 ; QM6 ; QM7 ; QM8 ; OBE ; WZG . However, the results obtained in these theoretical approaches are quite different from each other. More investigations are needed to deepen our understanding of the fully heavy hexaquark systems. In this work, we study the possible bound states of the triple- \eta_{c} and triple- J/\psi systems using the QCD sum rules method. Formalism. — In this section, we introduce the QCD sum rules method for investigating fully heavy hexaquark states sr1 ; sr2 . We construct the following two interpolating currents \displaystyle\begin{split}J(x)=&(\bar{c}_{a}\text{i}\gamma_{5}c_{a})(\bar{c}_{b}\text{i}\gamma_{5}c_{b})(\bar{c}_{c}\text{i}\gamma_{5}c_{c}),\\ J_{\mu}(x)=&(\bar{c}_{a}\gamma_{\mu}c_{a})(\bar{c}_{b}\gamma_{\nu}c_{b})(\bar{c}_{c}\gamma^{\nu}c_{c}),\end{split} (1) to study the triple- \eta_{c} and triple- J/\psi systems, respectively. The scalar current J(x) carries quantum numbers J^{PC}=0^{-+} , while the vector current J_{\mu}(x) carries J^{PC}=0^{+-},1^{--} . The two-point correlation functions induced by these two interpolating currents are defined as \displaystyle\begin{split}\Pi(q^{2})=&\text{i}\int d^{4}xe^{\text{i}q\cdot x}\langle 0|T[J(x)J^{\dagger}(0)]|0\rangle,\\ \Pi_{\mu\nu}(q^{2})=&\text{i}\int d^{4}xe^{\text{i}q\cdot x}\langle 0|T[J_{\mu}(x)J_{\nu}^{\dagger}(0)]|0\rangle\\ =&\left(\frac{q_{\mu}q_{\nu}}{q^{2}}-g_{\mu\nu}\right)\Pi_{1}(q^{2})+\frac{q_{\mu}q_{\nu}}{q^{2}}\Pi_{0}(q^{2}),\end{split} (2) in which the invariant functions \Pi_{1}(q^{2}) and \Pi_{0}(q^{2}) correspond to the 1^{--} and 0^{+-} pieces, respectively. We shall extract the invariant function \Pi_{1}(q^{2}) to investigate the vector triple- J/\psi state. In this work, we don’t study the 0^{+-} state due to the external P -wave excitation in J_{\mu}(x) , which may lead to a higher state in this channel. In general, the interpolating currents can couple to all structures with the same quantum numbers, including bound states, tri-meson scattering states and continuum. All of them will contribute to the correlation functions in Eq. ( 2 ). However, it has been demonstrated that only exotic multi-quark states can saturate the QCD sum rules, but not the scattering states. Moreover, the contributions from the scattering states are numerically small Wang:2025sic ; Wang:2020cme ; Wang:2019gal ; Albuquerque:2021tqd ; Wang:2020fuh . Figure 1: Feynman diagrams involved in the OPE series. At the quark-gluonic level, the correlation functions can be calculated via the method of operator product expansion (OPE). We adopt the following heavy quark propagator \displaystyle\begin{split}\text{i}S_{Q}^{ij}(p)&=\frac{\text{i}\delta^{ij}}{\not{p}-m_{Q}}+\frac{\text{i}\delta^{ij}}{12}\langle g_{s}^{2}GG\rangle m_{Q}\frac{p^{2}+m_{Q}\not{p}}{(p^{2}-m_{Q}^{2})^{4}}\\ &-\frac{\text{i}}{4}g_{s}\frac{\lambda^{a}_{ij}}{2}G^{a}_{\mu\nu}\frac{\sigma^{\mu\nu}\left(\not{p}+m_{Q}\right)+\left(\not{p}+m_{Q}\right)\sigma^{\mu\nu}}{(p^{2}-m_{Q}^{2})^{2}}.\end{split} (3) where \lambda^{a}_{ij} is the Gell-Mann matrix, with i,j the color indices. In the fully-heavy systems, only gluon condensates contribute to the nonperturbative effects, and thus we consider the OPE series up to dimension four condensate \displaystyle\Pi^{\text{OPE}}(q^{2})=\Pi_{a}^{\text{Pert}}(q^{2})+\Pi_{b}^{\langle G^{2}\rangle}(q^{2})+\Pi_{c}^{\langle G^{2}\rangle}(q^{2}), (4) which are depicted in Fig. 1 (a-c), respectively. In this work, we shall not consider the dimension six tri-gluon condensates in the OPE series, which are usually negligible in fully heavy multiquark systems Chen:2016jxd ; Wang:2020avt ; Wang:2021mma ; Wang:2021taf ; Yang:2021zrc ; Wu:2021tzo . Moreover, the computations of tri-gluon condensates will involve the massive high-power propagators in the 5-loop integrals, which are very difficult and complicated at the present stage. Actually, the calculations are already challenging enough for the Feynman diagrams in Fig. 1 (a-c). We shall introduce some integral techniques in the following to improve the computational efficiency. At the hadronic level, the hadronic spectral function can be parametrized by the “narrow resonance” assumption \displaystyle\rho^{\text{PH}}(s)\equiv\pi^{-1}\text{Im}\Pi^{\text{PH}}(s)=f_{X}^{2}\delta(s-m_{X}^{2})+\cdots, (5) where m_{X} and f_{X} are respectively the hadron mass and coupling of the ground state, and “ \cdots ” represents contributions from the continuum/excited states. The coupling constant f_{X} is defined as \displaystyle\begin{split}\left\langle 0\left\lvert J\right\rvert X\right\rangle&=f_{X}\,,\\ \left\langle 0\left\lvert J_{\mu}\right\rvert X\right\rangle&=f_{X}\epsilon_{\mu}\,,\end{split} (6) in which \epsilon_{\mu} is the polarization vector. Applying the dispersion relation (DR), one obtains the correlation function at the hadronic level \displaystyle\Pi^{\text{PH}}(q^{2})=\int_{s_{N}}^{\infty}ds\frac{(q^{2})^{n}\rho^{\text{PH}}(s)}{s^{n}(s-q^{2}-\text{i}0^{+})}+\sum^{n-1}_{i=0}b_{i}(q^{2})^{i}, (7)