Quantum-Secured Device-Independent Global Positioning System
Chon-Fai Kam, En-Jui Kuo · 2025
Read Quantum-Secured Device-Independent Global Positioning System by Chon-Fai Kam, En-Jui Kuo (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-08465.txt.
Introduction
Chon-Fai Kam and En-Jui Kuo propose a quantum check that could harden satellite navigation against attack. Their 2025 paper sets out a self-testing protocol for groups of entangled particles. The test relies on Bell nonlocality, a quantum effect so strict that passing it certifies the shared state is truly entangled, without trusting the devices used.
The authors then ask what such a check would demand in practice for a task like the Global Positioning System. They work through a five-qubit code, a small error-correcting unit, on two kinds of present-day quantum hardware. Superconducting and trapped-ion machines are compared on circuit fidelity and total gate time. The study maps what current noisy quantum devices would need to run the scheme, and where the gaps still lie.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Chon-Fai Kam, En-Jui Kuo |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 22 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-08465
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Quantum-Secured Device-Independent Global Positioning System Chon-Fai Kam, En-Jui Kuo Abstract This paper introduces a novel device-independent quantum self-testing protocol designed specifically for multipartite quantum communication. By exploiting the quantum rigidity in Bell nonlocality, the protocol enables the certification of genuinely entangled subspaces without reliance on device assumptions. Additionally, we investigate its potential to enhance the security of the Global Positioning System (GPS) against malicious cyberattacks. The study concludes with a comprehensive analysis of the experimental requirements, comparing superconducting and trapped-ion qubit architectures in terms of full-circuit fidelity and total gate time for generating a five-qubit code in the context of the noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) era. I Introduction Quantum communication marks a significant advancement in the future of technology, primarily due to its unparalleled security and rapid data transmission capabilities. Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) [ bennett2014quantum , ekert1991quantum ] exemplifies this progress by offering encryption that is theoretically immune to cyber-attacks. Its foundation in quantum mechanics ensures that any attempt at eavesdropping disrupts the quantum state of particles, rendering the transmission invalid. This characteristic distinguishes it significantly from classical communication protocols. A notable class of quantum protocols that provides exceptionally robust protection for encrypted data is known as quantum device-independent protocols [ baccari2020device ] . These protocols treat the encrypted quantum states as a “black box" and verify their integrity in laboratories that are spatially separated through the application of Bell-type inequalities. According to the literature, both quantum secure direct communication (QSDC) [ long2002theoretically , deng2004secure ] and quantum key distribution (QKD) [ acin2007device ] have been demonstrated to incorporate device-independent protocols. As a result, these protocols are considered among the most advanced and secure technologies at the forefront of information security. In this work, we examine a novel device-independent quantum communication protocol and demonstrate its applicability to protect the global positioning system (GPS) [ kaplan2017understanding ] against cyberattacks. The protocol is centered on quantum self-testing, where a maximally entangled quantum state is shared between the satellite and the receiver. The rigidity of Bell non-locality shared between the satellites and receivers ensures that any tampering with the quantum state can be identified through the non-maximal violation of the Bell-CHSH-like inequalities. Recent studies [ sarkar2025using ] have introduced protocols aimed at protecting the Global Positioning System (GPS) from simple attacks on transmissions between a satellite and a receiver, utilizing the bipartite Bell-CHSH inequality [ clauser1969proposed , bell1964einstein ] to certify the maximally entangled Bell state shared between the two parties. However, a single satellite is insufficient for accurately determining the position of a three-dimensional object on Earth, as this requires at least three satellites. Moreover, a fourth satellite is essential to achieve high precision in measuring local time [ kaplan2017understanding ] . Increasing the number of satellites further improves the accuracy of both time synchronization and distance measurement. As such, a multipartite quantum communication protocol is crucial for ensuring high-precision transmissions, such as those required by GPS, as it enables the secure and accurate exchange of information among multiple satellites and receivers. Intriguingly, Rigorous mathematical studies have also demonstrated that, in most cases, a network of five satellites is essential to pinpoint the exact location of a moving object on Earth with high precision [ boutin2024global ] . Central to this quantum protocol is the quantum self-testing of the five-qubit code, denoted as [[5,1,3]] , which was proposed by Baccari et al. [ baccari2020device ] . This code encodes a single logical qubit into five physical qubits and represents the smallest possible code capable of correcting arbitrary single-qubit error. Intriguingly, this code facilitates a quantum communication protocol tailored for applications involving four satellites and a single receiver — be it a car, an aircraft, or a ship — where precise receiver positioning is critical. In this proposal, the quantum communication tasks between the satellites and the receiver are based on quantum self-testing of the entangled subspace within the physical code space. The structure of the entangled subspace ensures that errors affecting local physical qubits can be detected and corrected. Consequently, any hostile cyber attackers would need to compromise multiple physical qubits in a manner that exceeds the error correction capabilities of the code; otherwise, the attack would fail. Moreover, a direct extension of the Bell-CHSH inequality, like the Mermin inequality [ adhikari2016analytical , cabello2008mermin ] , is inadequate for defending against all potential cyber attacks that introduce single-qubit errors on the physical qubits. Additionally, a simple quantum circuit for the five-qubit code, designed exclusively with two-qubit CNOT gates and single-qubit Hadamard gates, has been explicitly formulated [ mondal2024optimized ] . This makes our quantum protocol particularly suited for quantum computers in the noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) era [ preskill2018quantum , brooks2019beyond ] , where the fidelities of two-qubit gates and single-qubit states have improved to nearly or surpassing 99.99%, with operation times on the scale of tens of nanoseconds for superconducting quantum systems. Also, to the best of our knowledge, the multipartite generalization of entangled states used in Bell-CHSH-type inequalities — such as the Mermin-Ardehali-Belinskii-Klyshko (MABK) inequality [ panwar2023elegant ] , Compact Bell Inequalities [ wu2013compact ] , or Iterative Multipartite CHSH-Type Inequalities [ fan2023generalized ] — as well as most stabilizer codes, excluding the simplest Mermin inequality and the five-qubit code utilized in this work, lacks explicit quantum circuit designs. This underscores the unique significance of our multipartite quantum communication proposal. Notice that our multipartite quantum communication protocol is not confined to the five-qubit code; more advanced error correction codes can be implemented for higher-precision scenarios involving more than five satellites, as long as the rigidity of quantum locality is maintained. Furthermore, our protocol differs from quantum key distribution methods, such as the BB84 protocol [ bennett2014quantum ] , in that it does not require distinguishing between public and private keys. Additionally, we eliminate the need for classical channels, ensuring that the entangled states shared among the satellites remain secure and immune to compromise or jamming. Figure 1: Illustration of a quantum-secured device-independent global positioning system. Here, we denote the four satellites as \mathcal{S}_{i} for i=1,2,3,4 , and the receiver as R . The middle state \ket{\psi} illustrates the entangled states shared by 5 parties. II Methods At the core of our protocol is the principle of quantum self-testing. Quantum self-testing is a method that employs spacelike-separated correlation experiments to infer the characteristics of multipartite quantum states without any prior knowledge of the entangled state. To illustrate this concept, we use the bipartite Bell-CHSH test as an example. In the standard Bell-CHSH scenario, two observers, Alice and Bob, perform correlation measurements from spacelike-separated laboratories. Each observer has two binary measurement operators, represented as A_{0} and A_{1} for Alice, and B_{0} and B_{1} for Bob. Physically, the term binary operators signifies that the quantum particles involved possess two energy levels. The Pauli matrices, which represent these binary operators, act as operators in this system and can be interpreted as rotations on the Bloch sphere. Mathematically, binary operators signify that the Pauli matrices or their combinations have eigenvalues restricted to 1 and -1 . This reflects the fact that any single measurement produces one of two possible outcomes: either 1 or -1 . Moreover, the binary operators are involutory, meaning they square