Information bounds on the accuracy of cell polarization

Tau-Mu Yi · 2025

Read Information bounds on the accuracy of cell polarization by Tau-Mu Yi (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-08164.txt.

Introduction

A cell facing a chemical gradient must decide which way to point, and noise in the signal limits how well it can choose. Tau-Mu Yi treats that pointing, called polarization, as information about the gradient's direction. He applies a theory of optimal sensing built on the information capacity of a Gaussian channel. Ligand diffusion and receptor binding are modeled as a mixed Poisson process, matching known single-receptor accuracy limits.

Simulations of molecule counts at the cell surface came close to the theoretical bound when the signal was weak. Testing three generic polarity models, he found that a filter-amplifier design and time integration both shrug off noise well. He then compared the theory with yeast mating experiments. Slow ligand binding emerged as the key limit, which longer averaging can partly offset at the cost of a slower response.

Catalog record

CREATORTau-Mu Yi
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE61 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-08164

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Information bounds on the accuracy of cell polarization Tau-Mu Yi Abstract Here we characterized an information measure for cell polarity that applies to non-motile cells responding to a chemical gradient. The central idea is that polarization represents information about the direction of the gradient. We applied a theory of optimal gradient sensing and response in the presence of external noise based on the information capacity of a Gaussian channel. First, we formulated an information framework that describes spatial gradient sensing and polarization response. As part of this section, we modeled ligand diffusion and receptor-binding dynamics as a mixed Poisson distribution, confirming the single receptor accuracy limits derived by ten Wolde and colleagues. Second, we performed numerical calculations of stochastic ligand levels at the cell surface to estimate the information provided about the directional component of the gradient vector, which was close to the Gaussian channel bound for low signal-to-noise ratios. Third, we used the information framework to evaluate the noise-robustness of three generic models of cell polarity, demonstrating that a filter-amplifier architecture and time integration can attenuate the detrimental impact of noise on polarity so that the model can approach the theoretical limits. Fourth, we compared the theory to published experimental data on yeast mating projection growth in a pheromone gradient, identifying the ligand association rate and integration time as two key parameters affecting directional accuracy. By varying these parameters, we showed that for certain ranges the theory is roughly in agreement with the data, and that the slow binding rate constant is a key limiting factor. We concluded that temporal averaging can help overcome the slow binding rate to achieve greater accuracy, but with the drawback of a slow mating response. A Preprint Keywords Information theory \cdot Cell polarization \cdot Gradient sensing 1 Introduction Gradient sensing and response is a basic cellular behavior [ 1 , 2 ] . Cells sense a chemical gradient and then respond by moving or projecting up the gradient. During this process, protein components localize to the front (or back) of the cell; this asymmetry induced by an external (e.g. gradient) or internal cue is referred to as cell polarity [ 3 , 4 , 5 ] . Specialized structures, functions, and behaviors develop from this asymmetry. Examples include neurons forming axons and dendrites, and neutrophils actively tracking foreign invaders such as bacteria [ 6 , 7 ] . There are two basic strategies to traverse a chemical gradient: temporal sensing and spatial sensing [ 8 ] . In temporal sensing, the cell measures the change in chemical concentration as a function of time ( dC/dt ), and then decides whether to continue moving in the same direction or to change directions [ 9 , 10 ] . Here we focus on spatial sensing in which the cell measures the concentration differences on the cell surface ( dC/dx ), and based on this direct gradient information, moves or projects in the appropriate direction. The response can be measured in terms of polarization, e.g. projection growth (chemotropism), or movement (chemotaxis). Typically, the directional accuracy of the response is assessed by calculating the angle ( \theta ) of the polarization/growth/movement with respect to the gradient direction [ 11 , 12 ] . For nonmotile cells, one calculates the cosine of this angle between the projection and gradient ( cos(\theta) ) [ 13 ] . For motile cells, one measures the equivalent chemotaxis index (CI) which is the distance traveled up the gradient divided by the total distance [ 14 ] . It has been found that cells are quite remarkable at gradient sensing. For example, yeast, neurons, neutrophils and Dictyostelium cells can sense shallow gradients and respond by projecting or moving up the gradient with good accuracy [ 12 , 15 , 16 , 17 , 1 ] . However, this gradient sensing behavior is not perfect. Not all cells are perfectly aligned with the gradient, nor do they move perfectly straight up the gradient. What are the limits to the accuracy of gradient sensing and response? These limits are imposed by external or internal noise [ 18 ] to the cell; in the absence of noise, the sensing and response can be perfectly aligned with the gradient direction. Substantial progress has been made understanding how accurately cells can measure chemical concentrations [ 18 , 19 , 20 , 21 , 22 ] . In particular, researchers have characterized the constraints placed by external noise from diffusion and stochastic receptor binding. Berg and Purcell [ 23 ] originally formulated the theory for noise arising from individual ligand molecules randomly diffusing into the neighborhood of receptors. Subsequent work has described the additional variance from stochastic binding of those molecules to receptors on the cell surface giving rise to uncertainty in the estimated concentration [ 24 , 21 ] . Recently, ten Wolde and colleagues [ 18 ] reviewed the literature on the limits to cellular sensing of chemicals at low concentrations. One organizing principle was the concept of receptor correlation time ( t_{c} ), i.e. "the timescale over which fluctuations in the state of the receptor, arising from the stochastic receptor-ligand binding, decay." Cells sense chemical ligands by measuring receptor occupancy over a time window T , and the variance of this time-averaged occupancy ( n_{T} ) depends on a factor of T/(2t_{c}) , which can be interpreted as the number of independent measurements. The review then characterized the various results in the literature as different approaches to estimating t_{c} . Kaizu et al. [ 24 ] took advantage of the formalism of Agmon and Szabo [ 25 ] for reversible diffusion-influenced reactions to calculate the zero-frequency limit of the correlation function from which the receptor correlation time t_{c} was obtained in terms of renormalized association and dissociation rate constants. The end result was an expression for the fractional variance of the concentration estimate by a single receptor which consisted of two terms. The first represented the uncertainty or noise from diffusion and was identical to the expression of Berg and Purcell [ 23 ] , and the second represented noise from receptor binding, which was absent in the original work. Bialek and Setayeshgar [ 21 ] applied the fluctuation-dissipation theorem (FDT) to the differential equation system describing receptor binding. Fluctuations in both diffusion and receptor-ligand interaction "impede" the force of receptor binding, thereby relating spontaneous fluctuations in receptor occupancy to the linear response of receptor occupancy to changes in binding free energy. From the power spectrum of these fluctuations, one can calculate the receptor correlation time ( t_{c} ), and hence the variance in monitored ligand concentration. The result was very similar to the expression of Kaizu et al. [ 24 ] with an identical receptor-binding noise term and a slightly different diffusion term. Whereas the above work was concerned with the cell measuring the concentration of a chemical ligand at a given point or region in space, other research has addressed the question of spatial sensing, i.e. determining gradient direction by monitoring chemical concentration at different points on the cell surface. What are the limits of spatial sensing? Endres and Wingreen [ 20 ] studied spatial sensing taking into account noise arising from diffusion (but

Read the complete text