Centre vortices in thermal lattice QCD with dynamical fermions
Derek Leinweber · 2025
Read Centre vortices in thermal lattice QCD with dynamical fermions by Derek Leinweber (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-08131.txt.
Introduction
Jackson Mickley and co-authors report evidence for a second phase transition in the theory of the strong force, in a 2025 paper on centre vortices. The theory, quantum chromodynamics, has one known change as matter heats up. The team tracked swirling structures called centre vortices across many temperatures, to see whether confinement, the grip holding quarks inside particles, ends at that same point.
Using computer simulations with dynamical fermions, they watched the vortex web change shape with heat. The web spans the whole system through the known transition, then breaks up at about twice that temperature. That break-up signals the end of confinement. Counts of vortex density and cluster sizes back the picture, and the team pins the second transition at 321 mega-electron-volts, give or take six. Hot quark matter, it seems, passes through two distinct stages as it cools.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Derek Leinweber |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 24 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-08131
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Centre vortices in thermal lattice QCD with dynamical fermions Derek Leinweber Abstract Evidence for a second finite-temperature transition in Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD) is revealed through the study of centre vortex geometry and its temperature-dependent evolution. Using the anisotropic dynamical ensembles from the Fastsum collaboration, we conduct a detailed analysis at several temperatures above and below the established chiral transition. Visualisations of the centre vortex structure in temporal and spatial lattice slices demonstrate that vortex percolation persists through the chiral transition and ceases at approximately twice the chiral transition temperature, T c T_{c} . This indicates that confinement is maintained up to T ≈ 2 T c T\approx 2T_{c} , suggesting a second transition associated with deconfinement. The loss of percolation, quantified by vortex cluster extent, provides a clear signal for this transition. Statistical analysis of vortex density and cluster extent is presented which reveals consistent evidence of two transitions in QCD: the chiral transition at T c T_{c} and the deconfinement transition at T d ≈ 2 T c T_{d}\approx 2T_{c} . By analysing these, and other quantities, we obtain a precise determination of the deconfinement temperature, T d = 321 ( 6 ) MeV T_{d}=321(6)\,\text{MeV} . [b]Chris Allton 1 Introduction QCD’s phase structure has been extensively studied using lattice simulations (see e.g. [ 1 ] ). At low temperatures, QCD is confining, while asymptotic freedom suggests deconfinement at high temperatures. Early quenched simulations confirmed a first-order phase transition at T_{\text{quenched}}\simeq 290 MeV. However, with dynamical quarks, this transition becomes a crossover at the physical light quark masses, with T_{\text{c}}^{\text{phys}}\simeq 158 MeV, marking a chiral symmetry transition. Conventionally, this crossover transition in the dynamical theory is considered to be the continuation of the quenched transition. Centre vortices have long been used as a tool to understand the QCD confinement mechanism from an intuitive perspective [ 2 ] . It is therefore natural to investigate the evolution of centre vortex structure through the chiral transition and beyond. In these proceedings, based on Ref. [ 3 ] , we use 2+1 flavour anisotropic Fastsum lattice ensembles, with light quarks corresponding to m_{\pi}=239(1) MeV, and temperatures ranging from 47 to 760 MeV. The chiral crossover transition temperature for these ensembles is T_{c}=167(3) MeV [ 4 , 5 ] . We gauge fix in a two-step procedure to the Maximal Centre Gauge and study the resultant centre vortex clusters. By studying the vortex density and cluster extent we see clear evidence of confinement persisting through T_{c} and a second QCD transition at T\approx 2T_{c} which has deconfining properties. Indeed, there is some evidence suggesting that hadrons remain bound beyond T_{c} . By studying several other quantities, as outlined in detail in Ref. [ 3 ] , we determine a value of T_{d}=321(6) MeV. 2 Two transition temperatures in the literature Recent lattice QCD calculations with dynamical fermions have suggested hints of a second phase transition around T/T_{c}\approx 2 , though its existence and location remains uncertain, with estimates varying between 200 and 500 MeV. While it seems established that T_{c} is a chiral transition, there are some papers, summarised below, which postulate the presence of a second transition corresponding to a deconfinement temperature. This directly contradicts the widely-held picture that chiral symmetry restoration goes hand-in-hand with deconfinement. Monopole condensation studies in N_{f}=2+1 QCD suggest a deconfinement phase, T_{BEC} , at T\sim 275 MeV [ 6 ] , aligning with pure gauge SU(2) and SU(3) results [ 7 , 8 ] . Chiral-spin symmetry studies [ 9 , 10 , 11 , 12 ] propose bound quark states above T_{c} , with distinct meson multiplets forming due to chromoelectric interactions. Defining the onset of these symmetries remains challenging due to their approximate nature. Topological studies [ 13 , 14 , 15 , 16 ] , examining Polyakov loop observables and the topological charge, suggest a “Partial Deconfinement" phase from approximately 0.9T_{c} to 1.9T_{c} , with notable changes around 300 MeV. Axion-motivated research links topological susceptibility changes to a dilute-instanton gas at T\gtrsim 250 MeV, consistent with quenched studies. Scale invariance studies [ 17 ] further propose a new thermal QCD phase, observing spectral density shifts in the overlap Dirac operator from 200 to 250 MeV. While this summary indicates a clear groundswell of work proposing a second transition temperature, none of these papers are able to provide a precise a value for this transition temperature. 3 Lattice setup N_{\tau} 128 64 56 48 40 36 32 28 24 20 16 12 8 T\! (MeV) 47 95 109 127 152 169 190 217 253 304 380 507 760 T/T_{c} 0.28 0.57 0.65 0.76 0.91 1.01 1.14 1.30 1.52 1.82 2.28 3.03 4.55 Table 1: Temporal extent N_{\tau} and temperatures T in MeV and in units of the chiral crossover temperature T_{c} for the Fastsum Generation 2L ensembles, used in this study [ 5 ] . This study utilizes the “Generation 2L” thermal ensembles of the Fastsum collaboration [ 5 ] , which employ 2+1 flavours of \mathcal{O}(a) -improved Wilson fermions on anisotropic lattices with a renormalized anisotropy of \xi=a_{s}/a_{\tau}=3.453(6) , where a_{s(\tau)} is the spatial (temporal) lattice spacing, and a_{s}=0.11208(31) fm [ 18 ] . The analysis is based on the “Generation 2L” ensembles with a pion mass of m_{\pi}=239(1) MeV. The strange quark mass is tuned to its physical value. The lattice action follows that of the Hadron Spectrum Collaboration [ 19 ] , incorporating a Symanzik-improved gauge action with mean-field-improved coefficients and a mean-field-improved Wilson-clover fermion action with stout-smeared spatial links. Full details of our lattice action can be found in Ref. [ 19 ] . The ensembles were generated using Openqcd-Fastsum [ 20 ] , an extension of openQCD-1.6 . A fixed-scale approach is used, where the cut-off a_{\tau} is held fixed and the temperature is varied by changing N_{\tau} according to T=\frac{1}{a_{\tau}N_{\tau}} . The study includes five ensembles below the chiral crossover transition temperature T_{c}=167(3) MeV, one near T_{c} , and seven above it. This broad temperature range is essential for the analysis. Details of the temperature values and temporal extent, N_{\tau} , studied are in Table 1 . All of these temperatures used spatial volumes of N_{s}=32^{3} but some temperatures used 48^{3} as well, as described in Section 5.3 . 100 configurations were used for each temperature studied. 4 Centre Vortices Centre vortices are topological objects in lattice QCD and they have been used for a long time to explain the mechanism of confinement [ 2 ] . Full details of our procedure to determine centre vortices are detailed in Ref. [ 3 ] , but we summarise our approach here. The key concept is the centre element of the SU(3) gauge group, z\in\mathbb{Z}_{3} , where \mathbb{Z}_{3}=\left\{\exp\left(\frac{2\pi i}{3}\,m\right)\mathbb{I}\;\middle|\;m=-1,0,1\right\}\,, are the cube roots of unity. Centre elements commute with all elements of the SU(3) group, and this gives them a priviledged position. We first fix the gauge to the “Maximal Centre Gauge” (MCG) by bringing each link as close as possible to one of the three centre elements. A two-step procedure is utilised, first gauge fixing isotropically to ensure spatial links are optimised and then anisotropically including the required square of the anisotropy ratio factor to weight time