Sculpting the outer edge of accretion disks in pre-circumbinary binary black hole systems

Fabien Casse, Peggy Varniere, Léna Arthur, Fabrice Dodu · 2025

Read Sculpting the outer edge of accretion disks in pre-circumbinary binary black hole systems by Fabien Casse, Peggy Varniere, Léna Arthur, Fabrice Dodu (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-07880.txt.

Introduction

Fabien Casse and co-authors simulate the years before two black holes merge, when one still owns a private disk of gas. Mergers are now heard through gravitational waves, and much work studies the shared disk of the final act. The earlier configuration, a secondary black hole orbiting outside the primary's accretion disk, was largely unexplored. Their 2025 paper runs two-dimensional fluid simulations of that arrangement, with both holes' gravity fully counted.

Three effects stand out. The disk's outer edge is cut back hard, and how far it reaches, relative to the pair's separation, depends only on the two holes' mass ratio. Two spiral arms wind through the disk's gas. And the trimmed edge takes an elliptical shape set mainly by that same mass ratio. The authors give observers a set of fingerprints: a disk shaped this way betrays the companion waiting outside it.

Catalog record

CREATORFabien Casse, Peggy Varniere, Léna Arthur, Fabrice Dodu
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE50 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-07880

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Sculpting the outer edge of accretion disks in pre-circumbinary binary black hole systems Fabien Casse, Peggy Varniere, Léna Arthur, Fabrice Dodu Abstract Context. Binary black hole systems (BBHs) have become a vivid reality in astrophysics as stellar-mass black hole mergers are now detected through their related gravitational wave emission during the merger stage. If many studies were recently dedicated to the last stages of BBH where black holes are surrounded by a circumbinary disk (CBD), the structure of these systems prior to the formation of the CBD remains mostly unexplored. Aims. The aim of the present article is to investigate the potential modifications induced by the presence of a secondary black hole onto the structure of the accretion disk surrounding the primary black hole. Identifying potential specific features of the accretion flow in pre-circumbinary BBH may help us to identify such systems through their electromagnetic emission. Methods. We performed 2D classical hydrodynamical simulations of an accretion disk surrounding the primary black hole while taking into account all gravitational effects induced by both the primary black hole and the secondary black hole orbiting on circular orbits around the center of mass of the system. Results. We report three main effects of the presence of a secondary black hole orbiting a circular orbit beyond the outer edge of the accretion disk: 1/ the outer radius of the accretion disk is significantly reduced and its ratio to the black hole separation is directly linked to only the mass ratio of the black holes; 2/ two spiral arms are visible in the gas density structure of the disk and 3/ the outer edge of the accretion disk exhibits an elliptical shape that mainly depends on the mass ratio of the black holes. Conclusions. Our results show that an accretion disk orbiting a primary black hole in a pre-CBD BBH exhibits specific features induced by the gravitational force generated by the presence of a secondary black hole beyond its outer edge. Such features, directly linked to the binary separation and mass ratio, has therefore the potential to help in the search and identification of BBH in the pre-CBD stage. 1 Introduction For more than three decades, binary black holes have remained a conjecture in astrophysics when considering colliding galaxies hosting supermassive black holes ( Begelman et al., 1980 ) . In that context, supermassive black holes are expected to bind gravitationally and to progressively get closer until they merge. Over time, numerous studies have been performed in order to understand what are the physical processes that can preside such in-spiral motion. For orbital separation beyond the parsec scale the dynamical friction of black holes with the galactic gaseous environment seems to be the leading process ( Mayer et al., 2007 ) . At orbital separation below 10^{-2} pc, gravitational wave emission is expected to be the key phenomenon driving the in-spiral motion until the fusion of the two compact objects. Between these two separation scales no clear consensus has emerged identifying the mechanism driving the in-spiral motion - the ‘final parsec problem’- as three-body stellar interaction (see e.g. Preto et al. 2011 ) or disk gas interaction (e.g. Armitage & Natarajan 2002 ; Cuadra et al. 2009 ) are candidates for this role. Since the first detection of gravitational waves emitted by the fusion of a stellar binary black hole ( Abbott et al., 2016 ) , the binary black hole conjecture has become a vivid reality in the astrophysical community. Such discovery has enhanced the relevance of numerical studies devoted to the structure of the binary system, including the interaction between the two compact objects and the circumbinary disk (CBD) surrounding them ( MacFadyen & Milosavljević, 2008 ; Ragusa et al., 2016 ; Muñoz et al., 2020 ; Siwek et al., 2023 ; Franchini et al., 2023 ) , the impact of the binary gravitational field upon the CBD ( Noble et al., 2012 ; Zilhão et al., 2015 ; Noble et al., 2021 ; Mignon-Risse et al., 2023a ) , the presence of individual accretion structures around each black hole (also dubbed as ’mini-disks’) ( Pihajoki et al., 2018 ; Ingram et al., 2021 ; Davelaar & Haiman, 2022 ) or the existence of the so-called ’lump’ structure at the inner edge of the CBD ( Shi et al., 2012 ; Noble et al., 2012 ; D’Orazio et al., 2013 ; Mignon-Risse et al., 2023b ) . Understanding the dynamical structure of the gas orbiting within the complex gravitational field generated by the binary black hole is likely to be a key to discriminate between single black holes and pre-merger binary black holes through the electromagnetic output of the system. So far the characterisation of electromagnetic signatures of binary black hole systems have been performed in the framework of black hole orbital separation up to a few hundreds of gravitational radii (see e.g. Tanaka et al. 2012 ; Tang et al. 2018 ; d’Ascoli et al. 2018 ; Combi et al. 2022 ; Krauth et al. 2024 ; Cocchiararo et al. 2024 ) and suggest that electromagnetic binary black hole signature should be detectable for most of the mass ratio of the binary black-holes provided the redshift of these systems remains relatively small. It is noteworthy that all the aforementioned studies have been performed assuming ad-hoc initial conditions that are not originating from simulations devoted to earlier phases of the binary (see e.g. Lai & Muñoz 2023 for a review on general binaries and Duffell et al. 2024 for a review on numerical simulations devoted to supermassive BBH). In particular it is still unclear how the CBD forms around the binary black holes thus leading to uncertainties regarding initial conditions used in fluid simulations and the derived electromagnetic emission of the binary in the CBD stage. Simulations of the early phase of the binary, namely before the formation of the CBD, are then required in order to bridge the gap between the very early stage (’pre-CBD’) and the CBD stage of the binary system. The transition between these two stages of BBH systems is not yet clearly identified in terms of black hole separation. However since no active galactic nuclei (AGN) do exhibit accretion disks whose outer radii are larger a few thousands of gravitational radii of the central black hole (see e.g. Jha et al., 2022 , and references therein) it is likely that CBDs do not stretch to more than a few thousands gravitational radii. As such, the separation between the two black holes in the CBD stage is likely to be of the order of, at most, a few hundreds of gravitational radii. Regarding pre-CBD BBH, the separation between the two black holes can be quite large and even larger than the typical size of AGN disks so one can assume that, in the pre-CBD stage, one or even two of the black holes are still surrounded by their own ’primordial’ accretion disks. Pre-CBD BBH are exhibiting gravitational fields that are quite similar to other binary systems such as binary stars or star-planet systems. In a classical gravitational context, numerous authors have already investigated the impact of the presence of a bound gravitational disruptor upon the accretion disk surrounding a

Read the complete text