Homogeneous nucleation rate of carbon dioxide hydrate formation under experimental condition from Seeding simulations
I. M. Zerón, J. Algaba, J. M. Míguez, J. Grabowska, S. Blazquez, E. Sanz, C. Vega, F. J. Blas ∗ · 2025
Read Homogeneous nucleation rate of carbon dioxide hydrate formation under experimental condition from Seeding simulations by I. M. Zerón, J. Algaba, J. M. Míguez, J. Grabowska, S. Blazquez, E. Sanz, C. Vega, F. J. Blas ∗ (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-07492.txt.
Introduction
An eight-author team maps how fast carbon dioxide hydrates form from cold gas-water mixes in 2025. Computer runs at 400 bar track ice-like cages of water around the gas at set heats and gas loads. Deep chill runs grew cages on their own, while seeded runs filled mild spots.
One seed run gave a growth rate far above the methane case at like chill, tied to a weaker cage-water skin cost. The team pairs that cost with a rate curve for full gas loads. Plain growth cannot fire below 20 degrees of chill, so real starts need a surface.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | I. M. Zerón, J. Algaba, J. M. Míguez, J. Grabowska, S. Blazquez, E. Sanz, C. Vega, F. J. Blas ∗ |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 93 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-07492
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Homogeneous nucleation rate of carbon dioxide hydrate formation under experimental condition from Seeding simulations I. M. Zerón, J. Algaba, J. M. Míguez, J. Grabowska, S. Blazquez, E. Sanz, C. Vega, F. J. Blas ∗ Abstract We investigate the nucleation of carbon dioxide (CO 2 ) hydrates from carbon dioxide aqueous solutions by means of molecular dynamics simulations using the TIP4P/Ice and the TraPPE models for water and CO 2 respectively. We work at 400 bar and different temperatures and CO 2 concentrations. We use brute force molecular dynamics when the supersaturation or the supercooling are so high so that nucleation occurs spontaneously and Seeding otherwise. We used both methods for a particular state and found an excellent agreement when using a linear combination of q ¯ 3 \overline{q}_{3} and q ¯ 12 \overline{q}_{12} order parameters to identify critical clusters. With such order parameter we get a rate of 10 m − 3 25 s − 1 {}^{25}\,\text{m}^{-3}\text{s}^{-1} for nucleation in a CO 2 saturated solution at 255 K 255\,\text{K} ( 35 K 35\,\text{K} of supercooling). By comparison with our previous work on methane hydrates, we conclude that nucleation of CO 2 hydrates is several orders of magnitude faster due to a lower interfacial free energy between the crystal and the solution. By combining our nucleation studies with a recent calculation of the hydrate-solution interfacial free energy at coexistence [Algaba et al. , J. Colloid Interface Sci. 623 , 354–367 (2022)], we obtain a prediction of the nucleation rate temperature dependence for CO 2 -saturated solutions (the experimentally relevant concentration). On the one hand, we open the window for comparison with experiments for supercooling larger than 25 K 25\,\text{K} . On the other hand, we conclude that homogeneous nucleation is impossible for supercooling lower than 20 K 20\,\text{K} . Therefore, nucleation must be heterogeneous in typical experiments where hydrate formation is observed at low supercooling. To assess the hypothesis that nucleation occurs at the solution-CO 2 interface we run spontaneous nucleation simulations in two-phase systems and find, by comparison with single-phase simulations, that the interface does not affect hydrate nucleation, at least at the deep supercooling at which this study was carried out ( 40 40 and 45 K 45\,\text{K} ). Overall, our work sheds light on molecular and thermodynamic aspects of hydrate nucleation. Preprint: AIP/123-QED ∗ Corresponding author: [email protected] I Introduction When a liquid is cooled below the solid-liquid coexistence temperature, the crystallization is not an immediate process and the liquid can remain in a metastable supercooled state for some time. Fluctuations still exist and the formation of small embryos of the stable crystal phase can be observed. When these fluctuations lead to the formation of a solid cluster that surpasses a critical size then crystallization cannot be avoided. This mechanism is usually known as homogeneous nucleation. In the proximity of the equilibrium freezing temperature, the critical cluster size is quite large and the liquid phase can remain stable for quite a long time. The presence of solid impurities reduces the size of the critical cluster and makes nucleation easier, leading to heterogeneous nucleation that can be observed easily even for temperatures moderately below the freezing temperature. [ 1 ] An interesting observable is the nucleation rate J defined as the number of critical clusters per unit of time and volume. The nucleation rate can be determined in experiments, mainly for ice in supercooled water [ 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 ] but only (due to limitations in system size and accessible time) when its value is smaller than 10^{16}/(\text{m}^{3}\,\text{s}) . In simulations, the nucleation rate can be determined in brute force (BF) simulations only when its value is of the order of 10^{30}/(\text{m}^{3}\,\text{s}) or higher (due to limitations in system size and accessible time). Thus, there is a range of nucleation rates between 10^{16}-10^{30}/(\text{m}^{3}\,\text{s}) that cannot be accessed either by experiments or by BF simulations. However, the use of special rare event technique simulations allows to determine the nucleation rate in this intermediate regime or even for temperatures accessible in experiments. Several techniques have been proposed to obtain nucleation rates in simulations when BF simulations are not sufficient. Two of them: Umbrella Sampling [ 12 ] (US) and Metadynamics [ 13 ] are aimed at determining the free energy barrier for nucleation and the nucleation rate using the formalism proposed by Volmer and Weber [ 14 ] and Becker and Döring. [ 15 ] About 25 years ago Bolhuis and coworkers proposed a methodology, the Transition Path Sampling (TPS), [ 16 ] where an analysis of the trajectories that are reactive (i.e., leading from the metastable phase to the stable phase) is performed, allowing the determination of nucleation rates. About twenty years ago another method, the Forward Flux Sampling (FFS), [ 17 , 18 ] was proposed to analyze the fraction of successful trajectories leading from one value of the order parameter to the next and the flux to the initial lowest order value of the order parameter considered. The nucleation rates obtained by these four methods (Umbrella Sampling, Metadynamics, Transition Path Sampling, and Forward Flux Sampling) are in principle exact (or almost exact) for the considered potential model. More recently some of us [ 19 ] and independently Knott et al . [ 20 ] introduced a new approximate technique to determine nucleation rates known as Seeding. In this technique, a solid cluster is inserted into a metastable fluid and the conditions at which this cluster is critical (i.e., with 50% probability of evolving to either phase) are determined. This followed the first ideas about using seeds for nucleation studies introduced by Bai and Li. [ 21 , 22 ] Once the size of the critical cluster is determined then the expression of the Classical Nucleation Theory (CNT) is used to estimate the nucleation rate. The main disadvantage of Seeding is that it is an approximate technique as the results depend on the choice of the order parameter. However, its main advantage is its simplicity thus, allowing to study really complex systems for which more rigorous methods are too expensive from a computational point of view. It has been shown, that with appropriate order parameters, Seeding correctly predicts the nucleation rates of hard spheres, Lennard-Jones systems, [ 23 ] electrolytes [ 24 ] or even the nucleation of ice both from pure water and from aqueous electrolyte solutions. [ 25 , 26 ] Recently we have shown that it can also predict the nucleation rate of hydrate formation for the methane hydrate. [ 27 ] Hydrates are non-stoichiometric solids formed when a gas (typically methane or carbon dioxide) is in contact with water under moderate pressure (i.e., 30-1000\,\text{bar} ) and the system is cooled. In the most common hydrate structure (sI) the unit cell has cubic symmetry and contains 46 molecules of water and 8 molecules of guest (occupying two types of cavities, six large and two somewhat smaller). [ 28 , 29 , 30 ] Methane hydrates can be found naturally on the seafloor near the coasts and it is also formed in the pipes transporting natural