Scenarios for magnetic X-point collapse in 2D incompressible dissipationless extended magnetohydrodynamics

Alain J. Brizard · 2025

Read Scenarios for magnetic X-point collapse in 2D incompressible dissipationless extended magnetohydrodynamics by Alain J. Brizard (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-07311.txt.

Introduction

Alain Brizard solves a set of paths by which a magnetic X-point can collapse in a refined plasma model, in a 2025 paper. The model, extended magnetohydrodynamics, keeps effects that simpler versions drop, including the inertia of electrons. In two dimensions it binds the flow field and the magnetic field into one system. That system can blow up in finite time at an X-point, where field lines cross and snap.

Brizard shrinks the four fields onto a self-similar frame, so the whole problem falls to five coupled rate equations. Those he solves in closed form with elliptic functions, sorting the paths by how a particle would move in a four-power well. The closed forms match direct computer runs closely, down to the very time the X-point gives way. The author offers the paths as exact benchmarks for collapse physics.

Catalog record

CREATORAlain J. Brizard
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE100 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-07311

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Scenarios for magnetic X-point collapse in 2D incompressible dissipationless extended magnetohydrodynamics Alain J. Brizard Abstract The equations of 2D incompressible dissipationless extended magnetohydrodynamics (XMHD) extend the equations of incompressible Hall MHD (HMHD) by retaining finite-electron inertia. These XMHD equations couple the fluid velocity 𝐕 = 𝗓 ^ × ∇ ϕ + V z ​ 𝗓 ^ {\bf V}=\widehat{\sf z}\,\mbox{\boldmath$\times$}\,\nabla\phi+V_{z}\,\widehat{\sf z} with the magnetic field 𝐁 = ∇ ψ × 𝗓 ^ + B z 𝗓 ^ {\bf B}=\nabla\psi\,\mbox{\boldmath$\times$}\,\widehat{\sf z}+B_{z}\,\widehat{\sf z} in a process that is known to support dissipationless solutions that exhibit finite-time singularities associated with magnetic X-point collapse in the magnetic plane ( B x = ∂ ψ / ∂ y , B y = − ∂ ψ / ∂ x ) (B_{x}=\partial\psi/\partial y,B_{y}=-\,\partial\psi/\partial x) . Here, by adopting a 2D self-similar model for the four XMHD fields ( ϕ , ψ , V z , B z ) (\phi,\psi,V_{z},B_{z}) , we obtain five coupled ordinary differential equations that are solved in terms of the Jacobi elliptic functions based on an orbital classification associated with particle motion in a quartic potential. Excellent agreement is found when these analytical solutions are compared with numerical solutions, including the precise time of a magnetic X-point collapse. I Introduction The problem of the dissipationless collapse of a magnetic X-point [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 ] is a paradigm problem in plasma physics that requires an extended formulation beyond ideal magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) [ 5 , 6 ] , where two-fluid effects (e.g., the Hall term and finite electron inertia) are retained. These dissipationless extended MHD (XMHD) equations [ 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 ] are parametrized by the plasma dimensionless parameters {\sf d}_{i}=c/(\omega_{\rm pi}L) and {\sf d}_{e}\equiv\sqrt{\delta}\,{\sf d}_{i} , which denote the ion and electron skin depths (with a finite electron-ion mass ratio \delta\equiv m_{e}/m_{i}\ll 1 ) normalized to a characteristic length scale L . We note, on the one hand, that the dissipationless XMHD equations include the dissipationless Hall MHD (HMHD) equations [ 11 ] ( {\sf d}_{i}\neq 0 and {\sf d}_{e}=0 ) and the dissipationless inertial MHD equations [ 7 ] ( {\sf d}_{i}=0 and {\sf d}_{e}\neq 0 ), and these dissipationless reduced MHD equations possess solutions that exhibit magnetic X-point collapse singularities that occur in a finite time [ 12 , 13 , 14 , 15 , 19 , 20 , 16 , 17 , 18 ] . We note that the equations of ideal MHD [ 21 , 22 ] ( {\sf d}_{i}=0={\sf d}_{e} ), on the other hand, cannot break the magnetic topology needed for a dissipationless magnetic X-point collapse. I.1 Incompressible dissipationless extended MHD equations The extended MHD study of the dissipationless collapse of a magnetic X-point is based on the following coupled incompressible fluid equations (normalized to standard Alfvénic units) [ 10 ] : the fluid momentum equation \frac{\partial\bf V}{\partial t}+{\bf V}\,\mbox{\boldmath$\cdot$}\,\nabla{\bf V}\;=\;-\,\nabla P\;+\;{\bf J}\,\mbox{\boldmath$\times$}\,{\bf B}\;-\;{\sf d}_{e}^{2}\;{\bf J}\,\mbox{\boldmath$\cdot$}\,\nabla{\bf J}, (1) where {\bf V} denotes the normalized center-of-mass fluid velocity, the normalized fluid mass density \varrho=1 has been set to unity (so that the fluid continuity equation yields the incompressibility condition \nabla\,\mbox{\boldmath$\cdot$}\,{\bf V}\equiv 0 ), P denotes the normalized total fluid pressure, and {\bf J}\equiv\nabla\,\mbox{\boldmath$\times$}\,{\bf B} denotes the normalized Ampère current density obtained from the normalized magnetic field {\bf B}\equiv\nabla\,\mbox{\boldmath$\times$}\,{\bf A} ; the generalized Ohm’s law {\bf E}+{\bf V}\,\mbox{\boldmath$\times$}\,{\bf B}\;=\;{\sf d}_{i}\left({\bf J}\,\mbox{\boldmath$\times$}\,{\bf B}-\nabla P_{e}\right)\;+\;{\sf d}_{e}^{2}\left(\frac{\partial\bf J}{\partial t}+{\bf V}\,\mbox{\boldmath$\cdot$}\,\nabla{\bf J}+{\bf J}\,\mbox{\boldmath$\cdot$}\,\nabla{\bf V}\right)\;-\;{\sf d}_{i}{\sf d}_{e}^{2}\,{\bf J}\,\mbox{\boldmath$\cdot$}\,\nabla{\bf J}, (2) where {\bf E}\equiv-\,\nabla\phi-\partial{\bf A}/\partial t denotes the normalized electric field and P_{e} denotes the normalized electron pressure; and Faraday’s law \frac{\partial\bf B}{\partial t}\;=\;-\;\nabla\,\mbox{\boldmath$\times$}\,{\bf E}, (3) which is subject to the condition \nabla\,\mbox{\boldmath$\cdot$}\,{\bf B}\equiv 0 . Here, terms that involve {\sf d}_{i}\neq 0 represent Hall corrections while terms that involve {\sf d}_{e}\equiv\sqrt{\delta}\,{\sf d}_{i}\neq 0 represent finite electron-inertia corrections. While the nature of three-dimensional (3D) magnetic reconnection can be very different from two-dimensional (2D) magnetic reconnection [ 2 , 4 ] , we focus our attention on 2D dissipationless magnetic reconnection [ 23 , 24 ] in the present paper because of its simplicity and its relevance in many physical situations. Here, we assume that the fields are independent of the z -coordinate, so that the incompressible fluid velocity {\bf V}=\widehat{\sf z}\,\mbox{\boldmath$\times$}\,\nabla\phi+V_{z}\,\widehat{\sf z} and the magnetic field {\bf B}=\nabla\psi\,\mbox{\boldmath$\times$}\,\widehat{\sf z}+B_{z}\,\widehat{\sf z} are now defined in terms of the 2D four fields (\phi,V_{z},\psi,B_{z}) , where {\bf A}\equiv\psi\,\widehat{\sf z}+{\bf A}_{\bot} , B_{z}\equiv\widehat{\sf z}\,\mbox{\boldmath$\cdot$}\,\nabla\,\mbox{\boldmath$\times$}\,{\bf A}_{\bot} , and {\bf J}=-\,\nabla^{2}\psi\,\widehat{\sf z}+\nabla B_{z}\,\mbox{\boldmath$\times$}\,\widehat{\sf z} . The evolution equations for the four XMHD fields (\phi,V_{z},\psi,B_{z}) are extracted from Eqs. ( 1 )-( 3 ) as follows [ 10 ] . First, we take the z -component of the momentum equation ( 1 ) to obtain \frac{dV_{z}}{dt}\;\equiv\;\frac{\partial V_{z}}{\partial t}+\left[\phi,\;V_{z}\right]\;=\;\left[B_{z},\;\psi^{*}\right], (4) where the antisymmetric spatial bracket [f,\;g]\equiv\widehat{\sf z}\,\mbox{\boldmath$\cdot$}\,\nabla f\,\mbox{\boldmath$\times$}\,\nabla g is expressed in terms of normalized spatial coordinates (x,y) , and \psi^{*}\equiv\psi-{\sf d}_{e}^{2}\nabla^{2}\psi includes a finite electron-inertia correction [ 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 ] . Second, we take the curl of the momentum equation ( 1 ), which yields the vorticity equation for \widehat{\sf z}\,\mbox{\boldmath$\cdot$}\,\nabla\,\mbox{\boldmath$\times$}\,{\bf V}=\nabla^{2}\phi : \frac{d\nabla^{2}\phi}{dt}\;\equiv\;\frac{\partial\nabla^{2}\phi}{\partial t}+\left[\phi,\;\nabla^{2}\phi\right]\;=\;\left[\psi,\;\nabla^{2}\psi\right]\;-\;{\sf d}_{e}^{2}\,\left[B_{z},\;\nabla^{2}B_{z}\right], (5) Third, we take the z -component of the generalized Ohm’s Law ( 2 ), which yields \frac{d\psi^{*}}{dt}\;\equiv\;\frac{\partial\psi^{*}}{\partial t}+\left[\phi,\;\psi^{*}\right]\;=\;-\,{\sf d}_{i}\,\left[B_{z},\;\psi^{*}\right]\;+\;{\sf d}_{e}^{2}\,\left[B_{z},\;V_{z}\right], (6) while, fourth, the z -component of Faraday’s Law ( 3 ) yields \frac{dB_{z}^{*}}{dt}\;\equiv\;\frac{\partial B_{z}^{*}}{\partial t}+\left[\phi,\;B_{z}^{*}\right]\;=\;{\sf d}_{i}\,\left[\nabla^{2}\psi,\;\psi\right]\;+\;\left[V_{z},\;\psi\right]\;+\;{\sf d}_{e}^{2}\,\left(\left[B_{z},\;\nabla^{2}\phi\right]\;+\frac{}{}{\sf d}_{i}\,\left[B_{z},\;\nabla^{2}B_{z}\right]\right), (7) where B_{z}^{*}\equiv B_{z}-{\sf d}_{e}^{2}\nabla^{2}B_{z} includes finite electron-inertia correction [ 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 ] . We note that Eqs. ( 4 )-( 7 ) may be combined in terms of the two coupled equations \displaystyle\frac{d}{dt}\left({\sf d}_{i}V_{z}\;+\frac{}{}\psi^{*}\right) \displaystyle= \displaystyle{\sf d}_{e}^{2}\,[B_{z},\;V_{z}], (8) \displaystyle\frac{d}{dt}\left(B_{z}^{*}\;+\frac{}{}{\sf d}_{i}\,\nabla^{2}\phi\right) \displaystyle= \displaystyle[V_{z},\;\psi]\;+\;{\sf d}_{e}^{2}\,[B_{z},\;\nabla^{2}\phi], (9) which consider the time evolutions of the z -component of the canonical momentum \widehat{\sf z}\,\mbox{\boldmath$\cdot$}\,{\bf P}^{*}\;=\;\widehat{\sf z}\,\mbox{\boldmath$\cdot$}\,\left({\sf d}_{i}\,{\bf V}+{\bf A}^{*}\right)={\sf d}_{i}V_{z}+\psi^{*} and its parallel vorticity \widehat{\sf z}\,\mbox{\boldmath$\cdot$}\,\nabla\,\mbox{\boldmath$\times$}\,{\bf P}^{*}\;=\;{\sf d}_{i}\,\nabla^{2}\phi+B_{z}^{*} . The Hamiltonian properties of the 2D XMHD equations ( 4 )-( 7 ), including the associated Casimir invariants, have been studied extensively elsewhere [ 7 , 6 ] . Here, we point out that, according to dissipationless Hall MHD ( {\sf d}_{e}=0 ), we obtain the conservation law \frac{d}{dt}\left({\sf d}_{i}\,V_{z}\;+\frac{}{}\psi\right)\;=\;0 (10) from Eq. ( 8 ), which breaks the ideal MHD ( {\sf d}_{i}=0 ) frozen-flux condition \widehat{\sf z}\,\mbox{\boldmath$\cdot$}\,({\bf E}+{\bf V}\,\mbox{\boldmath$\times$}\,{\bf B})=-\,d\psi/dt=0 and allows a change in magnetic topology in the (x,y) -plane. Lastly, we note that, without the axial fields V_{z}=0=B_{z} , which bypasses the Hall term in Eq. ( 6 ), the two-field dissipationless equations d\nabla^{2}\phi/dt=[\psi,\;\nabla^{2}\psi] and d\psi^{*}/dt=0 can also be used to study collisionless magnetic reconnection [ 12 , 25 ] . Other dissipationless two-field extended MHD models used to study dissipationless 2D magnetic reconnection (where the magnetic field {\bf B}=B_{0}\,\widehat{\sf z}+\nabla\psi\,\mbox{\boldmath$\times$}\,\widehat{z} includes a constant guide field B_{0} ) have appeared in the literature [ 26 , 27 , 28 ] , where a new dimensionless parameter {\sf d}_{s}=(c_{s}/\omega_{ci})/L\equiv\sqrt{\beta_{e}}\,{\sf d}_{i} , which is defined as the normalized ratio of the ion sound speed c_{s} to the ion cyclotron frequency \omega_{ci} , is introduced (associated with the inclusion of parallel electron compressibility, with \beta_{e}=4\pi\,n_{0}T_{e}/B_{0}^{2} ), so that we obtain a new set of two-field equations become d\nabla^{2}\phi/dt=[\psi,\;\nabla^{2}\psi] and d\psi^{*}/dt={\sf d}_{s}^{2}\,[\nabla^{2}\phi,\;\psi] . We note that these equations can be combined into the coupled

Read the complete text