Prospects for detecting new dark physics with the next generation of atomic clocks

Benjamin Elder, Giorgio Mentasti, Elizabeth Pasatembou, Charles F. A. Baynham, Oliver Buchmueller, Carlo R. Contaldi, Claudia de Rham, Richard Hobson, Andrew J. Tolley · 2025

Read Prospects for detecting new dark physics with the next generation of atomic clocks by Benjamin Elder, Giorgio Mentasti, Elizabeth Pasatembou, Charles F. A. Baynham, Oliver Buchmueller, Carlo R. Contaldi, Claudia de Rham, Richard Hobson, Andrew J. Tolley (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-07179.txt.

Introduction

Benjamin Elder, Giorgio Mentasti, Elizabeth Pasatembou and colleagues ask what the next generation of atomic clocks could reveal about dark physics in 2025. Many theories beyond the Standard Model predict tiny drifts in particle mass ratios, which precision clock comparisons can detect.

The team first searched published clock data for changes in the electron-proton mass ratio. They then modelled the noise of realistic near-future clock pairs and translated their sensitivity into projected bounds on theories tied to dark matter, dark energy and unification. The forecast promises much tighter limits within a few years, and the authors package their code as a tool that turns clock specifications into physics bounds.

Catalog record

CREATORBenjamin Elder, Giorgio Mentasti, Elizabeth Pasatembou, Charles F. A. Baynham, Oliver Buchmueller, Carlo R. Contaldi, Claudia de Rham, Richard Hobson, Andrew J. Tolley
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE109 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-07179

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Prospects for detecting new dark physics with the next generation of atomic clocks Benjamin Elder, Giorgio Mentasti, Elizabeth Pasatembou, Charles F. A. Baynham, Oliver Buchmueller, Carlo R. Contaldi, Claudia de Rham, Richard Hobson, Andrew J. Tolley Abstract Wide classes of new fundamental physics theories cause apparent variations in particle mass ratios in space and time. In theories that violate the weak equivalence principle (EP), those variations are not uniform across all particles and may be detected with atomic and molecular clock frequency comparisons. In this work we explore the potential to detect those variations with near-future clock comparisons. We begin by searching published clock data for variations in the electron-proton mass ratio. We then undertake a statistical analysis to model the noise in a variety of clock pairs that can be built in the near future according to the current state of the art, determining their sensitivity to various fundamental physics signals. Those signals are then connected to constraints on fundamental physics theories that lead directly or indirectly to an effective EP-violating, including those motivated by dark matter, dark energy, the vacuum energy problem, unification or other open questions of fundamental physics. This work results in projections for tight new bounds on fundamental physics that could be achieved with atomic and molecular clocks within the next few years. Our code for this work is packaged into a forecast tool that translates clock characteristics into bounds on fundamental physics. I Introduction The world’s most precise clock to date can reach relative uncertainties of 10^{-19} [ 1 ] , a level of precision which would lose less than a second over the age of the universe. This level of precision opens up new avenues for testing fundamental physics theories by searching for variations in Nature’s constants. In many theories beyond the Standard Model, “fundamental constants” such as the proton-to-electron mass ratio ( \mu ) and the fine structure constant ( \alpha ) are not fixed but can vary dynamically over time [ 2 , 3 , 4 ] . This behavior is exhibited in a wide variety of dark matter, dark energy, and modified gravity theories. Atomic, molecular and ion clock transition frequencies depend on those fundamental constants and are therefore sensitive to their variations [ 5 ] . By comparing the frequencies of two different atomic/molecular transitions, we obtain a unit-less observable that is sensitive to fundamental constant variations [ 6 , 7 ] ; the level of constraint produced by such a comparison depends on both the precision of the clocks involved and their intrinsic sensitivity to the fundamental constants under question [ 8 ] . Earlier studies of temporal variations of fundamental constants searched for linear drifts in the atomic clock frequency ratios between two clock species [ 9 , 6 , 8 , 10 ] . Drift rates were extracted from linear fits to the data, with \mu and \alpha dependence derived through computational calculations of atomic structure. More recently, frequency measurements of atomic clocks have also been used to search for oscillatory fundamental constant variations caused by hypothetical gravitational potential couplings to \mu and \alpha by investigating the possibility of annual sinusoidal variations caused by the varying gravitational potential as the Earth orbits the Sun. Previous studies that have searched for such variations have used neutral strontium vs. caesium-fountain [ 11 ] , hydrogen maser vs. caesium [ 12 ] , and ytterbium ion vs. caesium [ 13 ] comparisons. These studies have searched for violations of general relativistic local position invariance with no such variations observed to date, resulting in some of the strictest constraints on fundamental theories currently known. In parallel, over the past several decades, there have been enormous advancements in the development of different types of clocks, including atomic, molecular, and ion clocks. There are over 450 atomic clocks in over 80 national laboratories worldwide, contributing to International Atomic Time (TAI) alone [ 14 ] . It is estimated that there are thousands of atomic clocks worldwide in telecommunication networks, GPS satellites, and research institutions and universities. The most precise and accurate atomic clock has recently recorded a systematic uncertainty of 8\times 10^{-19} [ 1 ] . Dedicated efforts to build networks of clocks with unprecedented sensitivity to temporal variations of the fundamental constants are also ongoing [ 15 , 16 ] . The pace of progress in both theoretical fundamental physics and optical frequency metrology motivates a coordinated approach that integrates theory and experiment. The purpose of this work is threefold. First, we overview wide classes of new physics theories focusing on those with specific predictions that atomic clocks can measure. Second, we carry out a preliminary search for those signals by compiling existing publicly available data from the BIPM Circular T database [ 17 ] . Third, we introduce a tool to apply statistical methods and generate constraints based on the characteristics of the clocks in question that can be used to test the sensitivity of clocks to fundamental physics theories, specifically a wide variety of modified gravity, dark energy and dark matter theories. This tool can also be used to forecast the degree to which future atomic clock advancements can result in stronger bounds on fundamental physics, and we use it to explore several such possibilities in this work. The rest of this paper is organised as follows. Section II provides an overview of the fundamental theories that we test. Secs. III and IV present an illustrative analysis using publicly available data from optical atomic clocks to produce constraints on those theories and to provide forecasts on state-of-the-art/future clock experiments and projections for their testability with atomic clocks. Section V presents a publicly available tool that can be used to derive constraints using the characteristics of atomic clocks as input. We conclude in Sec. VI . Conventions: Throughout this work, we use natural units in which c=\hbar=1 , the mostly-plus metric convention, and we define the reduced Planck mass in the usual way as M_{\mathrm{Pl}}=(8\pi G)^{-1/2}\approx 2\times 10^{18}~\mathrm{GeV} . II Theoretical Models There is clear motivation from cosmology to introduce new physics. Despite nearly a century of effort, 95% of the matter in the universe remains unaccounted for, as does about 70% of the total energy. This energy appears to be driving the accelerated expansion of the universe, which can otherwise be produced by no particle in the Standard Model apart from quantum or classical vacuum energy which suffers the worse fine-tuning problem of particle physics. Faced with this challenge, myriad of new theories have been proposed in an attempt to explain some of the aforementioned phenomena by involving either new particles, new interactions or modifications of some of the properties of the known particles of the Standard Model or the graviton. These models generically involve new scalar (alongside potentially higher spin) fields, either as fundamental new degrees of freedom, or (more commonly) as effective or decoupled local and four-dimensional descriptions of the new effects [ 18 ] . Taking this new physics to be described by a real scalar field \phi , the lowest-order couplings to ordinary matter have an interaction Lagrangian that may be written as {\cal L}_{\mathrm{int}}\sim\frac{\phi}{M_{p}}m_{p}\bar{p}p+\frac{\phi}{M_{n}}m_{n}\bar{n}n+\frac{\phi}{M_{e}}m_{e}\bar{e}e\,. (1) Note that we have chosen to work at the

Read the complete text