Hubble tension and small-scale inhomogeneities on light propagation
L. Kraiselburd \corrauth [email protected], C. Pigozzo, S.J. Landau, J. Alcaniz · 2025
Read Hubble tension and small-scale inhomogeneities on light propagation by L. Kraiselburd \corrauth [email protected], C. Pigozzo, S.J. Landau, J. Alcaniz (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-06831.txt.
Introduction
Lucila Kraiselburd and co-authors explore whether small clumps in the universe can ease the Hubble tension in this 2025 paper. That tension is a firm gap between two ways of measuring how fast the universe expands. Early-universe data give one value, and local star ladders give a higher one. The standard math assumes light travels through smooth space. The team relaxes that assumption using an older approximation. It lets some light paths pass through emptier regions than average.
Two forms of that approximation were tested against the data. If clumpiness bends distance estimates, the local value could shift toward the early one. The authors frame this as an alternative path to closing the gap. No new particles or forces are needed under this idea. The paper is a theory test within standard cosmology tools. Its verdict rests on how well the forms fit observations.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | L. Kraiselburd \corrauth [email protected], C. Pigozzo, S.J. Landau, J. Alcaniz |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 41 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-06831
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Hubble tension and small-scale inhomogeneities on light propagation L. Kraiselburd \corrauth [email protected], C. Pigozzo, S.J. Landau, J. Alcaniz Abstract Context. A major observational challenge within the standard cosmological framework is the Hubble tension, a statistically significant ( ∼ 5 σ \sim 5\sigma ) disagreement between the Hubble constant derived from cosmic microwave background measurements and the value obtained through local distance-ladder methods based on Type Ia supernovae and Cepheid variable stars. Aims. We relax the assumption of the Friedmann-Lemaître-Robertson-Walker (FLRW) distance- redshift relation and explore theinfluence of small-scale inhomogeneities on the propagation of light from distant sources, using the Zeldovich-Kantowski-Dyer-Roeder (ZKDR) approximation as an alternative approach to address this tension. Methods. We employ two distinct formulations of the ZKDR equation to test our hypothesis using recent Type Ia supernovae datafrom the Pantheon+ compilation and the SH0ES collaboration and six gravitational lens systems from the H0LiCOW collaboration. Results. We obtained constraints on the cosmological parameters and the ZKDR model parameters within the framework of the inhomogeneous models considered. The model comparison criterion indicates that the data show weak preference of Λ \Lambda CDM over the flat ZKDR model , whereas the remaining models studied are strongly disfavored. Conclusions. Our findings indicate that a background model characterized by the ZKDR approximation and its modifications does not solve or alleviate the Hubble tension. 1 Introduction Advancements in our understanding of systematic errors, combined with the increased quantity and precision of cosmological data over the past 20 years, have resulted in a more accurate determination of cosmological parameters. Although the standard \Lambda -Cold Dark Matter ( \Lambda CDM) model can explain most current datasets, there are significant discrepancies in the values of cosmological parameters derived from different data sources within this model 1 1 1 Measurements of Baryon Acoustic Oscillations from the DESI collaboration ( Abdul Karim et al. 2025 ) , combined with data from the cosmic microwave background and Type Ia supernovae data, have challenged the \Lambda CDM paradigm indicating a potential evolution in the dark energy equation of state. These results are currently the subject of debate ( Efstathiou 2025b ) , with both parametric and non-parametric analyses yielding divergent conclusions ( Adame and others 2025 ; Dinda and Maartens 2025a ; Sousa-Neto et al. 2025 ; Lodha and others 2025 ) . . The most significant issue is known as the Hubble tension, which refers to a discrepancy between the value of the Hubble constant H_{0} obtained from Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) data within the \Lambda CDM model ( Planck Collaboration: Aghanim and et al. 2020 ) and the value derived from type Ia supernovae (SNIa) and Cepheid variables observations ( Brout et al. 2022 ; Scolnic et al. 2022 ) . Quantitatively, fitting the \Lambda CDM model to the Planck data, we find H_{0}=67.43\pm 0.49\ {\rm{kms^{-1}Mpc^{-1}}}\,. (1) In comparison, the value of the Hubble constant measured by the SH0ES collaboration based on Cepheid variables and SNIa observations is H_{0}=73.01\pm 0.99\ {\rm{kms^{-1}Mpc^{-1}}}\,, (2) which differs from ( 1 ) by more than 5\sigma . High-resolution ground-based experiments ( Aiola et al. 2020 ; Balkenhol et al. 2023 ) yield independent H_{0} estimates within the \Lambda CDM framework that are consistent with the Planck value, while JWST observations of Cepheids, the tip of the red giant branch, and carbon-rich asymptotic giant branch stars furnish ( Freedman et al. 2020 ) H_{0}=69.8\pm 1.9\ {\rm{kms^{-1}Mpc^{-1}}}\,, (3) which is \sim 1.5\sigma and \sim 1.2\sigma away from the SH0ES and CMB values, respectively (for recent reviews on the H_{0} tension, we refer the reader to Freedman (2021) ; Di Valentino et al. (2021) ; Efstathiou (2025a) ). The origin of this tension has sparked considerable debate within the cosmological community. Some analyses argue that systematic errors in the SH0ES data may not have been fully accounted for ( Efstathiou 2021 ; Freedman et al. 2025 ; Perivolaropoulos 2024 ) while others conclude that the \Lambda CDM model may be missing new physics and investigate alternative cosmological models (see e.g. Karwal and Kamionkowski (2016) ; Alcaniz et al. (2021) ; Poulin et al. (2019) ; Alcaniz et al. (2022) ; Khalife et al. (2024) ; da Costa et al. (2024) and references therein). In this paper, we take a different approach to investigate the Hubble tension and explore the global effects of small-scale inhomogeneities in light propagation, while still assuming that the universe is homogeneous and isotropic. This idea was initially explored by Zeldovich, Dashevskii, and Kantowski in their respective studies ( Zel’dovich 1964 ; Dashevskii and Zel’dovich 1965 ; Kantowski 1969 ) . It maintains the Friedmann-Lamaître-Robertson-Walker (FLRW) background geometry and expansion history but separates matter into two components: one that is smoothly distributed, accounting for a fraction \alpha of the total density, and the other, comprising 1-\alpha , which consists of clumps (for a recent review, see ( Helbig 2020 ) ). In what follows, we consider the Zeldovich-Kantowski-Dyer-Roeder (ZKDR) distance relation and a modified version of it (mZKDR) to describe the propagation of light rays 2 2 2 Most studies refer to the distance relation incorporating these concepts as the Dyer-Roeder approximation. Here, we follow Alcaniz et al. (2004) and refer to it (see Eq. 5 ) as the Zeldovich-Kantowski-Dyer-Roeder (ZKDR) distance relation to recognize the contributions of the original authors on this topic. . We examine both flat and curved universes and consider the possibility that the smoothness parameter of the mZKDR equation varies with redshift. We test these scenarios with SNIa data from the Pantheon+ compilation, as well as low-redshift SNIa data calibrated with Cepheids from the SH0ES collaboration ( Brout et al. 2022 ; Scolnic et al. 2022 ) . Additionally, we incorporate in our analyses the time delays of gravitational lenses reported by the H0LiCOW collaboration ( Wong et al. 2020 ) . It is well known that the low sample size of the H0LiCOW data set leads to weak constraints on H_{0} which also remain consistent with both CMB and SH0ES estimates. Consequently, addressing the H_{0} tension in this study requires that the H_{0} values inferred from type Ia supernovae data, using the modified Dyer-Roeder distances, be consistent with the CMB estimate. The structure of our paper is as follows: In Section 2 , we summarize the fundamental principles of the ZKDR and mZKDR equations, detailing how each framework modifies the angular diameter distance. Section 3 provides a brief overview of the data sets used in our analysis, while Section 4 presents and discusses the results of our statistical analysis. Finally, we present our main conclusions in Section 5 . 2 The ZKDR approximation We first recall the optical scalar equation in the geometric optics approximation ( Schneider et al. 1992 ) : \frac{d^{2}\sqrt{A}}{ds^{2}}+\tfrac{1}{2}R_{\alpha\beta}k^{\alpha}k^{\beta}\sqrt{A}=0\;, (4) where we neglect the optical shear. Here A refers to the beam cross section area, s is an affine parameter describing the null geodesics, k^{\alpha} is the tangent vector to the surface of propagation of the light ray and R_{\alpha\beta} is the Ricci tensor. If we assume a universe with presureless matter and a cosmological constant, in comoving and synchronous coordinates, then R_{\alpha\beta}k^{\alpha}k^{\beta}=\kappa\rho_{m}k^{0}k^{0} . As mentioned earlier, the key assumption of the ZKDR approximation is that a mass fraction \alpha of the