A new model for all C C -sequences are trivial
Assaf Rinot, Zhixing You, Jiachen Yuan · 2025
Read A new model for all C C -sequences are trivial by Assaf Rinot, Zhixing You, Jiachen Yuan (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-06794.txt.
Introduction
Assaf Rinot, Zhixing You, and Jiachen Yuan build a set-theoretic world with a surprising pair of traits. Their 2025 paper concerns C-sequences, ladders of sets assigned to ordinals, and when they can be trivialized. In the model they construct, every C-sequence is trivial, yet a certain tree still exists with full vanishing levels.
The combination answers a question posed by Lambie-Hanson and Rinot and is optimal, in that compactness and its failure coexist as strongly as possible. The construction extends Kunen's classic forcing method with a device the authors call a mutually exclusive ascent path. Such models chart the exact boundaries of what set theory can force to be true.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Assaf Rinot, Zhixing You, Jiachen Yuan |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 58 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-06794
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A new model for all C C -sequences are trivial Assaf Rinot, Zhixing You, Jiachen Yuan Abstract . We construct a model in which all C C -sequences are trivial, yet there exists a κ \kappa -Souslin tree with full vanishing levels. This answers a question from [ RYY23 ] , and provides an optimal combination of compactness and incompactness. It is obtained by incorporating a so-called mutually exclusive ascent path to Kunen’s original forcing construction. 2010 Mathematics Subject Classification Primary 03E35. Secondary 03E05, 03E55 1. introduction Motivated by a characterization of weak compactness in terms of C -sequences due to Todorčević [ Tod87 , Theorem 1.8] , Lambie-Hanson and Rinot [ LHR21 , Definition 1.6] introduced a new cardinal characteristic, the C -sequence number , to measure the compactness of a regular uncountable cardinal \kappa , where the best case \chi(\kappa)=0 amounts to saying that \kappa is weakly compact. This notion is quite useful, for example, if the C -sequence number of a strongly inaccessible \kappa is bigger than 1 (i.e., \chi(\kappa)>1 ), then the \kappa -chain condition is not infinitely productive (see [ LHR18 , Lemma 3.3] and [ LHR21 , Lemma 5.8] ), and there is a \kappa -Aronszajn tree with no ascent path of width less than \chi(\kappa) (see [ IR25 , Lemma 7.9] ). 1 1 1 Undefined terminology can be found in Section 2 . A simple way to argue that \chi(\kappa)=1 holds in a given model is to prove that the weak compactness of \kappa can be resurrected via some \kappa -cc notion of forcing. As a sole example, Kunen’s model [ Kun78 , §3] satisfies this requirement. In [ RS23 ] , Rinot and Shalev put forward the importance of the vanishing levels V(T) of a \kappa -Souslin tree T , deriving from it instances of the guessing principle \clubsuit_{\ad} and using it to solve problems in set-theoretic topology. They proved [ RS23 , Theorem 2.30] that for \kappa weakly compact, \clubsuit_{\ad} fails over every club in \kappa . In addition, if \clubsuit_{\ad} holds over a club in \kappa , then \kappa is immediately seen to be non-subtle. This raises the question of what large cardinal notions are compatible with \clubsuit_{\ad} holding over a club. The best known result in this vein is [ RYY23 , Theorem E] asserting that assuming the consistency of a weakly compact cardinal, it is consistent that for some strongly inaccessible cardinal \kappa satisfying \chi(\kappa)=\omega , \clubsuit_{\ad} holds over a club in \kappa , furthermore, there is a \kappa -Souslin tree T such that V(T)=\acc(\kappa) . Whether this result may be improved to \chi(\kappa)<\omega remained an evasive open problem. Here, this remaining case is resolved. Main Theorem . Suppose that \kappa is a weakly compact cardinal. Then there exists a forcing extension in which \kappa is strongly inaccessible, \chi(\kappa)=1 and there exists a \kappa -Souslin tree T such that V(T)=\acc(\kappa) . A natural attempt to prove the preceding is to follow Kunen’s approach, this time adding a generic \kappa -Souslin tree T such that V(T) covers a club in \kappa , hopefully arguing that the weak compactness of \kappa can be resurrected by a further \kappa -cc forcing. However, in view of the implicit requirement to kill subtle-ness, this demands adding at least \kappa^{+} -many branches through T , which has a negative effect on the chain condition of the further forcing. Instead, our approach is to produce a model admitting a family of generic elementary embeddings living in further \kappa -cc forcing extensions, as follows. We will start with \kappa a weakly compact cardinal, carry out some preparatory forcing below \kappa , and then force to add a uniformly homogeneous \kappa -Souslin subtree T of {}^{<\kappa}\kappa such that V(T) is a club in \kappa and such that T admits an \mathcal{F} -ascent path for an educated choice of a filter \mathcal{F} over \omega . Our plan is to argue that \chi(\kappa)=1 holds in the final model by showing that for every C -sequence \vec{C} over \kappa , a nontrivial elementary embedding j:M\rightarrow N between two \kappa -models with \crit(j)=\kappa and \vec{C}\in M exists in some further \kappa -cc forcing extension. In the inevitable case that our tree T belongs to M , it would admit a branch b:\kappa\rightarrow\kappa , as witnessed by any element of the \kappa^{\text{th}} -level of j(T) . Meanwhile, since V(T) covers a club, \kappa\in j(V(T))=V(j(T)) , and hence the tree j(T) would have a vanishing \kappa -branch b^{\prime}:\kappa\rightarrow\kappa . As b is non-vanishing and b^{\prime} is vanishing, the fact that T is uniformly homogeneous implies that b and b^{\prime} must disagree cofinally often. By iterating such an argument, we infer that the tree must have at least \omega -many cofinal branches that disagree with each other cofinally often. Thus, we shall need a notion of forcing that introduces such cofinal branches in a \kappa -cc fashion. This is exactly where the definition of a mutually exclusive \mathcal{F} -ascent path arises. To connect on a previous remark, instead of adding \kappa^{+} -many branches, in our approach only countably many (mutually exclusive ones) are added. 1.1. Organization of this paper In Section 2 , we provide some necessary background on trees, ascent paths and C -sequences. We motivate the new notion of a mutually exclusive \mathcal{F} -ascent path by showing that variations of Kunen’s forcing that do not make use of this kind of ascent path are not well behaved. In Section 3 , we present our main notions of forcing. Large cardinals play no role in this section, and the results are applicable as low as at \aleph_{2} . In Section 4 , we prove the main theorem by iterating the posets of Section 3 below and at a weakly compact cardinal. 2. Preliminaries 2.1. Trees and vanishing levels For simplicity, instead of working with abstract trees, we opt to work with the following more concrete implementation. A streamlined tree is a subset T\subseteq{}^{<\kappa}H_{\kappa} for some cardinal \kappa that is downward-closed, i.e., for every t\in T , \{t\mathbin{\upharpoonright}\alpha\mathrel{|}\allowbreak\alpha<\kappa\}\subseteq T . The height of a node x\in T is \dom(x) . The height of T , denoted \h(T) , is the least ordinal \beta such that T_{\beta}:=\{x\in T\mathrel{|}\allowbreak\dom(x)=\beta\} is empty. Note that for every ordinal \beta , T\mathbin{\upharpoonright}\beta:=\{x\in T\mathrel{|}\allowbreak\dom(x)<\beta\} is as well a streamlined tree. A streamlined tree T is said to be normal iff for every x\in T and every \alpha<\h(T) , there exists some y\in T_{\alpha} with either x\subseteq y or y\subseteq x . A streamlined \kappa -tree [ BR21 , Definition 2.3] is a downward-closed subset T of {}^{<\kappa}H_{\kappa} satisfying that 0<|T_{\alpha}|<\kappa for every \alpha<\kappa . 2 2 2 In this case, the poset (T,{\subsetneq}) is a set-theoretic \kappa -tree in the usual abstract sense. A streamlined \kappa -Souslin tree is a streamlined \kappa -tree having no \kappa -branches and no \kappa -sized antichains with respect to the ordering \subsetneq . Convention 2.1 . Hereafter, by a tree, we mean a streamlined tree. Definition 2.2 . For all s,t\in{}^{<\kappa}H_{\kappa} , let \Delta(s,t):=\min(\{\dom(s),\dom(t)\}\cup\{\delta\in\dom(s)\cap\dom(t)\mathrel{|}\allowbreak s(\delta)\neq t(\delta)\}). In addition, we define (s*t):\dom(t)\rightarrow H_{\kappa} via: (s*t)(\varepsilon):=\begin{cases}s(\varepsilon),&\text{if }\varepsilon\in\dom(s);\\ t(\varepsilon),&\text{otherwise.}\end{cases} Definition 2.3 . A \kappa -tree T is uniformly homogeneous iff for all s,t\in T , s*t