Some Remarks on the Product Formula for Defect Numbers of Closed Operators
Christoph Fischbacher, Fritz Gesztesy, Lance L. Littlejohn · 2025
Read Some Remarks on the Product Formula for Defect Numbers of Closed Operators by Christoph Fischbacher, Fritz Gesztesy, Lance L. Littlejohn (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-06506.txt.
Introduction
Christoph Fischbacher, Fritz Gesztesy, and Lance Littlejohn review product rules for defect numbers in a 2025 paper. The paper is largely a teaching piece. Defect numbers measure how far a closed operator sits from being fully well behaved, and they matter when operators are multiplied together. The authors gather known facts on how defect numbers behave for products.
Their tools come from the theory of semi-Fredholm operators, a class with well mapped behavior. They apply the product facts to whole-number powers of symmetric operators. They then turn to minimal Sturm-Liouville operators and to higher even-order operators, in both ordinary and partial differential form. Along the way, they flag chances that past research groups missed when similar work was compared side by side.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Christoph Fischbacher, Fritz Gesztesy, Lance L. Littlejohn |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 75 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-06506
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Some Remarks on the Product Formula for Defect Numbers of Closed Operators Christoph Fischbacher, Fritz Gesztesy, Lance L. Littlejohn Abstract . This largely pedagogical note recalls some facts on defect numbers of products of closed operators employing results from the theory of semi-Fredholm operators and then applies these facts to positive integer powers of symmetric operators and subsequently to certain minimal Sturm–Liouville and minimal higher even-order ordinary differential operators. We also point out some unexpected missed opportunities when comparing the work of different groups on this subject. 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification Primary: 47A05, 47A53. Secondary: 47B02, 47E05, 47F05 1. Introduction A very happy birthday, Henk! We hope this note will cause some smiles on your part. This primarily pedagogical note originated with the following explicit question: “What are the deficiency indices of positive integer powers of of the minimal Legendre operator in L^{2}((-1,1)) ?” It did not take long to realize that this question, actually, a much more general one, had long been answered by at least three different groups. In 1950 (Engl. translation in 1953) I. M. Glazman [ 40 ] determined the deficiency indices of products of densely defined and closed linear operators T_{1} and T_{2} in a complex separable Hilbert space assuming finite defect numbers of T_{1},T_{2} , that is, \defe(T_{j},0)=\dim(\ker(T_{j}^{*}))<\infty,\quad j=1,2, (1.1) and 0 in the domain of regularity of T_{1},T_{2} , that is, there exists constants c_{T_{j}}\in(0,\infty) such that \|T_{j}f\|_{{\mathcal{H}}}\geqslant c_{T_{j}}\|f\|_{{\mathcal{H}}},\quad f\in\dom(T_{j}),\;j=1,2. (1.2) Under these hypotheses, Glazman proved that \defe(T_{2}T_{1},0)=\defe(T_{1},0)+\defe(T_{2},0). (1.3) In addition, Glazman proved the result that if S is symmetric with with finite deficiency indices n_{\pm}(S)=\dim(\ker(S^{*}\mp iI_{{\mathcal{H}}}))\in{\mathbb{N}}, (1.4) then n_{\pm}\big(S^{2}\big)=n_{+}(S)+n_{-}(S) (1.5) (These results extend of course to higher positive integer powers of S .) These 1950 results by Glazman are also mentioned in his 1965 book [ 41 , p. 24–27] . R. M. Kauffman, T. Read, and A. Zettl, in their 1977 lecture notes [ 54 , Ch. V.4] on the deficiency indices of powers of ordinary differential expressions are citing Glazman’s 1950 paper, but not his 1965 book. At the same time, H. Behncke and H. Focke also derived ( 1.5 ) (and its higher positive integer power analog) in 1977 as a byproduct of their study of stability properties of of deficiency indices with respect to sufficiently small relative bounded perturbations. In addition, Behncke and Focke also deal with the case of possibly infinite deficiency indices. Interestingly, Behncke and Focke do not cite Glazman and, being essentially simultaneous with Kauffman, Read, and Zettl, neither group appears to have been aware of the activities of the other. In addition to the three groups mentioned, there has been considerable interest in studying powers and generally, products of symmetric operators, both, in an abstract context (see, e.g., [ 1 ] , [ 4 ] , [ 5 ] , [ 10 , App. D] , [ 12 ] , [ 17 ] , [ 47 ] , [ 71 ] ) and particularly in the context of (minimally) defined differential operators (see, e.g., [ 3 ] , [ 13 ] , [ 15 ] , [ 21 ] , [ 22 ] , [ 23 ] , [ 24 ] , [ 25 ] , [ 26 ] , [ 28 ] , [ 31 ] , [ 32 ] , [ 33 ] , [ 47 ] , [ 52 ] , [ 53 ] , [ 54 , Ch. V] , [ 67 ] , [ 76 ] , [ 77 ] , [ 78 ] , [ 79 ] ). For fundamental papers on the number of L^{2} -solutions associated with n th-order differential equations, n\in{\mathbb{N}}) (including the case of matrix-valued coefficients), see, for instance, [ 20 ] , [ 55 ] , [ 56 ] , [ 58 ] , [ 59 ] , [ 62 ] , [ 64 ] , [ 80 ] , and the literature cited therein. In Section 2 we recall the basic abstract results of defect numbers of products of densely defined closed operators and, utilizing the notion of semi-Fredholm operators, apply this to positive integer powers of symmetric operators S in {\mathcal{H}} in Theorems 2.8 and 2.9 . This is then extended to real polynomials of S , recovering a result of Behncke and Focke (and extending the corresponding results of Glazman). We also provide a discussion of the product formula for (semi-)Fredholm operators and in this context note that Sandovici and de Snoo describe the index formula for products of linear relations in [ 68 ] . In Section 3 we hint at some possible applications to positive integer powers of certain minimal Sturm–Liouville and minimal higher even-order ordinary differential operators. In addition, we analyze in great detail the differential expression introduced by J. Chaudhuri and W. N. Everitt [ 14 ] \tau_{2,CE}=-\frac{d}{dx}\frac{1}{6}(x+1)^{4}\frac{d}{dx}+(x+1)^{2},\quad x\in[0,\infty), (1.6) which we reduce to the special case \alpha=\sqrt{33}/2\in(1,3) of the following one-parameter Bessel differential expression \tau_{2,\alpha}=-\frac{d^{2}}{dx^{2}}+\frac{\alpha^{2}-(1/4)}{(1-x)^{2}},\quad\alpha\in[1,\infty),\;x\in[0,1), (1.7) implying \displaystyle\begin{split}\tau_{4,\alpha}=\tau_{2,\alpha}^{2}=\frac{d^{4}}{dx^{4}}-\frac{d}{dx}\frac{2\alpha^{2}-(1/2)}{(1-x)^{2}}\frac{d}{dx}+\frac{\alpha^{4}-(13/2)\alpha^{2}+(5/4)^{2}}{(1-x)^{4}},&\\ \alpha\in[1,\infty),\;x\in[0,1).&\end{split} (1.8) The point of this example lies in the facts \displaystyle\defe(T_{2,\alpha,min},0)=1, (1.9) \displaystyle\defe\big(T_{2,\alpha,min}^{2},0\big)=2=2\defe(T_{2,\alpha,min},0), (1.10) \displaystyle\defe(T_{4,\alpha,min},0)=3;\quad\alpha\in[1,3), (1.11) where ( 1.10 ) is of course in agreement with ( 1.5 ), and ( 1.11 ) is rather remarkable. Here T_{2,\alpha,min} and T_{4,\alpha,min} denote the minimal operators associated with the differential expressions \tau_{2,\alpha} and \tau_{4,\alpha} in L^{2}((0,1)) . The property \defe(T_{4,\alpha,min},0)=3 in ( 1.11 ) is dubbed the “limit- 3 property” of T_{4,\alpha,min} in [ 14 ] and we refer, for instance, also to [ 23 ] , [ 24 ] , [ 25 ] , [ 26 ] , [ 27 ] , for more details in this connection. We conclude Section 3 with some applications to partial differential operators. First, we study strongly singular, homogenous perturbations of the Laplacian on {\mathbb{R}}^{n} of the form \big[-\Delta_{n}-\{[(n-1)(n-3)/4]+L(L+n-2)\}|x|^{-2}\big]\big|_{C_{0}^{\infty}({\mathbb{R}}^{n}\backslash\{0\}}. (1.12) It is well-known that this operator is unitarily equivalent to a direct sum of countably many Bessel differential operators, where the first L+1 members of this direct sum have deficiency indices both equal to one, while the remaining members are essentially self-adjoint and therefore have deficiency indices both equal to zero. From this, we conclude that the deficiency indices of (the closure of) the operator in ( 1.12 ) are equal to L+1 and hence, its m^{th} power has deficiency indices m(L+1) . Finally, we consider singular perturbations of the Dirichlet Laplacian T_{\Omega,D} in L^{2}(\Omega) , where \Omega\subset{\mathbb{R}}^{n} is a bounded domain with smooth boundary \partial\Omega . By “singular perturbations”, we mean symmetric restrictions T_{\Omega,h,k} of T_{\Omega,D} with defect indices equal to one, which are parametrized by h\in L^{2}(\Omega) and k\in C(\partial\Omega) . The domains of these restrictions are described by the additional non-local boundary condition \dom(T_{\Omega,h,k})=\{g\in\dom(T_{\Omega,D})\,|\,(h,g)_{L^{2}(\Omega)}=(k,\gamma_{N}g)_{L^{2}(\partial\Omega)}\}, (1.13) where \gamma_{N} is the Neumann trace on the boundary \partial\Omega . We determine the adjoint T_{\Omega,h,k}^{*} and the Friedrichs and Krein–von Neumann extensions of T_{\Omega,h,k} . Moreover, using von Neumann’s theory of self-adjoint extensions of symmetric operators, we describe the one-parameter family of all self-adjoint extensions of T_{\Omega,h,k} and, using the Birman–Krein–Vishik theory, we also describe all of its nonnegative self-adjoint extensions. Applying the general results from Section 2 , we also get a description of the powers T_{\Omega,h,k}^{m} and their defect indices. Finally, we briefly summarize some of the notation used in