The Ishango Bone: Evidence for Intentional Arithmetic Design in the Upper Palaeolithic?
Jenny Baur · 2025
Read The Ishango Bone: Evidence for Intentional Arithmetic Design in the Upper Palaeolithic? by Jenny Baur (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-06412.txt.
Introduction
Jenny Baur re-examines the Ishango Bone in a 2025 paper. The bone, found near the Semliki River in what is now Congo, dates to about 20,000 years ago. Its sixteen groups of notches, in three columns, have sparked debate for decades over whether they encode math.
Baur reports patterns across all three columns. Two columns hold prime and odd numbers in a set range, missing only the set's own mean. Each column sums to 60 and splits into halves of 30. A global shuffle test found the full pattern in none of a million random rearrangements. She argues the bone may have taught arithmetic, not merely tallied counts.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jenny Baur |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 67 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-06412
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The Ishango Bone: Evidence for Intentional Arithmetic Design in the Upper Palaeolithic? Jenny Baur Abstract The Ishango Bone is a prehistoric artifact dated to approximately 20,000 years ago, discovered near the Semliki River in what is now the Democratic Republic of Congo ( Crevecoeur et al., 2016 ; de Heinzelin de Braucourt, 1957 ) , and has been the subject of scholarly debate for decades. The artifact displays sixteen groups of notches organised into three distinct columns, a structure that permits relational analysis, yet its precise function remains debated. This study identifies previously undescribed mathematical patterns across all three columns. Two columns comprise all prime and odd numbers between 9 and 21, with the sole exception of 15, itself the arithmetic mean of this set. Each column sums to 60 and subdivides into two internal groupings, each summing to 30. Exploratory positional adjustments, each uniquely constrained by the data, appear to reveal a consistent grouping rule and arithmetic relationships, spanning all three columns. Five structural properties are evaluated simultaneously through a global permutation test. The fully adjusted configuration achieves a score that is not observed among the 1,000,000 random rearrangements of the same values. The findings in this study support the hypothesis that the Ishango Bone may have functioned as a reference for demonstrating and teaching arithmetic relationships, challenging its characterisation as a simple tallying tool and suggesting a considerably more sophisticated level of mathematical reasoning in the Upper Palaeolithic than is commonly assumed. Figure 1: Notched bone from Ishango Left: Photograph of the Ishango Bone. © RBINS. Retrieved from https://www.naturalsciences.be/en/museum/exhibitions-activities/exhibitions/250-years-of-natural-sciences/the-ishango-bone Right: Drawing of the Ishango Bone by Jean de Heinzelin, originally published in 1957 in Découverte de l’industrie du paléolithique supérieur dans la région d’Ishango (Congo belge), Bulletin de l’Institut Royal des Sciences Naturelles de Belgique, 33(6):1–29. © RBINS. These images have been reproduced with permission. 1 Introduction The Ishango Bone is an artifact from the Upper Palaeolithic era, unearthed in 1950 by Belgian geologist Jean de Heinzelin during excavations along the Semliki River near Lake Edward in what is now the Democratic Republic of Congo ( de Heinzelin de Braucourt, 1957 ) . Approximately 10 centimetres in length, with a piece of quartz affixed to one end, the bone is engraved with sixteen groups of notches organised into three distinct columns, an arrangement that has intrigued researchers across disciplines for decades and is often cited as one of the earliest known mathematical artifacts ( Institute of Natural Sciences, n.d. ) . Early interpretations have suggested that the artifact functioned as a lunar or time-reckoning device ( ICOMOS and IAU, 2010 ; Marshack, 1971 ) , may reflect a base-12 numerical system ( Pletser and Huylebrouck, 1999 ) , or might have functioned as a mathematical sieve ( Kamalu, 2021 ) . Despite these hypotheses, its precise purpose remains a subject of ongoing debate ( Joseph, 2011 ; Rudman, 2007 ) . Building on de Heinzelin’s original documentation ( Institute of Natural Sciences, n.d. ; de Heinzelin de Braucourt, 1957 ) , the present study proposes previously undescribed mathematical patterns spanning all three columns. The column labels G (front left), D (front right), and M (reverse side) follow de Heinzelin’s own designations. The analysis begins with Columns G and D, where the grouped notches appear to comprise all prime and odd numbers between 9 and 21, with the sole exception of 15. Each column sums to 60 and subdivides into two internal groupings, each summing to 30, and five consistent groupings of 30 can be identified, spanning all three columns. The relationships extend to support all four basic arithmetic operations: the row sums of Columns G and D are matched by the products of corresponding number pairs in Column M, and addition and subtraction of a secondary value generate a consecutive integer sequence from 2 to 13 within Column M. Each configuration is evaluated through a global permutation test using a composite statistic S , defined as the number of structural properties simultaneously satisfied by a given arrangement. This approach avoids the multiple comparisons problem inherent in testing individually identified properties and asks a single, well-defined question: how often does a random redistribution of the same sixteen values across the same three-column structure achieve an equal or higher overall score? The fully adjusted configuration satisfies all five structural properties simultaneously, a score achieved by none of 1,000,000 random rearrangements of the same values. The findings lead to the hypothesis that the Ishango Bone’s numerical design may have served as a reference for laying out values with physical markers for demonstrative or educational purposes, in which the exploration of mathematical relationships themselves may have constituted a form of mathematical storytelling. In doing so, this study aims to broaden the interpretation of the Ishango Bone beyond its traditional characterisation as a simple tallying device, and to invite a reconsideration of the mathematical capabilities of Upper Palaeolithic humans. 2 Methods This study employs a systematic and exploratory approach to analyse the numerical arrangements inscribed on the Ishango Bone and documented by its finder, Jean de Heinzelin. The exploratory approach is a flexible and adaptive method for examining the Ishango Bone dataset, employed here to heuristically test for potentially underlying patterns. It emphasises hypothesis formation from observed data, allowing for dynamic interpretation and the development of new insights ( Tukey, 1977 ; Cowgill, 1993 ) . The investigation focused on identifying mathematical patterns, intercolumn relationships, and grouping rules within the three numerical columns. The analysis begins with the observation that Columns G and D together contain all prime and odd numbers between 9 and 21, with the sole exception of 15. Each column consists of four such numbers summing to 60, and each column subdivides into two pairs, each summing to 30. These properties form the starting point for the pattern analysis. It was then hypothesised that the dualistic grouping arrangement consistently observed in Column G had been slightly disrupted in Column D through an error introduced during oral transmission. An exploratory adjustment was therefore applied, exchanging the positions of numbers 11 and 21 in Column D, to test whether this would restore the dualistic pairing structure and align Column D with the arrangement observed in Column G. This adjustment revealed additional patterns and mathematical interrelationships across Columns G and D, involving all numbers, including a diagonal placement of the doubled primes and a consistent arithmetic progression of row sums. The numerical values from Column M, which is located on the reverse side of the artefact, were then included in the analysis. Given that Columns G and D each contain four numbers arranged in four rows, and Column M contains eight numbers, it was hypothesised that the values in Column M might be organised as four number pairs, each corresponding by row to the adjacent values in Columns G and D. However, no structural patterns connecting Column M to Columns G and D could be identified in this initial configuration. The same structural logic was then extended to Column M as a testable hypothesis: if the Column D deviation reflected a potential misalignment in an otherwise consistent design, Column M, as the third column of the same artifact, might exhibit a corresponding misalignment