Review, Definition and Challenges of Electrical Energy Hubs

Giacomo Bastianel, Jan Kircheis, Merijn Van Deyck, Dongyeong Lee, Geraint Chaffey, Marta Vanin, Hakan Ergun, Jef Beerten, Dirk Van Hertem · 2025

Read Review, Definition and Challenges of Electrical Energy Hubs by Giacomo Bastianel, Jan Kircheis, Merijn Van Deyck, Dongyeong Lee, Geraint Chaffey, Marta Vanin, Hakan Ergun, Jef Beerten, Dirk Van Hertem (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-06373.txt.

Introduction

Giacomo Bastianel and co-authors published a review paper in 2025 on giant offshore power hubs that gather wind energy in the North Sea and send it ashore. Such projects pack many gigawatts into a small sea area with several links to land grids. Planners lacked a shared, precise word for the thing they were building.

The paper coins a formal definition, Electrical Energy Hub, and spells out what such hubs do. It then walks through the hard problems they pose for control, planning, and fault protection. A list of live and planned projects is checked against the new definition. Clear terms, the authors argue, must come before sound grid codes and support rules.

Catalog record

CREATORGiacomo Bastianel, Jan Kircheis, Merijn Van Deyck, Dongyeong Lee, Geraint Chaffey, Marta Vanin, Hakan Ergun, Jef Beerten, Dirk Van Hertem
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE36 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-06373

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Review, Definition and Challenges of Electrical Energy Hubs Giacomo Bastianel, Jan Kircheis, Merijn Van Deyck, Dongyeong Lee, Geraint Chaffey, Marta Vanin, Hakan Ergun, Jef Beerten, Dirk Van Hertem Abstract To transition towards a carbon-neutral power system, considerable amounts of renewable energy generation capacity are being installed in the North Sea area. Consequently, projects aggregating many gigawatts of power generation capacity and transmitting renewable energy to the main load centers are being developed. Given the electrical challenges arising from having bulk power capacity in a compact geographical area with several connections to the main grid, and a lack of a robust definition identifying the type of system under study, this paper proposes a general technical definition of such projects introducing the term Electrical Energy Hub (EEH) . The concept, purpose, and functionalities of EEHs are introduced in the text, emphasizing the importance of a clear technical definition for future planning procedures, grid codes, regulations, and support schemes for EEHs and multiterminal HVDC (MTDC) grids in general. Furthermore, the unique electrical challenges associated with integrating EEHs into the power system are discussed. Three research areas of concern are identified, namely control, planning, and protection. Through this analysis, insights are provided into the effective implementation of multi-GW scale EEH projects and their integration into the power grid through multiple interconnections. Finally, a list of ongoing and planned grid development projects is evaluated to assess whether they fall within the EEH category. Keywords: AC/DC grids , Electrical energy hubs, Energy islands, Multi-terminal HVDC grids , Offshore grids 1 Introduction Climate change and the constant increase in the average global temperature compared to pre-industrial levels have triggered a rapid transition towards net-zero power systems. To achieve a decrease in CO_{2} emissions, considerable amounts of renewable energy sources (RES) are installed, with a cumulative worldwide capacity of 1185 GW of solar PV [ 1 ] and 906 GW of wind power [ 2 ] in 2023. Among the installed wind power capacity, offshore wind grew from 2.1 GW in 2009 to 72.7 GW in 2023. In addition, 380 GW of offshore wind generation capacity is expected to be installed worldwide in the next decade [ 2 ] . In this regard, the European Union (EU) foresees 300 GW of installed offshore wind capacity in its territory by 2050 [ 3 ] . As such, offshore wind plays a key role in the EU’s plans to reduce the CO_{2} emissions by 2030 with at least 55% compared to 1990 levels and to make the continent carbon-neutral by 2050 [ 4 ] . In particular, the governments of Belgium, Germany, the Netherlands, Denmark, France, Ireland, Luxembourg, Norway, and the United Kingdom have agreed on reaching at least 300 GW of offshore wind capacity installed in the North Sea by 2050 with the Ostend Declaration [ 5 ] . So far, offshore wind power has mainly been transmitted from wind farms directly to the onshore grid, either in AC [ 6 ] or high-voltage DC (HVDC) [ 7 ] . With many wind farms installed in the North Sea area, scientific literature has proposed creating offshore grids to connect and deliver RES power to different points in onshore power systems more than a decade ago [ 8 ] . Recently, several institutions such as the International Energy Agency [ 9 ] , the European Commision [ 10 ] , ENTSO-E [ 11 ] and the Belgian (Elia [ 12 ] ), Danish (Energinet [ 13 , 14 ] ) and Dutch-German (TenneT [ 15 ] ) transmission system operators have remarked the importance of offshore grids and, in general, of transmission infrastructure investments to decarbonize our society. Such offshore grids shall be predominantly based on HVDC cables, which have proven to be the most cost-effective solution for transmitting electricity over long distances [ 16 ] . Furthermore, the power generated by offshore RES can be collected in electrical nodes and transmitted to the onshore grid through interconnected HVDC links, creating a multiterminal HVDC (MTDC) grid. These grids facilitate power exchange between different control areas without congesting the existing AC grid and will likely become considerably more common in the future [ 11 , 17 ] . When combining this interconnection aspect with multi-GW generation in a single unit such as in recent “ energy island ” projects [ 12 , 14 , 13 ] , several technical challenges emerge. As there is no clear definition of these new projects, nor an in-depth description of the technical challenges related to them, this paper proposes the term electrical energy hubs to describe such projects. The rest of this paper is organized as follows. Section 2 includes a definition for the proposed term electrical energy hubs , their functionalities, and the motivation behind this work. Section 3 positions the term in the literature, emphasizing the need for a clear definition, while Section 4 discusses the technical challenges related to the previously listed functionalities and to which research domain they belong among control, planning, and protection. Finally, Section 5 classifies some ongoing and planned grid infrastructure projects, and Section 6 concludes the paper. 2 Motivation and definition of electrical energy hubs With an increase in the distance of offshore wind farms from shore, the power transmission projects in the North Sea area have shifted from Point-to-Point (PtP) AC [ 6 , 18 , 19 , 20 ] to PtP HVDC [ 7 , 21 , 22 , 23 , 24 ] links. As HVDC transmission systems are cheaper than AC technologies over long distances [ 16 , 25 ] , and guarantee enhanced power flow controllability and frequency support between asynchronous zones [ 8 ] , they are currently the preferred option for transmission grid expansion projects related to offshore wind. Moreover, several options for future development of offshore HVDC grids are being proposed, ranging from a central hub with interconnectors [ 26 ] , to several hub-and-spoke combinations with integrated hydrogen production [ 27 ] , standardized HVDC PtP links [ 15 ] or MTDC/meshed offshore HVDC grids [ 8 , 28 , 29 ] . The last two options coexist in the ENTSO-E Offshore Network Development Plan [ 11 ] , where a combination of offshore “ hybrid transmission corridors ” and PtP links is foreseen for the European future grid. In this regard, Elia [ 12 ] and Energinet [ 13 , 14 ] proposed to combine the aggregation of several GW of offshore wind power and its transmission to several European countries via HVDC interconnections in one unit, creating offshore MTDC grids. These projects follow the concept proposed in [ 26 ] . While there seems to be a general understanding of the main principles underlying the goals of these projects [ 30 , 12 , 13 ] , there is currently no consistent terminology to address them from a technical perspective. Therefore, in this paper, the following definition of the term electrical energy hub is proposed: An Electrical Energy Hub (EEH) is a multifunctional node in a power system, managed separately from the main existing control areas, which aggregates local GW-size electrical generation capacity. It is characterized by a high density of electrical equipment and has multiple interconnections

Read the complete text