Testing compact massive black hole binary candidates through multi-epoch spectroscopy
Lorenzo Bertassi ,, Erika Sottocorno, Fabio Rigamonti, Daniel D’Orazio, Michael Eracleous, Zoltán Haiman, Massimo Dotti · 2025
Read Testing compact massive black hole binary candidates through multi-epoch spectroscopy by Lorenzo Bertassi ,, Erika Sottocorno, Fabio Rigamonti, Daniel D’Orazio, Michael Eracleous, Zoltán Haiman, Massimo Dotti (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-06349.txt.
Introduction
Lorenzo Bertassi and co-authors propose a new test for pairs of giant black holes in a 2025 paper. Two such black holes bound close together should make their shared gas glow in shifting ways. Orbital motion boosts the light aimed at us, like a lighthouse beam sweeping past. The surrounding gas then re-emits that light in broad spectral lines.
The team model how a disc of this gas answers the sweeping beam. The blue and red sides of the lines answer half an orbit out of step with each other. A single black hole with pulsing brightness cannot mimic that pattern. The lag split offers a fresh signature for hunting true black hole pairs in survey data.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Lorenzo Bertassi ,, Erika Sottocorno, Fabio Rigamonti, Daniel D’Orazio, Michael Eracleous, Zoltán Haiman, Massimo Dotti |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 62 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-06349
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Testing compact massive black hole binary candidates through multi-epoch spectroscopy Lorenzo Bertassi ,, Erika Sottocorno, Fabio Rigamonti, Daniel D’Orazio, Michael Eracleous, Zoltán Haiman, Massimo Dotti Abstract Emission from two massive black holes (MBHs) bound in a close binary is expected to be modulated by different processes, such as the Doppler boost due to the orbital motion, accretion rate variability generated by the interaction with a circumbinary disc, and binary gravitational self-lensing. When the binary is compact enough, the two black holes are thought to be surrounded by a common broad-line region that reprocesses the impinging periodically varying ionising flux, creating broad emission lines with variable line shapes. Therefore, the study of broad emission line variability through multi-epoch spectroscopic campaigns is of paramount importance for the unambiguous identification of a binary. In this work, we study the response of a disc-like broad-line region to the Doppler-boosted ionising flux emitted by sub-milliparsec MBH binaries on a circular orbit and compare it with the response of a broad-line region illuminated by a single MBH with a periodically but isotropically varying intrinsic luminosity. We show that in the binary case, the time lags of the blue and red wings of the broad emission lines, arising from diametrically opposite sides of the circumbinary disc, are out of phase by half of the binary’s orbital period, as they each respond to the periodic ‘lighthouse’ modulation from the binary’s continuum emission. This asymmetric time lag represents a new binary signature that cannot be mimicked by a single MBH. 1 Introduction Massive black hole binaries (MBHBs) are predicted to form in the aftermath of galaxy mergers ( Begelman et al. 1980 ) . These objects are expected to be among the loudest gravitational wave (GW) sources that will be identified by future space-borne interferometers ( Amaro-Seoane et al. 2023 , e.g.) and pulsar timing array campaigns ( Verbiest et al. 2016 ) . Recently, evidence of a GW background, possibly produced by supermassive black hole binaries, has been detected by PTA experiments ( Agazie et al. 2023 ; Antoniadis et al. 2023 , see, e.g.) . Identifying these sources simultaneously through electromagnetic (EM) observations will increase our knowledge of black hole inspirals, accretion physics, cosmology, and general relativity ( Baker et al. 2019 ; De Rosa et al. 2019 ; Amaro-Seoane et al. 2023 , see, e.g. ) . While there are confirmed EM detections of dual active galactic nuclei (AGNs) at \sim kiloparsec-parsec separations (see De Rosa et al. 2019 for a review, Trindade Falcão et al. 2024 for a recent candidate with a separation of 100 pc and Rodriguez et al. 2006 for a candidate with a separation of 7.3 pc), strong evidence of gravitationally bound MBHBs at sub-parsec scales is still missing. For this reason, several indirect observational signatures have been proposed (see e.g. Nguyen & Bogdanović 2016 ; D’Orazio & Haiman 2017 ; Nguyen et al. 2019 ; Dotti et al. 2023 ; D’Orazio & Charisi 2023 , for recent discussions) . Among these signatures, the photometric ones are of particular interest as they will be searched for in forthcoming large observational campaigns, such as the Vera Rubin Observatory’s 10-year Legacy Survey of Space and Time ( Ivezić et al. 2019 , LSST, see) and the Roman Space Telescope’s High Latitude Time Domain Survey ( Haiman et al. 2023 , HLTDS, see) , with the appropriate depth and cadence. Examples of these signatures are the variability in the continuum emission caused by the interaction between the binary and a circumbinary disc ( MacFadyen & Milosavljević 2008 , see) and by relativistic effects, such as Doppler boosting ( D’Orazio et al. 2015 , see) and gravitational self-lensing ( Kelley et al. 2021 , see) . The length and cadence of these new time domain surveys will allow us to reject sources that present false periodicities due to red noise observed in optical and UV light curves ( Vaughan et al. 2016 , e.g.) for short period binaries, with \rm{P}\lesssim 1\ \rm{month} corresponding to separations of a\sim 10^{-4}\ (M/10^{6}\rm{M_{\odot})}^{1/3}\ \mathrm{pc} , where M is the binary total mass. Even though a fraction of false candidates can be rejected through long-term monitoring, the effective presence of a binary needs to be tested in detail as single massive black holes (MBHs) may have a variable intrinsic luminosity mimicking modulation in the light curves expected from binaries ( Sandrinelli et al. 2016 , see e.g. the discussion in) . Our work proposes a new spectroscopic test to prove the binary nature of photometrically identified sub-milliparsec MBHB candidates. At such small separations, the hypothetical binaries will have mildly relativistic orbital speeds, approaching 0.1c for the more massive and compact systems, and are thought to be embedded in a common circumbinary broad-line region (BLR). If at least one of the two MBHs is accreting, the periodically modulated ionising flux impinging on the BLR is expected to affect the broad emission line (BEL) shape in unique ways, due to the beamed anisotropic irradiation. The BEL time evolution then encodes information about the presence of a binary. In our work, we assume disc-like BLRs, and we model both single and double-peaked BELs by changing the inclination of the system. Non-asymmetric BELs can be modelled by including deviations from axisymmetry in the BLR emissivity profile ( Storchi-Bergmann et al. 2017 , see) . Under this assumption, we compute how the BEL responds to the Doppler-modulated ionising continuum, which varies to first order as O(v/c) , in the case of an MBHB, as well as to an intrinsically isotropically variable continuum emitted by a single MBH that has the exact same photometric modulation as is observed in the MBHB case. The following discussion is tailored for the broad \rm{H{\beta}} line, but the proposed test can be readapted to other optical-UV BELs by adjusting the ‘characteristic radius’ of the BLR. Our scenario has some similarities with the model proposed by Hutchings & McCall (1977) to explain the 3-hour periodic variation of the observed magnitudes and emission lines in the Nova VI500 Cyg. Unlike our model, in which the modulation is caused by the anisotropic emission due to the Doppler boost, the periodic emission is explained by the varying presentation aspect of a hot spot in a conventional cataclysmic variable model ( Robinson 1976 , see) . In their model, the nebula, which plays a role similar to that of the BLR in our work, responds to the varying impinging continuum and presents a multi-component, axisymmetric structure consisting of a disc and two polar blobs. Similarly to the binary signature that we are proposing (see Section 3 ), the observed spectroscopic features of the nova emission lines cannot be explained under the assumption of an isotropic source. In Section 2 , we describe the underlying assumptions of our model, the methods with which the BELs are constructed, and how the fluxes of interest are computed. In Section 3 , we illustrate our main results. Finally, in Section 4 , we draw our main conclusions and propose the next steps to generalise our work to more complex scenarios. 2 Methodology In our work, we compare the response of a disc-like BLR (detailed in Section 2.2 ) to the