Factorizing Defects from Generalized Pinning Fields

Fedor K. Popov 1 and Yifan Wang 2 · 2025

Read Factorizing Defects from Generalized Pinning Fields by Fedor K. Popov 1 and Yifan Wang 2 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-06203.txt.

Introduction

Fedor Popov and Yifan Wang present a 2025 physics paper on a new kind of defect in conformal field theory. Conformal theories describe systems at a critical point, where patterns repeat at every scale. Defects model impurities placed inside such a system, and their behavior at long distance falls into known classes.

The authors define generalized pinning fields, defects set by certain unbounded operators on the state space. They prove that when such a defect sits on a surface dividing space, the whole system factorizes into two halves. Symmetry in the bulk restricts the possible factorization channels. As payoffs, they solve these impurities in two-dimensional minimal models and confirm a factorization seen earlier in a three-dimensional model.

Catalog record

CREATORFedor K. Popov 1 and Yifan Wang 2
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE87 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-06203

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Factorizing Defects from Generalized Pinning Fields Fedor K. Popov 1 and Yifan Wang 2 Abstract We introduce generalized pinning fields in conformal field theory that model a large class of critical impurities at large distance, enriching the familiar universality classes. We provide a rigorous definition of such defects as certain unbounded operators on the Hilbert space and prove that when inserted on codimension-one surfaces they factorize the spacetime into two halves. The factorization channels are further constrained by symmetries in the bulk. As a corollary, we solve such critical impurities in the 2d minimal models and establish the factorization phenomena previously observed for localized mass deformations in the 3d O ⁡ ( N ) {\rm O}(N) model. I Introduction and Summary Extended operators defined on submanifolds of the spacetime constitute a fundamental component of modern quantum field theory (QFT), shaping our understanding of symmetry principles, phases of matter and strong coupling phenomena. When extended in time, they are also known as defects – such as impurities and boundaries – which exhibit rich dynamics, particularly in gapless bulk systems described by conformal field theories (CFTs). In cases where the CFT admits a gravity dual, defects correspond to strings, branes and nontrivial backreacted geometries, providing a valuable portal to investigate systematically such nonperturbative objects in quantum gravity. Hence it is essential to determine what defects and extended operators are admissible in CFT (and QFT more broadly) and to understand their corresponding dynamics. To this end, powerful monotonicity theorems have been established for defect renormalization group (RG) flows Affleck and Ludwig 1991 ; Friedan and Konechny 2004 ; Jensen and O’Bannon 2016 ; Casini et al. 2019 ; Kobayashi et al. 2019 ; Wang 2021 ; Wang 2022 ; Cuomo et al. 2022a ; Shachar et al. 2023 ; Casini et al. 2023 , ensuring that certain defects remain unscreened at large distances, while additional constraints from generalized symmetries are beginning to be explored Konechny 2020 ; Thorngren and Wang 2021 ; Aharony et al. 2023a ; Choi et al. 2023 ; Aharony et al. 2023b ; Bhardwaj et al. 2024 ; Choi et al. 2024 ; Antinucci et al. 2024 . Furthermore, conformal bootstrap techniques have been developed to directly probe the operator algebra data at the defect fixed point Billò et al. 2016 , while the study of defect fusion and the Casimir effect offers new perspectives on universal defect data via the framework of effective field theory Diatlyk et al. 2024a ; Diatlyk et al. 2024b ; Kravchuk et al. 2024 ; Cuomo et al. 2024 . Nevertheless, explicit examples of nontrivial conformal defects remain scarce, and even with a well-defined short-distance description, their behavior at large distances remains unclear. Here we introduce a large family of defects with the following simple UV definition in an arbitrary CFT in d\geq 2 , \displaystyle{\cal D}_{h}({{\mathcal{O}}})\equiv\left[e^{h\hat{\mathcal{O}}}\right]_{\rm ren}\,,\quad\hat{\mathcal{O}}\equiv\int_{\Sigma_{p}}{\mathcal{O}}(x)\,, (I.1) where {\mathcal{O}} is a scalar operator of dimension \Delta_{\mathcal{O}}<p and \Sigma_{p} is the defect worldvolume which we will often take to be an {\mathbb{R}}^{p} hyperplane in the Euclidean spacetime. Intuitively, a nonzero coupling constant h in ( I.1 ) triggers a defect RG flow on \Sigma_{p} . With appropriate renormalization, this defines a p -dimensional flat defect in the CFT (similarly for \Sigma_{p}=S^{p} which defines the spherical defect). Such a defect is expected to flow to a nontrivial conformal defect in the IR, which we denote as, \displaystyle{\cal D}({{\mathcal{O}}})\equiv\lim_{h\to\infty}{\cal D}_{h}({{\mathcal{O}}})\,. (I.2) This is because the monotonicity theorems requires the defect entropy (for p odd) and conformal anomaly (for p even) to decrease under defect RG, and they both vanish for the trivial defect. These defects generalize the well-studied pinning field defects in the Ising and general {\rm O}(N) CFTs where {\mathcal{O}} is taken to be the fundamental scalar field (measuring the local spin) and h is the so-called background pinning field Parisen Toldin et al. 2017 ; Cuomo et al. 2022b . We will thus refer to ( I.1 ) and ( I.2 ) as the generalized pinning field defect and its conformal fixed point. In particular, our definition includes the defect RG flows studied by Krishnan and Metlitski 2023 ; Trépanier 2023 ; Raviv-Moshe and Zhong 2023 ; Giombi and Liu 2023 ; Diatlyk et al. 2024c in the very same {\rm O}(N) CFT but triggered by certain mass deformations on a surface. There it was observed based on large N analysis and \epsilon -expansion that the generalized pinning field surface defect at 3d appears to factorize into conformal boundary conditions for two disconnected regions of the spacetime. Interestingly, this factorization also manifests in different ways depending on the sign of the pinning field h , revealing the intricate phase structure on the surface, which includes a newly discovered extraordinary-log phase at strong surface coupling Metlitski 2022 ; Krishnan and Metlitski 2023 . In this work, we focus on codimension-one ( i.e. p=d-1 ) generalized pinning field defects and establish this factorization property in great generality. In particular, this implies that there is no energy transmission across the interface in the IR. Intuitively, this is because the conformal pinning defect ( I.2 ) will take the form of an un-normalized projector on the CFT rigged Hilbert space {\mathcal{H}} (see around ( II.4 )), \displaystyle{\mathcal{D}}({\mathcal{O}})=\bigoplus_{\alpha}|{\alpha}\rangle\langle{\alpha}|\,, (I.3) by projecting to the highest or lowest eigenvalues of the operator \hat{\mathcal{O}} depending on the sign of h , where the eigenbasis is denoted by |{\alpha}\rangle . The eigenstates |{\alpha}\rangle are scalars with respect to {\rm SO}(d-1) and hence do not support a non-vanishing two-point function of the stress energy tensor T_{\mu\nu} across the interface. Furthermore, by conformal symmetry, we expect these eigenstates to describe conformal boundary conditions of the CFT. However one should be cautious with the above heuristic reasoning, since the conformal boundary conditions do not define normalizable states in {\mathcal{H}} and relatedly \hat{\mathcal{O}} may not be a healthy bounded operator on {\mathcal{H}} . In the following we will formalize these points using results from the spectral theory of unbounded operators on Hilbert spaces, particularly the Gelfand triple construction. This framework allows us to precisely define generalized pinning field defects and prove their IR factorizations in Section II . The factorization property enables us to determine the long-distance dynamics of such defects by leveraging the full spectrum of conformal boundary conditions, thereby rendering the problem significantly more tractable. For example, as we discuss in Section IV.2 , this elucidates the conjectured factorization of the 3d {\rm O}(N) CFT induced by the {\rm O}(N) -symmetric surface mass term in terms of known boundary conditions and also yields nontrivial predictions for more general surface mass deformations. As another example, the conformal boundary conditions of Virasoro minimal models in 2d were classified long time ago. However limited results are available for conformal (non-topological) line defects except for those in the Ising CFT. In Section IV.1 , we analyze a large class of 2d pinning defects defined as in ( I.1 ), demonstrating how factorization together with the monotonicity g -theorem and symmetry constraints allow us to completely nail down the IR conformal defect. In general, the symmetries of the CFT restrict the possible factorization channels in ( I.3 ). In particular, anomalies of the symmetries preserved by the defect

Read the complete text