Energy-Conserving Neural Network Closure Model for Long-Time Accurate and Stable 2D LES

T. van Gastelen, W. Edeling, B. Sanderse · 2025

Read Energy-Conserving Neural Network Closure Model for Long-Time Accurate and Stable 2D LES by T. van Gastelen, W. Edeling, B. Sanderse (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-05868.txt.

Introduction

Toby van Gastelen, Wouter Edeling, and Benjamin Sanderse build a neural turbulence model that respects energy conservation in a 2025 paper. Large-eddy simulation models big swirls directly and must model the small ones with a closure. Learned closures capture complex dynamics but often blow up or drift from physics over long runs.

Their closure uses a skew-symmetric network design tied to a discretization that preserves mass, momentum, and energy by construction. Stability is then built in rather than hoped for. Tests run the model long to check accuracy holds. Reliable learned closures could cut the cost of simulating flows in weather, oceans, and engineering, where long stable runs are the whole point.

Catalog record

CREATORT. van Gastelen, W. Edeling, B. Sanderse
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE92 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-05868

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Energy-Conserving Neural Network Closure Model for Long-Time Accurate and Stable 2D LES T. van Gastelen, W. Edeling, B. Sanderse Abstract Machine learning-based closure models for large eddy simulation (LES) have shown promise in capturing complex turbulence dynamics but often suffer from instabilities and physical inconsistencies. In this work, we develop a novel skew-symmetric neural architecture as closure model that enforces stability while preserving key physical conservation laws. Our approach leverages a discretization that ensures mass, momentum, and energy conservation, along with a face-averaging filter to maintain mass conservation in coarse-grained velocity fields. We compare our model against several conventional data-driven closures (including unconstrained convolutional neural networks), and the physics-based Smagorinsky model. Performance is evaluated on decaying turbulence and Kolmogorov flow for multiple coarse-graining factors. In these test cases, we observe that unconstrained machine learning models suffer from numerical instabilities. In contrast, our skew-symmetric model remains stable across all tests, though at the cost of increased dissipation. Despite this trade-off, we demonstrate that our model still outperforms the Smagorinsky model in unseen scenarios. These findings highlight the potential of structure-preserving machine learning closures for reliable long-time LES . Journal: Computers & Fluids † † highlights: Introduce energy-conserving neural network closure for turbulence. Skew-symmetric term redistributes energy; negative definite term dissipates energy. Outperforms standard machine learning models; delivers accurate long-time LES. Neural network training procedure consistently yields accurate and stable LES. 1 Introduction The incompressible Navier-Stokes equations are a set of partial differential equations (PDEs) that describe conservation of mass and momentum of fluid flows. They are used to model a multitude of flow phenomena, such as for the design of aircraft and ships, weather modeling, and even the formation of galaxies [ 59 , 67 ] . To simulate these phenomena, we solve the Navier-Stokes equations on a computational grid. This requires discretizing the differential operators present in the PDE . This can be done with various techniques, such as finite difference, finite volume, and finite element methods [ 56 , 26 , 63 ] . In this work we employ a structure-preserving finite difference scheme, introduced in [ 30 ] . The advantage of this scheme is that it not only satisfies mass and momentum conservation, but also conserves the global kinetic energy (in absence of viscosity and boundary contributions). We refer to conservation of mass, momentum and kinetic energy collectively as the physical ‘structure’ of the system, and we refer to such conservative discretization schemes as ‘structure-preserving’ or ‘symmetry-preserving’ [ 16 , 66 ] . Such schemes have the advantage of being unconditionally stable without relying on artificial diffusion, such as upwind schemes [ 15 ] . This makes them more suitable for long-time simulations, where correct physical energy behavior is crucial. However, problems arise when considering high Reynolds number flows [ 54 ] . For such flows we require very fine computational grids to resolve the smallest eddies in the system. This places a large (often insurmountable) burden on the computational resources. A common approach to reduce computational requirements is large eddy simulation (LES) . In LES , the system is coarse-grained by applying a filter to the velocity field, so that the dimension of the problem is effectively reduced. In this work, we take the ‘discretize first, filter next’ approach [ 1 , 48 , 65 ] . This means that coarse-graining is done on the discrete level by applying a discrete filter to a fine-grid discretization. In particular, we use a face-averaging filter, which has the advantage that the filtered velocity field still satisfies mass conservation [ 2 ] . The latter is necessary to preserve the energy-conserving properties of the convection operator. This provides substantial stability benefits, see [ 2 ] . From the coarse-graining procedure, a commutator error arises. In the ‘discretize first, filter next’ framework, this commutator error also includes the discretization error. Modeling the commutator error is referred to as closure modeling, and the corresponding models are closure models. Closure modeling is a main subject in LES research [ 54 ] . The most commonly used closure models are eddy-viscosity (functional) models [ 60 , 62 ] . Their primary job is to remove (dissipate) energy from the system to account for energy transfer from the resolved scales to the unresolved scales. These models approximate the subgrid stress solely from the resolved scales by assuming proportionality between the subgrid-scale stress tensor and the rate-of-strain tensor [ 54 , 52 ] . The classical Smagorinsky model is the best-known example, but it is strictly dissipative [ 62 , 54 , 52 ] and therefore cannot represent backscatter, i.e., energy transfer from unresolved to resolved scales. Backscatter, however, plays an important role in many flows, including geophysical turbulence relevant for weather and climate modeling [ 19 , 14 , 28 ] . To address this limitation, structural models, such as scale-similarity closures, aim to reproduce the actual structure of the subgrid-scale stress tensor rather than parameterize its dissipation. While these models can, in principle, capture backscatter, they lack inherent dissipation. Consequently, they are often numerically unstable, requiring stabilization procedures such as explicit filtering or averaging. This need for both physical fidelity and numerical robustness motivated the development of mixed models, which combine a structural component with a dissipative functional component to achieve the accuracy of the former and the stability of the latter [ 49 ] . The dynamic Smagorinsky model [ 25 ] represents a related effort to increase flexibility within functional closures by adapting the eddy-viscosity coefficient based on resolved-scale information. Although it can produce limited backscatter, it too can suffer from numerical instabilities [ 44 ] . Several physics-based strategies have since been proposed to improve backscatter representation while maintaining stability. These include enforcing a consistent subgrid-scale energy budget [ 37 ] , introducing filter-based artificial dissipation [ 20 ] , and imposing explicit dissipation constraints [ 36 , 61 ] . Nevertheless, state-of-the-art subgrid-scale closures used in global climate models still exclude backscatter [ 32 ] , primarily due to concerns over robustness. In response, the machine-learned closure models that we will propose aim, in a somewhat similar spirit as mixed models, to combine the best of functional and structural approaches: we keep the structure of the subgrid stress tensor, while at the same time ensuring that the models are energy dissipative (but not as much as existing functional models). Shifting our attention to such machine learning algorithms, neural networks have shown great potential in accurately modeling the closure term, while accounting for backscatter [ 42 , 43 , 45 , 60 , 47 , 39 , 50 , 10 , 29 ] . Offline testing often shows good agreement of the neural network outputs with the true closure term. However, when using the closure term in an actual simulation, problems arise and instabilities occur [ 7 , 42 , 45 , 50 , 29 , 47 ] . One approach to handle this issue is by clipping the neural network such that the output becomes strictly dissipative, for example by projecting onto an eddy-viscosity basis [ 7 , 50 , 29 ] . However, this results in closure models which are generally too dissipative [ 29 ] , which

Read the complete text