Scalar-assisted magnetogenesis during the radiation-dominated epoch
Alexander Ganz, Chunshan Lin, Mian Zhu · 2025
Read Scalar-assisted magnetogenesis during the radiation-dominated epoch by Alexander Ganz, Chunshan Lin, Mian Zhu (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-05835.txt.
Introduction
Alexander Ganz, Chunshan Lin, and Mian Zhu propose a fresh route to cosmic magnetic fields in this 2025 paper. Magnetic fields fill the cosmos, but their origin in the early universe is unsettled. Many birth scenarios suffer from over-strong electric fields or other flaws.
Their plan lets a charged scalar field give the light field an effective mass. That breaks a symmetry that normally forbids field growth. The action starts after electroweak symmetry breaking, in the radiation era. High conductivity then cannot flood the system with electric fields. A tachyonic phase of the light, weakly coupled scalar can seed strong fields. The setup also dodges back-reaction and strong coupling troubles.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Alexander Ganz, Chunshan Lin, Mian Zhu |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 59 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-05835
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Scalar-assisted magnetogenesis during the radiation-dominated epoch Alexander Ganz, Chunshan Lin, Mian Zhu Abstract We propose a novel mechanism to generate primordial magnetic fields (PMFs) strong enough to explain the observed cosmic magnetic fields. We employ a scalar field charged under U(1) gauge symmetry with a non-trivial VEV to provide an effective mass term to the EM field and thus break its conformal invariance. The primordial magneto-genesis takes place in the radiation dominated (RD) epoch, after the electroweak symmetry breaking (EWSB) phase. As a result, our mechanism is naturally free from the over-production of electric fields due to high conductivity in the RD epoch, and the baryon isocurvature problem which takes place only if magneto-genesis happens before the ESWB phase. In addition, we find that a significant amount of PMFs can be generated when the scalar field experiences a tachyonic phase. In this case, the scalar field is light and weakly coupled and has negligible energy density compared to the cold dark matter, hence the strong coupling problem and the back-reaction problem are also absent. Therefore, our model is free from the above-mentioned problems that frequently appear in other primordial magneto-genesis scenarios. 1 Introduction Observations have confirmed the ubiquitous nature of magnetic fields Durrer:2013pga . Nonetheless, the origin of cosmic magnetic fields is still unclear. Observational signatures of magnetic fields in inter-galactic void regions Neronov:2010gir ; Tavecchio:2010ja ; Tavecchio:2010mk ; Taylor:2011bn imply a cosmological origin of large-scale magnetic fields, due to the difficulty to account for them in astrophysical mechanisms Bondarenko:2021fnn . Understanding the origin of large-scale magnetic fields is a longstanding problem. The blazar observations suggest that the strength of magnetic fields with a coherence length of a few Mpc should be larger than 10^{-15} Gauss Finke:2015ona ; MAGIC:2022piy . It is generically believed that primordial magneto-genesis before the structure formation sources the seed magnetic field, which, after astrophysical dynamo and compression amplification mechanisms, forms the large-scale magnetic field observed today, see Brandenburg:2004jv ; Subramanian:2015lua for a review. The strength of the seed magnetic field remains unclear due to uncertainties in the details of the dynamo mechanisms, which typically vary from 10^{-12} G to 10^{-22} G Kandus:2010nw ; Vachaspati:2020blt . It is difficult to produce such magnetic seeds through the primordial magneto-genesis process within classical electromagnetism and conventional cosmology Turner:1987bw . Inflation is believed to be a major candidate for the production of a large-scale magnetic field. Over the past years, vast inflationary magneto-genesis models have been proposed in the literature Garretson:1992vt ; Dolgov:1993vg ; Gasperini:1995dh ; Bamba:2003av ; Bamba:2006ga ; Martin:2007ue ; Kanno:2009ei ; Byrnes:2011aa ; Barnaby:2012tk ; Domenech:2015zzi ; Patel:2019isj ; Durrer:2022emo ; Sasaki:2022rat . All of these models share a key ingredient, namely, the breaking of conformal invariance Turner:1987bw . One of the most well-studied ideas is the Ratra theory Ratra:1991bn , in which a scalar field couples to the field strength f(\phi)^{2}F_{\mu\nu}F^{\mu\nu} . Most of these models potentially suffer from the strong coupling problem BazrafshanMoghaddam:2017zgx or the back reaction problem Green:2015fss . Additionally, a recent study reveals an overproduction of baryon isocurvature perturbations in any magneto-genesis scenario above the electroweak (EW) scale Kamada:2020bmb , arguably ruling out most inflationary magneto-genesis scenarios. In this paper, we propose a novel mechanism free from all the above problems. We will instead consider a new scalar field charged under U(1) gauge symmetry, and the conformal invariance is broken due to the effective mass term of the electromagnetic (EM) field generated due to a non-trivial vacuum expectation value (VEV) of the scalar. The magnetic field is then induced by the scalar currents in the early universe. In contrast to the previous work we assume that the scalar field is very light and is extremely weakly coupled, and therefore, the scalar particles are not thermalized before the EW scale. Very weakly coupled fermion particles (milli charged particles) have been extensively discussed in the literature as a potential candidate for dark matter GOLDBERG1986151 ; Cheung:2007ut and could arise as a low-energy limit of a new light U(1)^{\prime} gauge field which kinetically mixes with the Standard Model (SM) U(1) . The baryon isocurvature problem becomes irrelevant as long as the magneto-genesis takes place below the EW scale. In the literature, the condition is conventionally fulfilled by working in a low-scale inflation scenario Ferreira:2014hma ; Fujita:2016qab ; Kobayashi:2019uqs ; Yanagihara:2023qvx , namely the reheating temperature is way below the EW scale, at the cost of being contrary to the standard thermal history of the universe. In our work, we instead assume that the magneto-genesis happens in the standard radiation dominated epoch 1 1 1 See also e.g., Ref. Papanikolaou:2023nkx . . The problem of baryon isocurvature can be evaded as long as the primordial magnetic field is generated after the electroweak symmetry breaking (EWSB) phase, without altering the standard thermal history of our universe. Additionally, in the radiation dominated epoch, the universe is effectively a plasma, in which the induced electric field is diluted away by the high conductivity. Thus, we will not need to worry about the over-production of electric fields. One may worry about the feasibility of producing sufficient magnetic fields in our setup, as the inflationary magnetogenesis in scalar QED theory is argued to be ineffective Mazzitelli:1995mp ; Finelli:2000sh ; Davis:2000zp ; Bassett:2000aw ; Emami:2009vd . For instance, Ref. Emami:2009vd reports a seed magnetic field of order 10^{-29} G on \mathcal{O}(1){\rm Mpc}^{-1} scale from the coupling of inflaton with gauge field, which is marginally acceptable assuming a highly efficient astrophysical amplification mechanism. In radiation dominated epoch things may become worse due to the existence of high conductivity. We will show that a significant amount of primordial magnetic fields can be generated in the radiation dominated epoch without the back-reaction problem, provided that the scalar field experiences a tachyonic growth phase. Thus, our formalism provides a viable mechanism for generating large scale magnetic field without all problems mentioned above. We organize the paper as follows. We present our model in Sec. 2 . The general formalism of induced magnetic field is discussed in Sec. 3 . In Sec. 4 , we analyze the power spectrum of magnetic field when the scalar field is tachyonically amplified. We explicitly calculate the magnetic field when the magneto-genesis takes place before and after the electron-positron annihilation in Sec. 5 and Sec. 6 respectively. We show that the seed magnetic field from the interaction with the scalar field can be compatible to observations and conclude in Sec. 7 . Throughout this manuscript, the scalar field \phi takes mass dimension, and the fine structure constant is dimensionless such that the vector potential A_{\mu} has mass dimension. The normal and conformal magnetic field shall carry [M]^{2} dimension. The conformal time is denoted by \tau . Unless specified, a prime shall denote the differentiation with respect to \tau . 2 Our Model We work with the following action S=\int d^{4}x\sqrt{-g}\left[\frac{M_{p}^{2}}{2}\mathcal{R}-\frac{1}{2}\left(D_{\mu}\phi\right)^{\dagger}D^{\mu}\phi-V(\phi,\chi)+\mathcal{L}_{\chi}-\frac{1}{4}F_{\mu\nu}F^{\mu\nu}+\mathcal{L}_{bg}\right]~. (1) with D_{\mu}\equiv\partial_{\mu}-i\varrho A_{\mu} and \mathcal{R}/2 the Einstein-Hilbert action. The parameter \varrho is the effective coupling constant between the scalar field and the U(1) gauge field. The term \mathcal{L}_{\chi} represents the Lagrangian of an auxiliary scalar field \chi , which we shall explain in Sec. 4.2 . The complex scalar field \phi is coupled to the auxiliary field \chi via the