Work statistics and thermal phase transitions

Kwai-Kong Ng, Min-Fong Yang · 2025

Read Work statistics and thermal phase transitions by Kwai-Kong Ng, Min-Fong Yang (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-05826.txt.

Introduction

Kwai-Kong Ng and Min-Fong Yang ask whether the work done on a quantum system can betray its phase changes, in a 2025 paper. Quantum work is a statistical quantity, unlike its classical twin. Earlier work showed work statistics flag quantum phase changes after sudden quenches. Heat-driven changes, though, had gone untested.

The pair studied a hard-core boson model through three kinds of thermal transition: Ising, three-state Potts, and the swirling BKT kind. Careful scaling of finite systems showed work statistics track the critical behavior in each case. The result extends a quantum tool to everyday heat-driven change. It hints work records could read critical points across many-body physics.

Catalog record

CREATORKwai-Kong Ng, Min-Fong Yang
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE35 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-05826

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Work statistics and thermal phase transitions Kwai-Kong Ng, Min-Fong Yang Abstract The investigation of nonequilibrium thermodynamics in quantum many-body systems underscores the importance of quantum work, which differs from its classical counterpart due to its statistical nature. Recent studies have shown that quantum work can serve as an effective indicator of quantum phase transitions in systems subjected to sudden quenches. However, the potential of quantum work to identify thermal phase transitions remains largely unexplored. In this paper, we examine several types of thermal phase transitions in a sudden-quench hard-core boson model, including Ising, three-state Potts, and Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless transitions. Through finite-size scaling analysis, we conclude that work statistics can also characterize the critical behaviors of thermal phase transitions in generic many-body systems. Our investigation paves the way for applying work statistics to characterize critical behavior in many-body systems, with implications that may extend to broader contexts. I INTRODUCTION Investigating nonequilibrium thermodynamic properties of quantum many-body systems is a complex and demanding task. Quantum work, a concept rooted in the principles of quantum mechanics and thermodynamics, has emerged as a crucial area of study for understanding non-equilibrium quantum systems. Unlike its classical counterpart, quantum work is a fluctuating quantity that requires a statistical approach. This has led to the development of the two-point measurement scheme, where work is defined as the difference in energy between initial and final measurements on a quantum system Talkner_etal2007 . All the available statistical information about quantum work W is contained in the distribution function p(W) defined for work statistics. Not only being important for understanding fundamental thermodynamics, quantum work also provides valuable insights into quantum phase transitions (QPTs), where a system’s ground state changes qualitatively due to variations in controlling parameters Silva2008 ; Mascarenhas_etal2014 ; Sharma-Dutta2015 ; Campbell2016 ; Paganelli-Apollaro2016 ; Fei_etal2020 ; Zawadzki_etal2020 ; Varizi_etal2020 ; Zhang-Quan2022 ; Gu_etal2022 ; Zawadzki_etal2023 ; Lin-Huang2024 . (For a recent review, see Ref. review2018 .) In this context, researchers have particularly focused on the sudden-quench scenario, wherein the system parameters are subjected to an abrupt change. It is established in Ref. Mascarenhas_etal2014 that, analogous to the latent heat of classical phase transitions, the average work \langle W\rangle=\int dW\,p(W)\,W done per quench exhibits a discontinuity at first-order QPT points. For second-order QPTs, the average work \langle W\rangle changes continuous at the transition points. In contrast, particularly for weak sudden quenches, the irreversible work \langle W_{\mathrm{irr}}\rangle=\langle W\rangle-\Delta F (with \Delta F being the free energy difference after and before quench) diverges at the critical point Mascarenhas_etal2014 . Thus, both average work and irreversible work can serve as indicators for revealing QPTs without requiring prior knowledge of order parameters or symmetries. Furthermore, analyzing the scaling behavior of irreversible work can aid in understanding the universality classes of QPTs Sharma-Dutta2015 ; Paganelli-Apollaro2016 . These conclusions arise from the close relationship between average work and the first derivative of ground-state energy with respect to the quench parameter, and between irreversible work and the second derivative. The validity of quantum work in characterizing the quantum criticality of many-body systems has been corroborated by previous studies across various systems Silva2008 ; Mascarenhas_etal2014 ; Sharma-Dutta2015 ; Campbell2016 ; Paganelli-Apollaro2016 ; Fei_etal2020 ; Zawadzki_etal2020 ; Varizi_etal2020 ; Zhang-Quan2022 ; Gu_etal2022 ; Zawadzki_etal2023 ; Lin-Huang2024 ; review2018 . Most early investigations focused exclusively on QPTs, which take place only at or near absolute zero temperature. This is because thermal fluctuations generally obscure the nonanalytic behaviors associated with QPTs, thereby diminishing the effectiveness of work statistics in characterizing the criticality of many-body systems at finite temperatures. Nevertheless, the authors in Ref. Zhang-Wu2022 challenge this notion. They examine two solvable models, the Dicke model and the Lipkin-Meshkov-Glick model, from which analytic expressions for the average work \langle W\rangle in the thermodynamic limit can be derived. They find that \langle W\rangle displays a cusp at thermal phase transitions, indicating a nonanalyticity in its derivatives that arises solely from thermal fluctuations. Their conclusions suggest that quantum work statistics can also be employed to identify thermal phase transitions. However, generic many-body systems are usually not analytically solvable, making numerical calculations on finite-sized systems the only feasible approach. Due to finite-size effects, the cusps in the average work of limited-sized systems may become smeared. Consequently, it raises the question of whether a precise determination of thermal phase transition points can still be attained using this approach. In this paper, we address this issue by examining a hard-core boson model on both square and triangular lattices with nearest-neighbor hopping and repulsion Batrouni-Scalettar2000 ; Hebert_etal2001 ; Schmid_etal2002 ; Wessel-Troyer2005 ; Heidarian-Damle2005 ; Melko_etal2005 ; Boninsegni-Prokofev2005 . The models under consideration can exhibit several types of thermal phase transitions, including melting transitions characterized by Ising or three-state Potts universality, as well as normal-superfluid transitions of the Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless (BKT) type Schmid_etal2002 ; Boninsegni-Prokofev2005 . Here, we employ the widely used quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) method known as the stochastic series expansion (SSE) algorithm QMCreview to measure the average work \langle W\rangle and its temperature derivative \partial\langle W\rangle/\partial T . As discussed in the Appendix, the SSE method provides a direct estimate of \partial\langle W\rangle/\partial T based on the operator sequence from the simulation, thereby avoiding any additional noise that could arise from numerically differentiating the average work. Through the analysis of finite-size scaling Goldenfeld ; Cardy , we demonstrate that the temperature derivative of quantum work can effectively detect and differentiate between different types of second-order thermal phase transitions and accurately locate their critical points. More interestingly, we find that this approach can also be applied to infinite-order BKT transitions Berezinskii1971 ; Kosterlitz-Thouless1973 . Our results thus confirm the general validity of quantum work in characterizing the criticality of many-body systems. The remainder of this paper is organized as follows. The relationship between average work and free energy for systems subjected to sudden quenches is discussed in Sec. II . We then derive the finite-size scaling for the average work and its derivative with respect to temperature. In Sec. III , we introduce our model and the characteristics of the thermal phase transitions it encompasses. We then present our QMC results for the average work and its temperature derivative associated with these transitions. We conclude our paper in Sec. IV . The Appendix explains how the temperature derivative of average work can be measured directly based on the operator sequence from the simulation. II quantum work around thermal phase transitions II.1 Average work and its temperature derivative Unlike some conservative quantities, quantum work is not an observable and will depend on the microscopic details/paths of the non-equilibrium process. Due to its stochastic nature, the work performed on a finite system is described by a distribution function defined by the following two-point measurement scheme Talkner_etal2007 . Let us consider a quantum system described by the Hamiltonian H(\lambda) with \lambda being a time-dependent externally controllable parameter. At the beginning, the system with an initial value \lambda is prepared in a mixed state \rho_{0}=e^{-\beta H(\lambda)}/\mathrm{Tr}[e^{-\beta H(\lambda)}] in equilibrium with a heat bath at an inverse temperature \beta=1/T . The initial thermal equilibrium state is then decoupled from the bath and the controlling parameter is tuned to its final value \lambda^{\prime}=\lambda+\delta , such that the subsequent time evolution of the system is

Read the complete text