Proper constituent gluon mass as the final piece to construct hybrid
Zi-Xuan Ma 1, Qi Huang 1, Li-Ming Wang 2, Xiao-Huang Hu 3, Yue Tan 4, Jun He 1, Hong-Xia Huang 1 · 2025
Read Proper constituent gluon mass as the final piece to construct hybrid by Zi-Xuan Ma 1, Qi Huang 1, Li-Ming Wang 2, Xiao-Huang Hu 3, Yue Tan 4, Jun He 1, Hong-Xia Huang 1 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-05818.txt.
Introduction
Zi-Xuan Ma and co-authors propose a set gluon mass to identify hybrid mesons in this 2025 paper. Hybrid mesons mix quarks with a real gluon, unlike ordinary mesons. Telling a true hybrid from a normal state is a long puzzle in particle physics.
The team argue that one well-chosen gluon mass makes the sorting work. They test it on light hybrids with unusual quantum numbers. Their results cast doubt on two famous candidates as pure hybrids. They also predict a new hybrid state and name the decay channels to hunt it in. Collider teams at BESIII and elsewhere can run those searches. A confirmed prediction would validate the whole approach.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Zi-Xuan Ma 1, Qi Huang 1, Li-Ming Wang 2, Xiao-Huang Hu 3, Yue Tan 4, Jun He 1, Hong-Xia Huang 1 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 50 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-05818
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Proper constituent gluon mass as the final piece to construct hybrid Zi-Xuan Ma 1, Qi Huang 1, Li-Ming Wang 2, Xiao-Huang Hu 3, Yue Tan 4, Jun He 1, Hong-Xia Huang 1 Abstract After treating hybrid as a three-body system, we recalculate the spectra and decay widths of the 1 − + 1^{-+} light hybrids via the Gauss Expansion Method (GEM). Our result shows that, after adding into only one more parameter m g m_{g} =450 MeV, i.e., the constituent gluon mass, we can reproduce nearly all the results in our previous work by just using the model parameters from meson spectra calculation, which shows the unification of Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD). As a result, π 1 ( 1600 ) \pi_{1}(1600) and η 1 ( 1855 ) \eta_{1}(1855) may not be explained as 1 − + 1^{-+} hybrids simultaneously, and the η 1 ( 1855 ) \eta_{1}(1855) observed by BESIII may not be a hybrid. In addition, we predict an existence of a hybrid η 1 ( 1640 ) \eta_{1}(1640) , which can be verified by searching the a 1 ( 1260 ) π a_{1}(1260)\pi channel. Furthermore, to search for an isospin-0 and an isospin- 1 2 \frac{1}{2} hybrid, the golden channels may be K 1 ( 1270 ) K ¯ K_{1}(1270)\bar{K} and K 1 ( 1270 ) π K_{1}(1270)\pi , respectively. I Introduction As the fundamental theory of strong interaction, Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD) reveals us all the possible interactions between quarks, anti-quarks, and gluons. Thus, theoretically, it can present us explanations on nearly all the phenomena in strong interaction field. However, due to the complex mathematical structure of this theory itself, direct calculations that based on the first principle are usually too difficult to carry on. As a result, various phenomenological models that obey the basic requirements of QCD are successfully proposed, which stands for our further understandings on the strong interactions. Among these QCD based phenomenological models, potential model is one of the most successful ones, where quark model, one-gluon exchange potential that directly derived from QCD Lagrangian, and a phenomenological description on color confinement are combined together. After considering different modifications such as Goldstone boson exchange Vijande:2004he ; Yang:2011rp ; Chen:2024ukv ; Yang:2017rmm ; Huang:2015uda , hidden local symmetry He:2023ucd ; He:2023gqh , scalar meson exchange Yang:2017qan ; Vijande:2009pu ; Tan:2022pzi , semi-relativistic or relativistic Oettel:2000uw ; Aslanzadeh:2017hhz ; Godfrey:1985xj ; Capstick:1986ter , unquenched effects Tan:2019qwe ; Ni:2025gvx ; Ni:2023lvx ; Santopinto:2010zza ; Bijker:2012zza ; Cardoso:2014xda , etc., a global description on the spectra of traditional hadrons (mesons and baryons) can be actually well obtained. Especially, for the low-lying states, their masses can be very nicely reproduced Vijande:2004he ; Yang:2011rp ; Chen:2024ukv ; He:2023gqh . However, with the rapid development of experiments, there appears a large number of hadronic states that cannot be contained into the traditional quark model, although their existences are permitted by QCD. Among these states, one kind of the convincible ones might be those with exotic quantum numbers. For example, three J^{PC}=1^{-+} states \pi_{1}(1400/1600) E852:1998mbq ; CrystalBarrel:2019zqh ; JPAC:2018zyd ; Kopf:2020yoa ; IHEP-Brussels-LosAlamos-AnnecyLAPP:1988iqi ; Aoyagi:1993kn ; E852:1997gvf ; VES:2001rwn ; CrystalBarrel:1998cfz ; Meyer:2010ku ; Baker:2003jh ; Khokhlov:2000tk ; COMPASS:2009xrl ; CLEO:2011upl , \pi_{1}(2015) E852:2004gpn ; E852:2004rfa , and a new iso-scalar state \eta_{1}(1855) that was observed by the BESIII Collaboration in the J/\psi\to\gamma\eta\eta^{\prime} process BESIII:2022riz ; BESIII:2022iwi . Apparently, with the experimental observations of these three states, the classification of them naturally becomes an issue in the community. Nowadays, there are two main opinions for their interpretations, one is the tetraquark state Chen:2008qw ; Wan:2022xkx ; Dong:2022cuw ; Yang:2022rck ; Yan:2023vbh , the other is hybrid Narison:1999hg ; Shastry:2022mhk ; Chen:2023ukh ; Iddir:1988jd ; Benhamida:2019nfx ; Eshraim:2020ucw ; Zhang:2025xee ; Dudek:2010wm ; Qiu:2022ktc ; Chen:2022qpd , or a mixture of tetraquark and hybrid Narison:2009vj . The conception of tetraquark state is actually a simple generalization of the quark model, which means the hadron is composed by four constituent quarks. While hybrid is a little different, as this kind of state is composed by serval valence quarks and gluons, where the simplest case is q\bar{q}g . Thus, for hybrid, here instantly comes a question, i.e., how we understand constituent gluon, and at least, where is the location of its proper mass. As we have mentioned before, the application of QCD on the potential model can reproduce spectra of low-lying traditional hadrons well. Thus, considering the unification of QCD, we believe that if we have proper constituent gluon mass, after adding it into the potential model, together with interaction between (anti-)quark, we should give proper explanations or predictions on the hybrids without modifying the model parameters in quark model anymore (or do a fine-tuning at most), especially for the low-lying hybrids. Fortunately, studies on the effective mass of gluon had already been carried out Binosi:2012sj ; Binosi:2022djx ; Ding:2022ows . As a result, it is pointed in Refs. Binosi:2012sj ; Binosi:2022djx ; Ding:2022ows that gluons can be massive via Schwinger mechanism, i.e., non-perturbative effect of the gauge field itself will bring a correction into the gluon propagator and resulting into a mass term, and it is extracted to be m_{g}\approx\frac{1}{2}m_{p} , with m_{p} being the mass of proton. Moreover, it brings us that for quarks, the effective masses are m_{u/d}\approx\frac{1}{3}m_{p} , m_{s}\approx 500 MeV, etc. Binosi:2022djx . Obviously, these effective masses of up/down and strange quarks that Schwinger mechanism presents us are very close to the commonly used values in constituent quark model. Since in QCD Lagrangian, there is only one global coupling constant, it naturally makes us believe that m_{g} may be the last piece to construct the hybrid spectrum. Thus, following the spirit of constituent quark model, in this work, we treat gluon as a constituent and take q\bar{q}g hybrid as a three-body system. As our first trial, we recalculate the spectra of low-lying hybrids in the light sector with quantum number J^{PC}=1^{-+} , where the other model parameters are kept the same as the ones adopted in meson spectra calculations. Furthermore, we calculate their two body strong decays at leading order. It shows that after taking m_{g}\approx\frac{1}{2}m_{p} as Schwinger mechanism gives Binosi:2012sj ; Binosi:2022djx ; Ding:2022ows as the only additional parameter, our results are very consistent with the corresponding ones in our previous work Zhang:2025xee , although the calculation methods on spectra are totally different. As if it is just a coincidence, we will make more verifications in different systems in future works. This work is organized as follows, after the introduction, a brief presentation of our model will be given in Sec. II. Then the numerical results and relevant discussions will be given in Sec. III. Finally, this work will end up with a summary. II Model setup After taking into account the gluon as a constituent, under the framework of potential model, our treatment on the hybrid then becomes a three-body problem like baryon, whose coupling scheme can be given by Fig. 1 . Figure 1: The coupling scheme of hybrid (left) and the interaction between quark and gluon (right). Here, in left panel, the T-type solid lines means that quark and antiquark couple first to form a (q\bar{q})