Spontaneous vortex crystal formation in classical rotating flows

Gabriel Marchetti and Pablo D. Mininni · 2025

Read Spontaneous vortex crystal formation in classical rotating flows by Gabriel Marchetti and Pablo D. Mininni (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-05637.txt.

Introduction

Gabriel Marchetti and Pablo Mininni simulate rotating classical fluids to see whether vortex crystals form on their own. Such ordered vortex lattices are known in superconductors and superfluids, and have been guessed at in Jupiter's polar air. The team ran direct simulations of the Navier-Stokes equations in rotating frames, varying the shape of the domain.

Metastable crystals did emerge by themselves. Their lifetime tracked dissipation, and a scaling law links rotation rate, domain shape and lattice spacing. A sharp threshold in the Rossby number marked the change, much like a phase transition. Energy spectra and vortex shapes helped explain how the crystals form and evolve.

Catalog record

CREATORGabriel Marchetti and Pablo D. Mininni
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE41 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-05637

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Spontaneous vortex crystal formation in classical rotating flows Gabriel Marchetti and Pablo D. Mininni Abstract Vortex crystals, ordered structures observed in superconductors and rotating superfluids, have also been hypothesized to form in classical fluids, based on numerical simulations and observations of the Jovian polar atmospheres. We perform direct numerical simulations of the Navier–Stokes equations in rotating frames, to investigate the spontaneous emergence of metastable vortex crystals. We analyze the energy spectrum, vortex morphology, and spatio-temporal dynamics to understand their roles in crystal formation and evolution. In addition, we explore domains with varying aspect ratios to examine their impact on the vortex lattice. Our results indicate a relationship between the crystal lifespan and dissipation, and we propose a scaling law linking the rotation rate, domain geometry, and vortex lattice periodicity. Finally, we identify a critical threshold in the control parameter, the Rossby number, suggesting a behavior similar to that found in phase transitions. I Introduction Nonlinearity is one of the defining features of fluid dynamics, especially in the turbulent flow regime. Turbulence encompasses a myriad of interacting structures spanning a broad range of spatial and temporal scales. This property leads to disorder and chaotic behavior that is unrepeatable from one experiment to the next, yet with repeatable statistics. However, it is not only disorder that governs turbulent flows, but also order. Self-organization mechanisms in turbulence have been a subject of study for several decades, and in recent years have been observed in a variety of configurations Kraichnan and Montgomery 1980 ; Huang and Driscoll 1994 ; Fine et al. 1995 ; Jiménez and Guegan 2007 ; Xia et al. 2011 ; Sen et al. 2012 ; Adriani et al. 2018 ; Pouquet et al. 2017 ; Alexakis et al. 2024 . In this process, the chaotic motion of small eddies results in spontaneous macroscopic order. Canonical examples of this phenomenon include the inverse energy cascade and the energy condensate in two-dimensional flows Kraichnan and Montgomery 1980 ; Boffetta and Ecke 2012 and in space plasmas Hossain 1991 ; Mininni et al. 2005 ; Alexakis et al. 2006 ; Mininni 2007 . The spontaneous appearance of order has recently been understood as analogous to phase transitions in thermodynamic systems, governed by a system control parameter Biferale et al. 2017 ; Alexakis and Biferale 2018 . However, with the exception of condensates in ideal flows Kraichnan and Montgomery 1980 , the self-organization in forced and viscous cases take place in conditions that are far from equilibrium and where traditional thermodynamic ideas do not apply. Rotating flows provide an interesting example of inverse energy cascades and self-organization. The theory of rotating turbulence has been developed in detail Waleffe 1993 ; C. Cambon and N. N. Mansour and F. S. Godeferd 1997 ; Cambon et al. 2004 , and in the limit of infinite rotation and for infinite domains, two-dimensional modes are decoupled from three-dimensional modes which transfer their energy solely to smaller scales. Ideal truncated rotating flows also lack a condensate in their statistical equilibrium, displaying only thermalization of the energy, and disorder Mininni et al. 2011a . However, for finite rotation and in finite domains inverse energy cascades develop Smith and Waleffe 1999 ; Sen et al. 2012 ; Campagne et al. 2014 ; Buzzicotti et al. 2018 . This results in the formation of strong columnar vortices. While the stability of columnar structures in rotating flows can be understood in terms of the Proudman–Taylor theorem Davidson 2013 , it is the nonlinearity that is responsible for their formation in the dynamical case. As a result, energy injected at intermediate scales is transferred both to large and small scales, with some energy leaking from three-dimensional modes to two-dimensional modes, resulting in a partial flow bi-dimensionalization Waleffe 1993 ; Smith and Waleffe 1999 ; Sen et al. 2012 ; Alexakis and Biferale 2018 . These picture has been confirmed in experiments Campagne et al. 2014 , which showed that while rapidly rotating turbulence in finite domains results mainly in an inverse cascade of energy to large scales, at intermediate rotation strengths a split cascade develops in which energy is transferred in both directions, and eventually for sufficiently low rotation energy only goes to smaller scales. A remarkable example of organized states in this context is given by vortex crystals. Recently, self-organized metastable states of vortex crystals in rotating flows were observed in Clark Di Leoni et al. 2020 . The parameters that control the lattice formation, size, and stability are unclear, as the inverse energy cascade in rotating turbulence is expected to always proceed to the largest available scale instead of being arrested at some intermediate scale. But the resulting vortex lattice is reminiscent of other vortex crystals observed in condensed matter. Perhaps the most typical example of such vortex crystals is given by Bose-Einstein condensates Newton and Chamoun 2009 ; Fetter 2009 , particularly in magnetic vortices in superconductors Brandt 1986 , and in vortices in rotating superfluids and gaseous condensates Fetter 2009 ; Abo-Shaeer et al. 2001 ; Peretti et al. 2023 ; Amette Estrada et al. 2022 . These crystals organize in triangular lattices, commonly referred to as Abrikosov lattices. Vortex crystals have also been observed in some classical flows. Beside the case of classical rotating flows described in Clark Di Leoni et al. 2020 , examples are provided by electron systems subjected to a magnetic field with a large relaxation time Huang and Driscoll 1994 ; Fine et al. 1995 , two-dimensional turbulent flows in which a balance of deterministic and random forcing was used to sustain a stable vortex crystal in a background vorticity Jiménez and Guegan 2007 , and chiral liquid crystals Fernandez-Gonzalez et al. 2024 . Recently, vortex crystals were also reported in fluids with odd viscosity de Wit et al. 2024 . And observations of stable vortex arrays were reported by NASA Juno probe in the Jovian polar atmospheres Adriani et al. 2018 . This polar structures feature vortices with cyclonic behavior arranged in rotationally symmetric patterns, with the north pole featuring eight cyclones orbiting a central one, while the north pole features five cyclones. In this work, we study the spontaneous formation of vortex crystals in rotating flows. Our main objective is to identify under what conditions flows develop ordered vortex crystals by varying the physical parameters of the system, and to identify the parameters that control the lattice spatial periodicity and stability. To this end, we perform direct numerical simulations (DNSs) of the Navier-Stokes equations in a rotating frame. We consider the main three regimes observed in rotating flows, including cases with an inverse cascade of energy, a direct cascade of energy, and a flux-loop regime Clark Di Leoni et al. 2020 in which the inverse cascaded energy returns to smaller scales resulting in accumulation of energy at intermediate scales. Normal viscosity is used, which results in DNSs with moderate Reynolds numbers, but allows us to quantify the role of physical viscosity in the lattice stability. We consider the time evolution of the flow kinetic energy, as well as its spectrum, to identify regimes in which the inverse energy cascade stalls at an intermediate scale between the forcing scale and the largest scale in

Read the complete text