Hybrid Schrödinger-Liouville and projective dynamics

Kaja Krhac, Frederic P. Schuller, Stefano Stramigioli · 2025

Read Hybrid Schrödinger-Liouville and projective dynamics by Kaja Krhac, Frederic P. Schuller, Stefano Stramigioli (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-05532.txt.

Introduction

Kaja Krhac, Frederic Schuller, and Stefano Stramigioli reframe how quantum systems change when they are measured, in a 2025 paper. Between measurements, a quantum state evolves smoothly under a known equation. At a measurement, that smooth flow stops and is replaced by a sudden jump to a new state.

The authors show that both parts can be written as a single differential equation, if the space of states is refined in the right way. That single form lets standard tools from systems and control theory apply to the full process. The work is theoretical, and it aims to make quantum dynamics easier to analyse and to steer with port-based methods used in engineering. For specialists, it bridges two languages that are often kept apart.

Catalog record

CREATORKaja Krhac, Frederic P. Schuller, Stefano Stramigioli
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE28 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-05532

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Hybrid Schrödinger-Liouville and projective dynamics Kaja Krhac, Frederic P. Schuller, Stefano Stramigioli Abstract Quantum dynamics provides the arguably most fundamental example of hybrid dynamics: As long as no measurement takes place, the system state is governed by the Schrödinger-Liouville differential equation, which is however interrupted and replaced by projective dynamics at times when measurements take place. We show how this alternatingly continuous and projective evolution can be cast in form of one single differential equation for a refined state space manifold and thus be made amenable to standard port-theoretic analysis and control techniques. keywords Synthesis of stochastic systems, hybrid systems, quantum theory, information, port, Dirac structure Accepted for the Proceedings of the 5th IFAC Workshop on Control of Systems Governed by Partial Differential Equations 2025 1 Introduction The axiomatic formulation of quantum mechanics takes a mathematically seemingly trivial form – namely as a theory of linear operators on finite-dimensional complex Hilbert spaces – if one restricts attention to quantum systems without translational degrees of freedom. The physics of this class of quantum systems (the simplest of which are those employing a two-dimensional Hilbert space and play a fundamental role as so-called qubits in cutting-edge technological applications, see Nielsen and Chuang (2012) ) is, however, as rich as the physics of those systems that require an infinite-dimensional Hilbert space. This class is thus an ideal test bed for theoretical investigations and we will use it as such. The point we wish to address in this article is the logically impeccable, but technically patchy, description of the temporal evolution of a quantum state (described by a positive operator of unit trace) by way of two alternating dynamics, according to the axiomatic formulation of the theory: As long as no measurement takes place, the evolution of a generically mixed quantum state \hat{\rho} (of a materially and energetically isolated quantum system) is postulated to be governed by the Schrödinger-Liouville equation \dot{\hat{\rho}}(t)=-i[H,\hat{\rho}(t)]\,, where H is a hermitian operator that doubles as the measurement operator for the energy of the system and [A,B]:=AB-BA . As soon as a (non-degenerate) measurement takes place, however, this continuous evolution is interrupted in favour of an instantaneous and discontinuous change of the quantum state \hat{\rho} to the new state that can be predicted, ex ante , to be \sum_{z}P_{z}\hat{\rho}P_{z}\,, where z ranges from 1 to the dimension of the Hilbert space and the P_{z} are mutually orthogonal hermitian projectors uniquely determined by the spectral decomposition M=\sum_{z}m_{z}P_{z} of the hermitian operator M that mathematically abstracts and represents the physical measurement apparatus. Its spectrum \{m_{z}\} encodes all possible measurement outcomes that the apparatus could display. Another ex ante prediction are the probabilities \textrm{tr\,}(P_{z}\hat{\rho}) for the different possible measurement outcomes m_{z} to be obtained in any one particular performance of the measurement if the quantum state right before the measurement is \hat{\rho} . We emphasize that the above-described prediction of the discontinuous state change upon measurement is only the ex ante predictable part of the infamous collapse of the quantum state upon measurement. The full collapse, in contrast, cannot be predicted ex ante , but only be described ex post , meaning only after an actual measurement has already taken place and the actual measurement outcome m_{\textrm{\tiny obs}} is already known. Indeed, it is postulated that, ex post , the quantum state after the measurement is best described by \frac{P_{\textrm{\tiny obs}}\hat{\rho}P_{\textrm{\tiny obs}}}{\textrm{tr\,}(P_{\textrm{\tiny obs}}\hat{\rho}P_{\textrm{\tiny obs}})} than by the (however statistically compatible) ex ante prediction we laid out before. The technical purpose of this article is to reformulate the ex ante aspect, but not at all the ex post aspect, of the quantum measurement postulates, together with the continuous Schrödinger-Liouville evolution in the absence of measurements, in terms of one single differential equation on a refined quantum state space that combines classical and quantum degrees of freedom. It will turn out that a such refined framework allows for a complete absorption of the ex ante aspects of the measurement axioms into equally refined dynamics of the system and, thus, for a careful separation of the classical information about a quantum system from its quantum state. This reformulation provides the conceptual and technical foundation for a port-theoretic formulation of quantum theory including measurement (see van der Schaft and Jeltsema (2014) and Duindam et al. (2009) for classical physics and Krhac (2023) for the case of quantum physics without measurement) and the transfer of related control techniques. 2 Refined quantum kinematics The refined kinematics and dynamics presented in this and the following section go back to ideas and results of Diósi (2014) and Poulin and Preskill (2017) in the finite-dimensional case and have since been generalised to the infinite-dimensional case, in pursuit of a novel attempt to address the still elusive question of how quantum matter couples to the gravitational field; see Oppenheim et al. (2022) , Oppenheim et al. (2023) , Oppenheim (2023) and further references therein. Let \mathcal{H} be a d -dimensional complex Hilbert space underlying the quantum aspects of a system and Z:=\{1,\dots,d\} a discrete classical state space which, in the following, we will link to the possible classical measurement outcomes of any given measurement apparatus for that quantum system. The state space \mathcal{S}(\mathcal{H},Z) of a quantum-classical hybrid system of dimension d is then given by the set of maps \rho:Z\to L^{+}_{[0,1]}(\mathcal{H}) from a classical state space Z to the set L^{+}_{[0,1]}(\mathcal{H}) of positive semi-definite operators on \mathcal{H} whose trace lies in the interval [0,1] , provided that \sum_{z\in Z}\textrm{tr}(\rho(z))=1\,. (1) In order to see in what sense these hybrid states capture both the classical and the quantum nature of the state of any measurement apparatus for a quantum system with a finite-dimensional Hilbert space, it is convenient to consider three physically relevant quantities that are induced by any given hybrid state \rho . The first induced quantity is the induced quantum state \hat{\rho}:=\sum_{z\in Z}\rho(z)\,, which is a positive-semidefinite unit trace operator of \mathcal{H} due to ( 1 ). The other two induced quantities are the induced classical probabilities for the classical states and the potential collapsed quantum states p(z):=\textrm{tr\,}\rho(z)\qquad\textrm{and}\qquad\hat{\rho}_{\textrm{collapse}}(z):=\frac{\rho(z)}{\textrm{tr\,}\rho(z)} associated with each classical state z\in Z . Note that \hat{\rho} and all \hat{\rho}_{\textrm{collapse}}(z) are semi-definite and unit trace operators, while the p(z) are real numbers in the interval [0,1] for each z\in Z . The physical interpretation of all three quantities is exhibited by the trivial identity \hat{\rho}=\sum_{z\in Z}p(z)\hat{\rho}_{\textrm{collapse}}(z)\,, where p(z) is the probability for the measurement apparatus to show the classical state z , \hat{\rho}_{\textrm{collapse}}(z) is the quantum state if the classical state is z and \hat{\rho} is the mixed state that encodes all one can predict about the measurement without reading off the classical measurement outcome. The hybrid state combines all this quantum and classical information in one quantity. 3 Refined quantum dynamics Now consider a differentiable curve \rho:\mathbb{R}\to S(\mathcal{H},Z) in hybrid state space. For a thus described time-dependent hybrid state, the most general completely positive linear dynamics preserving the normalisation condition ( 1 ) are given by the Diósi-Poulin equation ( Diósi (2014) , Poulin and Preskill (2017) ) \frac{\partial\rho}{\partial t}(z,t)=\sum_{\alpha,\beta=0}^{d^{2}-1}\sum_{y\in Z}\big[W^{\alpha\beta}(z,y,t)L_{\alpha}\rho(y,t)L_{\beta}^{*}-\\ \tfrac{1}{2}W^{\alpha\beta}(y,z,t)(L_{\beta}^{*}L_{\alpha}\rho(z,t)+\rho(z,t)L_{\beta}^{*}L_{\alpha})\big]\,, (2) with the particular dynamics of a hybrid system depending on the choice of maps W^{\alpha\beta}(t):Z\times Z\to\mathbb{C} which for every time t\in\mathbb{R} must satisfy the two positive-semi-definiteness

Read the complete text