Assessing the Role of Intrinsic Variability in Black Hole Parameter Inference using Multi-Epoch EHT Data
Dominic O. Chang, Michael D. Johnson, Paul Tiede · 2025
Read Assessing the Role of Intrinsic Variability in Black Hole Parameter Inference using Multi-Epoch EHT Data by Dominic O. Chang, Michael D. Johnson, Paul Tiede (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-05472.txt.
Introduction
Dominic Chang and co-authors test how a black hole's flickering glow distorts the measurements drawn from its portrait, in a 2025 paper. The Event Horizon Telescope imaged the black hole in galaxy M87 across several years. The plasma around it churns, so each year's image differs, and simple models may misread the differences as changed physics. The team fit a semi-analytic cone model of the glowing plasma to multiple epochs.
The black hole's mass-to-distance ratio came out stable and consistent between years despite visibly different images. Spin stayed unconstrained in both epochs, even with better coverage in the later data. The inferred tilt and orientation of the spin axis disagreed between years, which the authors blame on variability plus model limits. They stress that repeated imaging is essential to price in this uncertainty honestly.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Dominic O. Chang, Michael D. Johnson, Paul Tiede |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 22 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-05472
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Assessing the Role of Intrinsic Variability in Black Hole Parameter Inference using Multi-Epoch EHT Data Dominic O. Chang, Michael D. Johnson, Paul Tiede Abstract Event Horizon Telescope (EHT) observations of M87* provide a means of constraining parameters of both the black hole and its surrounding plasma. However, intrinsic variability of the emitting material introduces a major source of systematic uncertainty, complicating parameter inference. The precise origin and structure of this variability remain uncertain, and previous studies have largely relied on general relativistic magnetohydrodynamic (GRMHD) simulations to estimate its effects. Here, we fit a semi-analytic, dual-cone model of the emitting plasma to multiple years of EHT observations to empirically assess the impact of intrinsic variability and improved array coverage on key measurements including the black hole mass-to-distance ratio, spin, and viewing inclination. Despite substantial differences in the images of the two epochs, we find that the inferred mass-to-distance ratio remains stable and mutually consistent. The black hole spin is unconstrained for both observations, despite the improved baseline coverage in 2018. The inferred position angle and inclination of the black hole spin axis are discrepant between the two years, suggesting that variability and model misspecification contribute significantly to the total error budget for these quantities. Our findings highlight both the promise and challenges of multi-epoch EHT observations: while they can refine parameter constraints, they also reveal the limitations of simple parametric models in capturing the full complexity of the source. Our analysis – the first to fit semi-analytic emission models to 2018 EHT observations – underscores the importance of systematic uncertainty quantification from intrinsic variability in future high-resolution imaging studies of black hole environments and the role of repeated observations in quantifying these uncertainties. I Introduction Black holes are the central engines of Active Galactic Nuclei (AGN), giving rise to observable structures seen over many orders of magnitude in scale ( Blandford et al. 2019 ) . Many of these phenomena are engendered by processes that originate on sub-parsec scales and propagate out to influence larger structures. The smallest scale structures likely occur near the event horizon of the central supermassive black hole. Here, strong relativistic effects lead to image features that encode information about the black hole and its environment, and these can now be studied directly using images with very long baseline interferometry (VLBI). Strong-field gravitational lensing, for example, gives rise to a characteristic dark depression – the black hole’s apparent shadow – whose size can be used to determine the mass-to-distance ratio ( \theta_{\rm g} ) of the black hole ( Falcke et al. 2000 ; EHTC et al. 2019 ; EHTC et al. 2022 ) . This inference provides an independent and complementary approach to stellar and gas dynamical modeling techniques ( Gebhardt et al. 2011 ; Walsh et al. 2013 ; Jeter & Broderick 2021 ; Liepold et al. 2023 ; Simon et al. 2023 , e.g.,) . M87 ∗ has long been an ideal candidate for the study of AGN since its angular size and luminosity allow it to be studied over a vast range of length scales and across the entire electromagnetic spectrum ( EHT MWL Science Working Group et al. 2021 ; Algaba et al. 2024 , e.g.,) . Recently, the near-horizon structure of M87 ∗ has been imaged using observations with the Event Horizon Telescope (EHT) in 2017 and 2018 ( EHTC et al. 2019a ; EHTC et al. 2019b ; EHTC et al. 2019c ; EHTC et al. 2019d ; EHTC et al. 2019e ; EHTC et al. 2019f ; EHTC et al. 2024 ; EHTC et al. 2025 ) . Using these observations, the EHT Collaboration (EHTC) estimated \theta_{\rm g}=3.62^{+0.41}_{-0.34}\;\mu as from a combined data study over the two observed epochs ( EHTC et al. 2025 ) . Chang et al. 2024 recently re-analyzed the 2017 EHT observations of M87 ∗ using Bayesian inference techniques with a dual-cone synchrotron jet model, leading to estimates of \theta_{\rm g} within the range of (2.84,3.75)\;\mu as to 95\% confidence. Both measurements are consistent with the stellar dynamics measurements of M87 ∗ from Gebhardt et al. 2011 , \theta_{\rm g}=3.62\pm 0.22\;\mu as, and from Liepold et al. 2023 , \theta_{\rm g}=3.16^{+0.22}_{-0.15}\;\mu as. 1 1 1 Both works report mass measurements for M87 ∗ that we have converted to \theta_{\rm g} assuming a distance of D=16.8\,{\rm Mpc} ( EHTC et al. 2019f ) . The EHTC uses a geometric modeling technique to estimate \theta_{\rm g} , relating it to specific image features. In particular, the diameter of the observed ring is correlated with the mass of the black hole. However, it can also be sensitive to the observing resolution, black hole spin, and the geometry of the emitting region. The EHTC quantified systematic uncertainties from these additional effects using a library of General Relativistic Magnetohydrodynamic (GRMHD) simulations and an associated “ \alpha -calibration” procedure ( EHTC et al. 2019 ; EHTC et al. 2022 ) . This procedure relates the ring diameter d in each simulated image to the mass-to-distance ratio via a calibration factor, \alpha=d/\theta_{\rm g} . The distribution of \alpha across a suite of simulations defines an approximation of the systematic uncertainty in this mapping, but a limitation of this procedure is its reliance on simulations. Chang et al. 2024 , in contrast, employed a more direct procedure in which a simple dual-cone emission model is fit directly to the EHT data. This model includes parameters of the black hole such as \theta_{\rm g} and those that describe the average emission properties. A major limitation of this procedure is that it does not include any estimates of the uncertainties arising from intrinsic source variability, which corresponds to misspecification for the underlying emission model. Here, we extend the analysis of Chang et al. 2024 to explore the effects of source variability on parameter inference by repeating the analysis for two independent EHT observations of M87 ∗ , in 2017 and 2018. Because the images in these two epochs are notably different, especially in a shift of the peak ring brightness, this approach provides an empirical estimate for the systematic uncertainty and bias arising from intrinsic variability. In Section II , we summarize the dual-cone model and define its parameters. In Section III , we describe the EHT observations of M87 ∗ in 2017 and 2018 used in this study and our approach to parameter inference using the EHT data. In Section IV , we summarize our results. II Description of the model Dual-Cone Model Parameters Classification Parameter Description \theta_{\rm g} Mass-to-distance ratio ( \mu as) Black Hole a Black hole dimensionless spin and Observer \theta_{\rm o} Observer inclination with respect to black hole spin axis (deg.) p.a. Position angle of projected spin axis on observer’s screen (deg.) \theta_{s} Cone opening angle (deg.) R Characteristic radius of intensity profile (\text{GM}/c^{2}) p_{1} Inner exponent of intensity profile Accretion p_{2} Outer exponent of intensity profile and \chi Fluid velocity azimuthal angle in ZAMO frame (deg.) Emission \iota Magnetic field orthogonality angle in fluid frame (deg.) \beta_{v} Fluid speed in ZAMO frame ( c ) \sigma Spectral index of emission \eta Magnetic field tangential angle in fluid frame (deg.) Table 1: Parameters of the dual-cone model. Four parameters define