A simulation modeling framework for fluid motion and transport in a rocking bioreactor with application to cultivated meat production

Minki Kim, Daniel M. Harris, Radu Cimpeanu · 2025

Read A simulation modeling framework for fluid motion and transport in a rocking bioreactor with application to cultivated meat production by Minki Kim, Daniel M. Harris, Radu Cimpeanu (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-05421.txt.

Introduction

Minki Kim, Daniel Harris, and Radu Cimpeanu build a 2025 computer model of fluid motion in a rocking bioreactor, with grown meat as the use case. Rocking bags mix cell cultures with a gentle wave. They are cheap, disposable, and easy to scale, but their inner flow is not well mapped across the many shapes and settings in use.

Their frame solves the flow and the movement of dissolved substances in a rectangular bag. It measures mixing time and oxygen transfer under varied conditions. Both link strongly to a steady drift inside the rocking flow. The team also found the shift from smooth to turbulent flow and settings that trigger resonance, which boosts mixing and oxygen transfer.

Catalog record

CREATORMinki Kim, Daniel M. Harris, Radu Cimpeanu
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE87 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-05421

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A simulation modeling framework for fluid motion and transport in a rocking bioreactor with application to cultivated meat production Minki Kim, Daniel M. Harris, Radu Cimpeanu Abstract Rocking or wave-mixed bioreactors have emerged as a promising innovation in the production of cultivated meat due to their disposable nature, low operating costs, and scalability. However, despite these advantages, the performance of rocking bioreactors is not well characterized in view of their relatively short history in the market and the wide range of geometrical and operating parameters. In the present study we develop a rigorous computational framework for this multiphase multi-physics system to quantitatively evaluate mixing, oxygen transfer, and shear stress within a rectangular rocking bioreactor under various operating conditions. This framework is implemented using the Basilisk open-source platform. We use a second-order finite volume Navier-Stokes solver and a volume-of-fluid interface reconstruction scheme to accurately resolve the highly nonlinear fluid motion. By solving the advection-diffusion equation for a multi-fluid system, we examine mixing time and the oxygen mass transfer coefficient ( k L ​ a k_{L}a ) for different operating conditions, both of which show a strong relationship with steady streaming underlying the instantaneous laminar flow. We further highlight two critical hydrodynamic phenomena that significantly influence bioreactor performance. Firstly, we investigate the transitional regime from laminar to turbulent flow. Moreover, we identify specific operating conditions that trigger resonance within the bioreactor, enhancing mixing and oxygen transfer. We finally discuss the potential effects of shear stress and energy dissipation rate on cell survival. Our findings are expected to provide valuable insights and guidelines for designing optimized bioreactors to support the next-generation cultivated meat industry pipelines. Journal: International Journal of Multiphase Flow 1 Introduction Conventional livestock production has been recognized as a primary contributor to habitat and biodiversity loss ( Machovina et al., 2015 ; Zabel et al., 2019 ) , as well as water and nutrient pollution ( Poore and Nemecek, 2018 ) and food-related greenhouse gas emissions ( Poore and Nemecek, 2018 ; Xu et al., 2021 ) . Their environmental impacts are recognized as significant drivers of climate change and threats to the sustainability of our planet. In response, cultivated meat, also known as lab-grown or cell-based meat, has emerged as a promising and environmentally friendly alternative to traditional meat production ( Santo et al., 2020 ) . In 2023, the United Nations highlighted the growing demand for animal source foods, underscoring their potential to mitigate environmental impacts, reduce carbon dioxide emissions, and address animal welfare concerns ( United Nations Environment Programme, 2023 ) . A significant milestone was achieved in November 2022 when the first regulatory approval for cultivated meat was granted in the United States. Following this, the United States Food and Drug Administration approved Upside Foods for its cultivated chicken, which became commercially available in June 2023 ( Food and Administration, 2023 ) . This regulatory approval is expected to accelerate the integration of sustainable alternatives, such as cultivated meat, into the meat production industry. While these advancements mark significant progress, technical and economic challenges remain before such alternatives can become a mainstream commodity ( Humbird, 2021 ) . One of the primary barriers is scaling up production to an industrial level, which is constrained by several factors, including slow cell growth rates, low final cell densities due to catabolic inhibition, and the high capital costs associated with aseptic operation. Addressing these challenges through continued innovation and process optimization will be critical to fully realizing the potential of cultivated meat within the food industry. In the manufacturing process of cultivated meat, bioreactors play a crucial role in cultivating animal cells in an oxygen-rich culture medium and facilitating cell differentiation to form muscle tissue. The cultivated cells are then harvested and processed into final meat products. Various types of bioreactors have been employed ( Rivera and Chen, 2022 ) , including stirred tank ( Liu, 2012 ; Bach et al., 2017 ; Wodołażski, 2020 ; Kahouadji et al., 2022 ) , rocking or wave-mixed ( Singh, 1999 ; Eibl et al., 2010 ; Junne et al., 2013 ) , airlift ( AL-Mashhadani et al., 2015 ; Mutaf and Oncel, 2023 ) , hollow fiber ( Mohebbi-Kalhori et al., 2012 ) , and rotary wall types ( Cinbiz et al., 2010 ) . They are used not only for animal cell cultivation but also for applications such as algae growth ( Duan and Shi, 2014 ) , microbial fermentation ( Gill et al., 2008 ) , and stem cell expansion ( King and Miller, 2007 ) . Among these, rocking or wave-mixed bioreactors have emerged as a particularly promising innovation owing to their disposable nature, cost-effectiveness, and scalability. In 1999, Singh (1999) first introduced a rocking or wave-mixed bioreactor system, demonstrating cultivation in volumes up to 100 L. The use of a disposable cellbag as the primary culturing structure allows for quick setup and flexibility in establishing new production facilities ( Eibl et al., 2010 ; Junne et al., 2013 ) . In addition, by inducing gentle liquid motions, rocking bioreactors reduce shear damage ( Singh, 1999 ; Junne et al., 2013 ) , in contrast to other bioreactor types such as stir-mixed and airlift bioreactors. These conventional systems rely on mechanical mixers and sparger-induced bubbles, which pose a higher risk of causing damage to cultured cells. In the design of rocking bioreactors, several key factors–oxygen transfer, mixing, shear stress, and energy dissipation rate–play a critical role in cell cultivation. Aerobic microorganisms, such as mammalian cells, rely on oxygen for their metabolic activities, making it essential to maintain sufficient oxygen levels in the medium to support cell growth. Efficient mixing is crucial for the uniform distribution of oxygen, nutrients, temperature, and even cells within the medium, allowing for continuous cell cultivation. However, excessive shear stress and high energy dissipation rates can cause physical damage or alterations in cell behavior, particularly in delicate cells, such as mammalian cells. Therefore, a careful balance of oxygen supply, mixing, shear stress, and energy dissipation rate are necessary to create a healthy and effective cultivation environment while reducing the risk of cell damage. Several experimental studies have investigated methodologies for accurately characterizing rocking bioreactor performance. Mixing time and oxygen mass transfer rates were experimentally measured using a fluorescent tracer dye and an oxygen-sensitive dye to visually assess mixing and dissolved oxygen in water, a technique referred to as the “classic dynamic method” ( Singh, 1999 ) . More recently, Bai et al. (2019a) employed the acidic tracer method, introducing a pH solution into the medium and evaluating solution homogeneity by monitoring local pH changes with a probe. They also used a dissolved oxygen probe to measure local oxygen concentrations, similar to Singh (1999) . Bartczak et al. (2022) utilized local pH measurements to determine mixing time. While these studies have quantified mixing and oxygen supply metrics using tracers, the dependence on point-wise measurements introduces significant uncertainty due to the limited information regarding the overall tracer distribution within the medium. Furthermore, nearly all empirical scaling relations derived for mixing time and oxygen transfer rate under given operating conditions are tailored to turbulent flows. Thus, directly extending these findings to laminar and transitional flow regimes is not

Read the complete text