Neutrino properties from muonium-antimuonium mixing
Mitrajyoti Ghosh, Kevin Liguori, Takemichi Okui, Kohsaku Tobioka · 2025
Read Neutrino properties from muonium-antimuonium mixing by Mitrajyoti Ghosh, Kevin Liguori, Takemichi Okui, Kohsaku Tobioka (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-05378.txt.
Introduction
Mitrajyoti Ghosh and co-authors propose catching neutrinos in an atomic identity swap. Whether neutrinos are their own antiparticles, the Majorana possibility, or distinct from them, the Dirac one, remains unsettled, and the flagship test, a rare nuclear decay, can only ever confirm one side. Their 2025 paper examines muonium, an electron orbiting a positive muon, flipping into its antimatter twin, a process a planned experiment called MACE will chase.
The team recomputes the flip rate in the standard model extended with heavy neutrinos of either kind, taking care with the infrared scales earlier work mishandled. A symmetry cancellation crushes the pure Dirac rate. Loosening the mixing matrix's unitarity, they show, cannot rescue it without muddying the very property under test. A hybrid case, mostly Dirac with a whisper of Majorana mass, can lift the rate strongly, especially in one mass ordering.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Mitrajyoti Ghosh, Kevin Liguori, Takemichi Okui, Kohsaku Tobioka |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 59 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-05378
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Neutrino properties from muonium-antimuonium mixing Mitrajyoti Ghosh, Kevin Liguori, Takemichi Okui, Kohsaku Tobioka Abstract The nature of neutrino mass—whether neutrinos are Dirac or Majorana particles—remains one of the central open questions in particle physics. While observation of neutrinoless double beta decay would confirm the Majorana case, the absence of a signal offers no definitive insight. In light of this, we investigate muonium–antimuonium mixing—proposed for further study at the MACE experiment—as an alternative probe of neutrino properties. We compute the mixing amplitude in the Standard Model minimally extended to include massive Dirac or Majorana neutrinos, and correct previous calculations by properly treating the relevant infrared scales. As the GIM mechanism strongly suppresses the Dirac contribution, we explore whether relaxing unitarity of the PMNS matrix can enhance the mixing without obscuring neutrino properties. Surprisingly, the answer to this question is negative. We also examine the pseudo-Dirac case—predominantly Dirac neutrinos with small Majorana masses—and find that this scenario can significantly enhance the mixing compared to the pure Dirac case, especially for normal mass ordering. 1 Introduction One of the most important unanswered questions in fundamental physics is whether neutrinos are lepton number violating (Majorana) or conserving (Dirac) particles. The most popular experimental search that attempts to answer this question is neutrino-less double beta decay ( 0\nu\beta\beta ) KamLAND-Zen:2022tow ; GERDA:2020xhi . However, if the neutrinos are Dirac, 0\nu\beta\beta will not provide us with a positive confirmation but only the absence of Majorana signals. For an experimental observable that can positively distinguish between Dirac vs Majorana, we need an observable that conserves total lepton number ( \Delta L=0 ). In addition, to further access neutrino properties not elucidated by 0\nu\beta\beta , it would be desirable to violate lepton number for individual lepton species (i.e., \Delta L_{e,\mu,\tau}\neq 0 ). One candidate process is mixing between muonium ( \mathcal{M} ) and its CP conjugate state antimuonium ( \overline{\mathcal{M}} ), where \mathcal{M} ( \overline{\mathcal{M}} ) is a bound state of \mu^{+} and e^{-} ( \mu^{-} and e^{+} ). For the purpose of studying neutrino properties, muonium provides an especially clean probe free from hadronic physics, and is also experimentally accessible due to its appreciably long lifetime, which is the muon lifetime to very good approximation ParticleDataGroup:2024cfk ; Czarnecki:1999yj . \mathcal{M}\text{--}\overline{\mathcal{M}} mixing has been studied also in other interesting contexts Feinberg:1961zza ; Glashow:1961zz ; Swartz:1989qz ; Hou:1995dg ; Horikawa:1995ae ; Willmann:1998gd ; Endo:2020mev ; Conlin:2020veq ; Han:2021nod ; Fukuyama:2021iyw ; Petrov:2022wau . The Muonium Antimuonium Conversion Spectrometer (MACS) Willmann:1998gd experiment at the Paul Scherrer Institute (PSI) searched for \mathcal{M}\text{--}\overline{\mathcal{M}} conversion (for earlier searches see Amato:1968xyq ; Chang:1989uk ; Chatterjee:1992yi ; Huber:1988gu ; Matthias:1991fw ). Since no \mathcal{M}\text{--}\overline{\mathcal{M}} conversion was seen at MACS with \sim 10^{11} muonium decays collected, the experiment placed an upper bound on the conversion probability <8.3\times 10^{-11} . The proposed Muonium-to-Antimuonium Conversion Experiment (MACE) Bai:2024skk aims to gather 10^{14} muonium decays to probe muonium conversion probabilities down to 10^{-13} . \mu^{+} e^{-} e^{+} \mu^{-} \nu_{i} \nu_{j} a A Dirac type diagram \mu^{+} e^{-} \mu^{-} e^{+} \nu_{i} \nu_{j} b A Majorana type diagram Figure 1 : Examples of the Feynman diagrams that contribute to \mathcal{M}\text{--}\overline{\mathcal{M}} mixing via neutrinos. Arrows represent the flow of lepton number. On the left is a “Dirac type” diagram where lepton number is conserved on each fermion line, while on the right is a “Majorana type” diagram where lepton number is violated on each fermion line by the Majorana mass. In the Standard Model (SM) minimally extended with neutrino masses, \mathcal{M}\text{--}\overline{\mathcal{M}} mixing occurs via one or both types of box diagrams shown in Fig 1 . The diagram in Fig. 1a is what we call a “Dirac type” diagram, where lepton arrows are preserved. Fig. 1b is what we refer to as a “Majorana type” diagram, where the lepton arrows are not preserved. In both diagrams, the total lepton number is conserved, \Delta L=0 . However, the muon and electron numbers are not individually conserved, \Delta L_{e,\mu}\neq 0 . If neutrinos are Dirac, only the Dirac type diagrams contribute to the mixing, whereas for Majorana neutrinos both Dirac and Majorana type diagrams contribute. A glance at Fig. 1 tells us that the Majorana type diagram goes as G_{F}^{2}\sum_{i,j}(U^{*}_{ej})^{2}U_{\mu i}^{2}m_{j}m_{i} while the Dirac type goes as G_{F}^{2}(\sum_{i}U^{*}_{ei}U_{\mu i}m_{i}^{2})^{2}/m_{\mu}^{2} , where U_{\alpha i} ( \alpha=e,\mu,\tau , i=1,2,3 ) denote components of the PMNS matrix ( U_{\mathrm{PMNS}} ). Note that for the Dirac type diagrams the amplitude would vanish by the unitarity of U_{\mathrm{PMNS}} if we did not pick up m_{i}^{2} . A calculation of the mixing amplitude exists in the literature Clark:2003tv ; Fukuyama:2021iyw for Majorana neutrinos; however, these previous calculations incorrectly handled IR scales and hence are parametrically incorrect. We will address this issue. The relative smallness of the Dirac type mixing amplitude compared to the Majorana type is a direct consequence of the unitarity of U_{\mathrm{PMNS}} . Since we do not expect the unitarity of U_{\mathrm{PMNS}} to be an exact property in the presence of new physics, there could be contributions without any powers of neutrino mass in the Dirac amplitude. It is then natural to ask if relaxing this rigid requirement of a unitary PMNS matrix could lead to an enhancement in the \mathcal{M}\text{--}\overline{\mathcal{M}} conversion probability. Further, Dirac neutrinos may well have small Majorana components (i.e., pseudo-Dirac). In this case, we expect the amplitude to go as the square of the small Majorana components, which could be larger than the above Dirac estimate. We will investigate these interesting and important questions. We organize the rest of the article as follows: In Sec. 2 , we discuss \mathcal{M}\text{--}\overline{\mathcal{M}} conversion from a macroscopic viewpoint without considering the internal structure of muonium. In particular, we identify appropriate amplitudes necessary to describe \mathcal{M}\text{--}\overline{\mathcal{M}} mixing. In Sec. 3 , we calculate those amplitudes from the Dirac type and Majorana type box diagrams. In Sec. 4 we then apply the results to obtain the conversion probabilities for Majorana, Dirac and pseudo-Dirac. We also address the question of whether relaxing the unitarity of U_{\mathrm{PMNS}} leads to an enhancement in the rate for Dirac neutrinos. We make concluding remarks in Sec. 5 . In the appendix we provide a modern treatment of interpolating a bound state using the fundamental fields of the SM. 2 Muonium-antimuonium mixing formalism In this section, we concern ourselves with an effective description of the production, propagation, and detection of (anti)muonium without going into microscopic details. We begin by representing the creation of an \mathcal{M} at a muonium source S , and its subsequent propagation and detection as an \mathcal{M} or \overline{\mathcal{M}} at a detector D or \bar{D} , respectively. That is, we would like to study the following effective quadratic lagrangian: \mathcal{L}=\dot{\phi}^{\dagger}\dot{\phi}-\tilde{M}^{2}\phi^{\dagger}\phi-\frac{\Sigma_{21}}{2}\phi\phi-\frac{\Sigma_{12}}{2}\phi^{\dagger}\phi^{\dagger}+S\phi^{\dagger}+D\phi+\bar{D}\phi^{\dagger}\,, (1) where \phi is the muonium field with \tilde{M}\equiv M-\mathrm{i}\Gamma/2 encapsulating the muonium mass M and width \Gamma that we would have in the absence of \mathcal{M} – \overline{\mathcal{M}} mixing. We work in the muonium rest frame and suppress the dependence on the muonium polarization. This is possible because the \mathcal{M}\text{--}\overline{\mathcal{M}} amplitude is independent of the polarization in the rest frame, as we will discuss later. \mathcal{M} – \overline{\mathcal{M}} mixing is described by \Sigma_{21} and \Sigma_{12} , where the former is the 1PI self-energy with an ingoing \mathcal{M} and an outgoing \overline{\mathcal{M}}