What We Do Not Know: GPT Use in Business and Management
Tammy Mackenzie, Branislav Radeljić, Leslie Salgado, Animesh Paul, Rubaina Khan, Aizhan Tursunbayeva, Natalie Perez, Sreyoshi Bhaduri · 2025
Read What We Do Not Know: GPT Use in Business and Management by Tammy Mackenzie, Branislav Radeljić, Leslie Salgado, Animesh Paul, Rubaina Khan, Aizhan Tursunbayeva, Natalie Perez, Sreyoshi Bhaduri (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-05273.txt.
Introduction
Tammy Mackenzie and co-authors review what research actually knows about GPT use in business and management, in a 2025 paper. They searched peer-reviewed studies from the first 22 months after GPT's release. For all the public talk, they found only 42 studies that fit. The work spreads thinly across finance, marketing, human resources, strategy, operations, production, and analytics.
No sector or subfield yet has enough evidence for firm claims about how the tools are used. The authors list open questions on jobs, productivity, energy costs, fairness, and small firms. They also suggest how consultants and journalists can help fill the gaps. The paper closes as a call for much more research, including work on control systems for AI risks in firms.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Tammy Mackenzie, Branislav Radeljić, Leslie Salgado, Animesh Paul, Rubaina Khan, Aizhan Tursunbayeva, Natalie Perez, Sreyoshi Bhaduri |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 47 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-05273
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
What We Do Not Know: GPT Use in Business and Management Tammy Mackenzie, Branislav Radeljić, Leslie Salgado, Animesh Paul, Rubaina Khan, Aizhan Tursunbayeva, Natalie Perez, Sreyoshi Bhaduri Abstract This systematic review examines peer-reviewed studies on application of GPT in business management, revealing significant knowledge gaps. Despite identifying interesting research directions (best practices, benchmarking, performance comparisons, social impacts), our analysis yields only 42 relevant studies for the 22 months since its release. There are so few studies looking at a particular sector or subfield that management researchers, business consultants, policymakers, and journalists do not yet have enough information to make well-founded statements on how GPT is being used in businesses. The primary contribution of this paper is a call to action for further research. We provide a description of current research and identify knowledge gaps on the use of GPT in business. We cover the management sub-fields of finance, marketing, human resources, strategy, operations, production, and analytics, excluding retail and sales. We discuss gaps in knowledge of GPT’s potential consequences on employment, productivity, environmental costs, oppression, and small businesses. We propose how management consultants and the media can help fill those gaps. We call for practical work on business control systems as they relate to existing and foreseeable AI-related business challenges. This work may be of interest to managers, to management researchers, and to people working on AI in society. K eywords AI, \cdot GPT, \cdot strategy, \cdot management science, \cdot policymaking, \cdot tech journalism, \cdot consultancy, \cdot business control systems, \cdot finance, \cdot marketing, \cdot human resources 1 Introduction Decision-makers such as business leaders and policymakers face a series of hard questions on the emergence and wide diffusion of artificial intelligence tools in businesses. Management scholars have called for more research. This study specifically considers “GPT,” since its public release in November 2022 has made the tool widely accessible and available to a large populous. GPT is the commercial product of a company called OpenAI, and its name is an acronym for “Generative Pretrained Transformer.” It is a large language model (LLM) AI system, including the ChatGPT series and GPT interfaces for making applications (collectively, “GPT”). Among other things, it can make complete sentences, produce reports, respond to questions, provide images and video, provide translations, and assist in coding and other data analysis. It also makes mistakes and has no self-awareness. However, as rightly assessed by Sliż (2024: 4) [ 1 ] , “[d]espite a substantial increase in publications on GPT, research avenues exploring its implementation potential in management methodologies like BPM (business process management) remain underexplored, prompting the need for focused investigation.” Addressing this underexplored research area could offer transformative advancements in process management. Management science is a social science, which relies on trustworthy information being transmitted with high fidelity [ 2 ] . While relying on honor and bravery, it also provides for checks and balances on the (in)directly involved actors and their policy preferences [ 3 ] . Accordingly, peer-reviewed studies in management can have a variety of study designs, such as case-study, action research, surveys, ethnographies, and reviews or position papers [ 4 , 5 ] . While position papers consider the available evidence to give recommendations, empirical papers engage with different phenomena with the goal of shedding light on potential effects. This review seeks to provide a greater insight into GPT- and LLM-related business challenges, including the effect of AI tools on employment, the environmental costs of AI use, and the cultural discrimination embedded in AI systems. Knowing more about these aspects is also helpful to consultants because of their remit in the handling of management challenges [ 6 ] . More worrisome, some unscrupulous people may make unsubstantiated claims [ 7 ] . Therefore, this research aims to assist consultants who do evidence-based work and empower people working in trade and scholarly research to collaborate on researching AI in business. This paper is of interest to managers, consultants, policymakers, researchers and journalists interested in the impact of GPT on business, for example in finance, marketing, human resources, and so on. Business managers and public decision-makers whom management researchers inform, and without whom management science would arguably be pointless [ 8 ] , face a lot of hard questions about technology and AI tools in general. Society is engaged in the project of AI as a socio-technical infrastructure. Understanding the challenges of AI in businesses is key to improving practices and preparing for further change. As such, this research is conducted and presented to be useful to people from industry and academia, and invites consultants and the media to collaborate with scholars in building our common knowledge. 2 The State of the Debate By many accounts, we are facing a crisis in management, through abuse of power or authority [ 9 ] in relation to 1/the standard of living and life expectancy of money [ 10 ] , 2/ the widespread impression that some view money as more important than other people [ 11 ] , or 3/ the tendency of some business leaders to use their businesses as cover for doing harm [ 12 ] . Drucker’s canonical contribution to the field of management science [ 8 ] , both in terms of research methods or applicability of management, remains pertinent to today’s challenges, most notably that the focus of the firm must be on the creation of customer value and, because of the impression that “culture eats strategy for breakfast,” one has to be a part of the firm to adequately guide it. Moreover, Drucker was also concerned about how time affects the quality of the information we can garner from social science, joining others [ 4 , 2 ] in affirming that management science is necessarily a reflective, not a predictive practice. Though well-rebutted by [ 13 ] , Drucker’s critics say that his theories may have been too unspecific, inapplicable, or based on an overly rational view of the world. We decline to join that debate. At the same time, these factors behoove us to humility in asking questions that are appropriate to the tools and context, and inform the scope and discussion of the present study. In brief, drawing from the above-mentioned scholars, the following characteristics are assumed of peer-reviewed scholarly research: (a) good will and intent of the authors; (b) study design that is appropriate to the question; (c) highest consideration of the latest ethical standards; (d) use of accurate data and possibility to reproduce the study; and (e) subject-matter specialists have verified and had the opportunity to criticize the claims, which can give rise to revisions. On the other hand, the nascent field of AI has been involved in some scientific controversies and potential pitfalls, relating to pertinence [ 14 ] , inapplicability [ 15 ] , researcher bias [ 16 ] , data manipulation [ 17 ] , hasty conclusions [ 18 ] , the influence of funders and politics [ 19 ] , self-serving or otherwise biased conclusions [ 20 , 21 ] , but also plagiarism [ 22 ] , papers-for-money (Liverpool, 2023), and faked or unsupervised GPT outputs [ 23 , 24 ] . Because of all this, each paper included in this review