Hollow Victory: How Malicious Proposers Exploit Validator Incentives in Optimistic Rollup Dispute Games

Suhyeon Lee · 2025

Read Hollow Victory: How Malicious Proposers Exploit Validator Incentives in Optimistic Rollup Dispute Games by Suhyeon Lee (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-05094.txt.

Introduction

Suhyeon Lee exposes a flaw in how blockchain dispute games pay their winners, in this 2025 paper. Optimistic rollups speed up chains like Ethereum by trusting block proposals unless challenged. Validators who prove a block wrong should earn part of the proposer's deposit. Lee shows that winners may walk away with little or no true profit.

A formal game model traces several scenes, including proposers who secretly control some validators. More competition among validators can, oddly, cut a bad proposer's losses. Auctions meant to draw challengers can be captured to the same end. Current designs may thus fail to scare off dishonest proposals. Fixes proposed include holding rewards in escrow and a commit-reveal step for challengers.

Catalog record

CREATORSuhyeon Lee
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE35 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-05094

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Hollow Victory: How Malicious Proposers Exploit Validator Incentives in Optimistic Rollup Dispute Games Suhyeon Lee Abstract Blockchain systems, such as Ethereum, are increasingly adopting layer-2 scaling solutions to improve transaction throughput and reduce fees. One popular layer-2 approach is the Optimistic Rollup, which relies security on a mechanism known as a dispute game for block proposals. In these systems, validators can challenge blocks that they believe contain errors, and a successful challenge results in the transfer of a portion of the proposer’s deposit as a reward. In this paper, we reveal a structural vulnerability in the mechanism: validators may not be awarded a proper profit despite winning a dispute challenge. We develop a formal game-theoretic model of the dispute game and analyze several scenarios, including cases where the proposer controls some validators and cases where a secondary auction mechanism is deployed to induce additional participation. Our analysis demonstrates that under current designs, the competitive pressure from validators may be insufficient to deter malicious behavior. We find that increased validator competition, paradoxically driven by higher rewards or participation, can allow a malicious proposer to significantly lower their net loss by capturing value through mechanisms like auctions. To address this, we propose countermeasures such as an escrowed reward mechanism and a commit-reveal protocol. Our findings provide critical insights into enhancing the economic security of layer-2 scaling solutions in blockchain networks. 1 Introduction Blockchain technology, and Ethereum in particular, has witnessed rapid growth in recent years. However, scalability and high transaction fees remain critical challenges. To address these issues, various layer-2 scaling solutions have been proposed, among which Optimistic Rollups have gained significant attention. Optimistic Rollups enable off-chain computation while relying on an on-chain dispute resolution mechanism to ensure correctness. In these systems, block proposals are accepted optimistically, and validators are empowered to challenge any block they believe to be incorrect through a process known as a dispute game . In a typical dispute game, a block proposer stakes a deposit and submits a block. Validators then monitor the block and, if they detect an error, submit a challenge. This challenge is called a fraud proof 1 1 1 It is also referred to as a fault proof by Optimism, one of the leading optimistic rollup teams. However, the term fraud proof appears to be more widely accepted among optimistic rollups. Therefore, throughout this paper, we will use the term fraud proof. . If the challenge is successful, the whole or a fraction of the proposer’s deposit is confiscated and awarded to the challenger. Ideally, this mechanism is meant to deter malicious behavior by imposing significant economic penalties on a proposer who submits an incorrect block. Conversely, if the validator loses the challenge, their deposit for the challenge will be forfeited and granted to the block proposer. However, if the incentive mechanism is not carefully calibrated, a malicious proposer might be able to limit his losses to only a small challenge fee even when many validators participate in challenging the block. It results in undermining the intended economic deterrence. In this paper, we model the dispute game using game-theoretic methods and analyze several attack scenarios with focusing on the malicious block proposer under a fraud proof challenge. We consider a case where the malicious proposer controls a subset of validators as well as cases in which a secondary auction is deployed to induce additional validator competition to get the dispute winner prize. Our analysis reveals that, under current incentive structures, the liveness of the dispute game may be insufficient to motivate them, thereby leaving the system vulnerable to strategic exploitation. Our contributions are as follows: • We develop a game-theoretic model of the dispute game in Optimistic Rollups, capturing the interactions between a malicious block proposer and validators under various challenge scenarios. • We identify a critical vulnerability: malicious proposers can strategically minimize their own financial losses after being challenged, while simultaneously exploiting validator competition in a way that can diminish the net profitability for challengers, weakening the overall security model. • We propose countermeasures, including an escrowed (deferred) reward mechanism and a commit-reveal protocol to rebalance the incentive structure and enhance the economic security of Optimistic Rollups. The rest of the paper is organized as follows: Section 2 reviews related work on dispute games and incentive mechanisms in layer-2 solutions. In Section 3 , we present our formal model of the Optimistic Rollup dispute game. Section 4 details the strategies a malicious proposer employ and introduces our proposed auction mechanism. Section 5 provides a game-theoretic analysis of the auction mechanism, including conditions under which validators are incentivized to participate. Section 6 proposes two countermeasures to solve this structural vulnerability. Finally, Section 7 discusses potential solutions and future research directions, and concludes the paper. 2 Related Works A variety of recent research has focused on understanding the economics and security of layer-2 scaling solutions. In this section, we review them particularly in the context of optimistic rollups. Economic and Incentive Analysis in Rollups. Early works in the economic analysis of rollups have focused on establishing robust security guarantees through well-aligned incentive mechanisms. Tas et al. [ 14 ] propose a framework for accountable safety in rollups, which emphasizes the need for designs that hold participants economically accountable for misbehavior. Li [ 8 ] further explores the security of optimistic blockchain mechanisms, highlighting the importance of ensuring that validator incentives are strong enough to deter malicious actions. In a similar vein, Mamageishvili and Felten [ 10 ] analyze incentive schemes for rollup validators, discussing strategies under the attention test. Data Availability Cost Optimization. Given that Optimistic Rollups are designed as a layer-2 scaling solution, minimizing the costs associated with data availability is a critical concern. Several studies have tackled this problem from different angles. Palakkal et al. [ 12 ] provide a systematization of compression techniques in rollups, outlining methods inefficiency in some rollups’ practice. Mamageishvili and Felten [ 9 ] propose efficient rollup batch posting strategies on the base layer using call data, while Crapis et al. [ 4 ] offer an in-depth analysis of EIP-4844 economics and rollup strategies including blob cost sharing. Complementary empirical investigations by Heimbach and Milionis [ 5 ] , Huang et al. [ 6 ] , and Park et al. [ 13 ] further document the inefficiencies in current DA cost structures and examine their impact on rollup transaction dynamics and consensus security. Lee [ 7 ] investigates blob sharing as a potential remedy for the dilemma faced by small rollups in the post-EIP-4844 era. Fraud Proof and Dispute Resolution Protocols. Prior research on fraud proofs in Optimistic Rollups has primarily focused on ensuring rapid dispute resolution and robust liveness. For example, BoLD [ 1 ] and Dave [ 11 ] propose protocols that optimize the dispute game to achieve low delays and cost-efficient on-chain verification, while Berger et al. [ 3 ] analyze economic censorship dynamics to guarantee that disputes are resolved even under adversarial conditions. While previous studies focus on ensuring the liveness of the dispute game, this paper present study concentrates on a different vulnerability: even when dispute games proceed smoothly, the existing incentive structure may fail to adequately reward honest validators, thereby allowing

Read the complete text