Surveying Professional Writers on AI: Limitations, Expectations, and Fears
Anastasiia Ivanova, Natalia Fedorova, Sergey Tilga, Ekaterina Artemova · 2025
Read Surveying Professional Writers on AI: Limitations, Expectations, and Fears by Anastasiia Ivanova, Natalia Fedorova, Sergey Tilga, Ekaterina Artemova (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-05008.txt.
Introduction
Anastasiia Ivanova and co-authors (2025) surveyed freelance professional writers about working with artificial intelligence. Three hundred one writers answered a questionnaire, and thirty-six took part in an interactive task. All used AI tools regularly in their work. The writers spanned more than twenty-five languages. The team asked about daily practice, ethics, and what the writers expect and fear.
Adoption turned out to be driven by peers and professional outlook more than by age or other demographics. Multilingual writers faced a double barrier: the tools perform worse in their languages, and others perceive their AI use more harshly. Fear for job security was widespread. Strikingly, it did not depend on how much a writer used AI. The authors argue that language equity and voice ownership deserve more attention as writing tools spread. The fears, they note, are structural rather than personal.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Anastasiia Ivanova, Natalia Fedorova, Sergey Tilga, Ekaterina Artemova |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 10 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-05008
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Surveying Professional Writers on AI: Limitations, Expectations, and Fears Anastasiia Ivanova, Natalia Fedorova, Sergey Tilga, Ekaterina Artemova Abstract The rapid development of AI-driven tools, particularly large language models (LLMs), is reshaping professional writing. Still, key aspects of their adoption such as languages support, ethics, and long-term impact on writers voice and creativity remain underexplored. In this work, we conducted a questionnaire ( N = 301 N=301 ) and an interactive survey ( N = 36 N=36 ) targeting professional writers regularly using AI. We examined LLM-assisted writing practices across 25+ languages, ethical concerns, and user expectations. The findings of the survey demonstrate important insights, reflecting upon the importance of: LLMs adoption for non-English speakers; the degree of misinformation, domain and style adaptation; usability and key features of LLMs. These insights can guide further development, benefiting both writers and a broader user base. 1 Introduction Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) have led to their adoption across various professional occupations. While research has explored the integration of AI chatbots in area such as research writing ( liao2024llms ) , software engineering ( stackoverflow2024 ), or creative industries ( guo2024pen ) , little attention has been paid to their adoption in professional writing. The latter can include e.g. journalism, corporate blogging, or technical writing. Since recently, LLMs in the form of AI chatbots have found their place among specialized tools for enhancing productivity of the writers and quality of their grammar and style. Still, their efficacy in practice is underexplored. In this study, we aim to analyze professional writers experience from using LLMs. To this end, we conduct a large-scale survey of professional writers. As noted by ( kellogg2018 ) , professional writing differs from general writing by requiring not only strong writing skills but also expertise in a specific genre or domain. Our survey focuses on non-fiction writers who are compensated for their work. The survey consists of two parts. First, we collect data from a questionnaire (N=301 respondents from 49 countries; see Figure 1 ) to understand best practices in AI chatbots adopted by professional writers, including the differences between writing in English and other languages, the limitations and expectations, and ethical concerns. Second, we conduct an interactive survey (N=36), in which writers showcase their best practices with LLMs. Based on the survey, we seek to answer the following research questions: RQ1. How do professional writers use AI chatbots? RQ2. How do AI chatbots impact professional writing tasks? RQ3. How useful are they in languages other than English? RQ4. Do they well-represent and respect cultural knowledge across different user backgrounds? RQ5. What are the main limitations writers face when using AI chatbots, and what improvements do they expect in the future? RQ6. What are the authors’ expectations and fears as to the impact of AI chatbots to their job security, text authorship rights and ethics in writing? Our findings in relation to these research questions highlight several important insights. However, a significant gap in performance across languages takes place, which makes multilingual users prefer English when interacting with AI chatbots. This highlights ongoing challenges in AI’s linguistic versatility. Moreover, the professional writing community is diverse, with varying opinions on key aspects of AI use. Writers differ in their views on AI’s role in authorship rights, its cultural and linguistic representation, and its potential impact on the future of the writing profession. To support further research, we release anonymized questionnaire data without personal information on GitHub 1 1 1 github.com/Toloka/surveying-prof-writers-on-ai . Figure 1: Perceived cultural representation in AI chatbots (N = 301) 2 Related work Human-AI Collaboration in Writing The proliferation of AI tools has sparked research into collaborative strategies with these systems across various domains. Academic writing has been a major focus, with studies exploring how researchers interact with AI ( fecher2023friend ; morris2023scientists ; liao2024llms ; monge2025investigating ) . These studies have explored common use cases in academic writing, from proofreading to collaborative brainstorming, as well as diverse techniques, ranging from prompt engineering to custom multi-tool pipelines. They also examine overall sentiment and perception, considering authorship, current limitations, and expectations for future AI-based tools. Similarly, creative writing has gathered significant attention, with recent studies of how AI can augment human creativity, provide unexpected twists, and help overcome writer’s block ( guo2024pen ; chakrabarty2024creativity ; wan2024felt ) . In professional writing, AI tools have become increasingly prevalent, assisting in various tasks. To name a few, LLM-powered generators like ChatGPT ( chatgpt ) and Gemini ( gemini2025 ) assist in efficient content creation. Grammar and style checkers such as Grammarly ( grammarly ) , quillbot , and hemingwayapp enhance writing by improving accuracy and consistency. A related line of research highlights the growing use of AI-assisted writing by professional writers in the corporate domain ( liang2025widespread ) and on social media ( sun2024we ) . Expectations and Limitations of Multilingual AI Users of multilingual large language models (LLMs) often encounter challenges that impact their experience. While these models may exhibit fluency and naturalness in non-English languages, they frequently struggle with deeper knowledge across diverse languages and cultures ( huang2024survey ; pawar2024survey ) . This issue arises because multilingual LLMs are predominantly trained on English-language data, leading to English-specific biases that can result in language inaccuracies ( shaib-etal-2024-detection ) , factual errors ( zhao-etal-2024-tracing ) , and a lack of cultural context in non-English outputs ( myung2024blend ) . Such shortcomings can lead to user dissatisfaction and disengagement, potentially creating inequities in technology adoption among multilingual users ( helm2023diversity ; wang2024understanding ; biswas2025mind ) . Previous studies have investigated user needs in language technologies, focusing on tools tailored for specific languages rather than a single chatbot or LLM, especially concerning native speakers of low-resource languages. These studies highlight a significant demand for tools that support native language input and effective machine translation systems ( Way2022Report ; blaschke-etal-2024-dialect ) . Additionally, entertainment and non-professional use have been identified as primary usage intents ( millour2019getting ) . Furthermore, proficiency in high-prestige, well-resourced languages often correlates with a reduced need or desire for technological support in other languages ( lent-etal-2022-creole ) . AI Impact and Ethical Challenges Sentiment towards AI in general and LLM-powered chatbots has been explored with respect to personality traits ( stein2024attitudes ) , professional occupation ( scott2021exploring ; ramadan2024facilitators ; stackoverflow2024 ; agyare2025cross ) , socio-demographic status ( rahman2024motivation ) , and across country-specific populations ( kelley2021exciting ; sindermann2021assessing ; lian2024public ; gnambs2025attitudes ) . AI adoption brings numerous benefits, including increased productivity and the potential in augmenting human creativity ( dell2023navigating ; lee2024empirical ) . Primary barriers to AI adoption are associated with potential ethical risks, including the spread of misinformation and fake news, organizational and governmental control and fear of job displacement ( wach2023dark ; augenstein2024factuality ; babiker2024attitude ) . Individuals in creative industries often express concerns about a lack of authorship feeling when using AI and show negative sentiment toward the inclusion of their work in pre-training data ( lovato2024foregrounding ; draxler2024ai ) . 3 Methodology Participant selection All participants in our study are verified writers on Toloka , a crowdsourcing platform for data labeling and high-quality annotation for downstream applications in generative AI. The writers engaged