Reducing quantum error correction overhead using soft information
Joonas Majaniemi, Elisha S. Matekole · 2025
Read Reducing quantum error correction overhead using soft information by Joonas Majaniemi, Elisha S. Matekole (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-03504.txt.
Introduction
Quantum computers drown their answers in measurement noise, but the raw measurement carries shades of gray that standard decoding throws away. Joonas Majaniemi and Elisha Matekole show in 2025 that this soft information can rescue error correction at smaller code sizes. They simulate soft decoding across hardware types and code families, including surface and bicycle codes.
Error suppression improved by up to eleven percent on superconducting qubits and twenty percent on neutral atoms. Those gains translate to thirteen and thirty-three percent smaller physical qubit footprints at a fixed logical error target. Soft decoding, they argue, cheapens the road to fault tolerance.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Joonas Majaniemi, Elisha S. Matekole |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 86 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-03504
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Reducing quantum error correction overhead using soft information Joonas Majaniemi, Elisha S. Matekole Abstract Imperfect measurements are a prevalent source of error across quantum computing platforms, significantly degrading the logical error rates achievable on current hardware. To mitigate this issue, rich measurement data referred to as soft information has been proposed to efficiently identify and correct measurement errors as they occur. In this work, we model soft information decoding across a variety of physical qubit platforms and decoders and showcase how soft information can make error correction viable at lower code distances and higher physical error rates than is otherwise possible. We simulate the effects of soft information decoding on quantum memories for surface codes and bivariate bicycle codes, and evaluate the error suppression performance of soft decoders against traditional decoders. Our simulations show that soft information decoding on near-term devices can provide up to 11 % 11\% higher error suppression on superconducting qubits and up to 20 % 20\% stronger error suppression on neutral atom qubits. These accuracy gains correspond to 13 % 13\% and 33 % 33\% reductions in the physical qubit footprint of superconducting and neutral atom devices respectively when operating at a logical error rate of 10 − 6 10^{-6} , showcasing that soft information is a powerful tool for reducing the cost and complexity of large-scale fault-tolerant quantum computers. I Introduction Quantum error correction (QEC) provides a pathway to high-fidelity operations on large-scale quantum computers [ 1 , 2 , 3 ] , a key requirement for reaching a quantum advantage on noise-limited hardware. Provided error rates in the underlying physical operations are below a certain threshold, QEC enables the encoding of higher-fidelity logical qubits into noisy physical qubits [ 4 ] . By increasing the physical qubit overhead, QEC achieves exponential suppression of errors in the logical qubits [ 5 ] . The extent of error suppression depends on the error correcting code chosen, the quality of the underlying qubits, and importantly, the accuracy of the classical decoder used for deciphering corrections to the logical state. While recent demonstrations have shown fault-tolerant logical operations and logical error rates below physical qubit error rates [ 1 , 2 , 3 ] , near-term error-corrected devices are far away from the logical error rates below 10^{-9} that are required for commercially viable applications [ 6 ] . Even with state-of-the art device fidelity, the number of physical qubits needed to encode a commercially viable high-fidelity logical qubit is prohibitively large on current hardware [ 7 ] . Improvements in classical decoders can offer a shortcut to stronger error suppression, but the accuracy of the decoder is often limited by how much information it has about the underlying system [ 8 ] . In standard QEC schemes such as surface code quantum computing [ 9 , 4 ] , successive rounds of stabiliser measurements are performed to track the state of a logical qubit against potential errors. This measurement data is typically converted from an analogue to a digital representation and classified to a binary measurement outcome before being passed to a classical decoder [ 10 ] . However, the binary classification process is sub-optimal as it throws away valuable information about the measurement process that can be used to improve decoding accuracy [ 11 , 12 ] . By using a probability estimator that captures the likelihood of a given measurement signal originating from state \ket{0} or \ket{1} , denoted as soft information, the decoder can more accurately track measurement errors over the course of a QEC protocol, enhancing the code threshold and making the decoder more resilient to classification errors. Prior simulations have shown that soft information can achieve a higher error-correction threshold on the surface code than traditional protocols [ 12 ] , and a number of experimental works have confirmed that the technique yields lower logical error rates in real-world systems [ 13 , 14 , 15 , 16 ] . The primary question that had been left to answer is whether soft information remains advantageous when moving towards large-scale future systems, and whether the previously shown improvements translate to other qubit platforms and error-correcting codes. It also remained an open question whether soft decoding is compatible with the high-throughput, low-latency decoding workflows needed for future large-scale error-corrected systems [ 1 ] . Previous soft decoder demonstrations required extensive computation during runtime [ 12 , 16 ] , which are potentially incompatible with real-time implementations. To fill this gap, we incorporate soft decoding capabilities into two promising real-time decoder architectures — the local clustering decoder (LCD) [ 17 ] and belief propagation (BP) [ 18 , 19 , 20 ] , and benchmark their accuracy on extensive simulations of two leading qubit platforms: superconducting transmon qubits and neutral atom qubits. Although superconducting qubits have enjoyed significant successes towards scalable QEC, neutral atoms have emerged as a competitive alternative thanks to their high fidelity, extensive connectivity and the ability to simultaneously manipulate multi-qubit arrays [ 21 , 2 , 22 ] . On these platforms, we simulate logical performance of our decoders on the surface code as well as the newly developed bivariate bicycle (BB) codes [ 23 ] , and compare the resource overheads needed to reach target error rates with soft and hard decoders. Our findings show that soft information yields consistently higher rates of error suppression than hard decoding across different error-correcting codes and qubit platforms, unlocking low logical error rates at substantially smaller qubit footprints that would otherwise be needed. Our results are of particular relevance to experimentalists, who we hope will leverage soft information to design faster and more hardware-efficient error-corrected quantum devices in the future. For our soft-information-augmented decoders, we use LCD [ 17 ] to decode the surface code simulations, and the BP-based decoder [ 18 , 19 ] to decode the BB codes. Our choice of decoders is motivated by their prospects in a real-time experiment — LCD is optimised for high-throughput implementation, and BP variants such as relay [ 20 ] have been shown to be compatible with the tight time constraints of real-time decoding. While most small-scale QEC experiments have been conducted with offline decoders where the syndrome information is decoded after the fact, utility-scale quantum computers will require data processing and decoding to happen at the timescale of syndrome extraction — requiring scalable and responsive decoders. We note that other decoders can be made compatible with soft information, such as minimum-weight perfect matching [ 24 ] which has been shown to deliver improved error rates in real-world experiments [ 13 , 14 , 16 ] , as well as network decoders which can be trained with soft information, delivering better error rates than their binary counterparts [ 8 , 25 ] . More general solvers such as Tesseract [ 26 ] may also be used with soft information by modifying the decoder prior, but these lack the scalability needed for a real-time setting. On both platforms, we evaluate the rate of error suppression, represented by the \Lambda -factor [ 27 ] , that can be achieved with soft information decoding and compare it to traditional hard decoding. We then relate improvements in \Lambda