Resilience of the autocatalytic feedback loop for gene regulation
Daniele Proverbio, Giulia Giordano · 2025
Read Resilience of the autocatalytic feedback loop for gene regulation by Daniele Proverbio, Giulia Giordano (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-03276.txt.
Introduction
Daniele Proverbio and Giulia Giordano wrote this 2025 paper on the toughness of a gene circuit that boosts its own production. A transcription factor that switches on its own gene forms a loop meant to hold its level steady through noise and shocks. The authors model that loop as a chance process and measure how well it keeps its resting state.
They find that when the factor works in larger clusters, the loop grows tougher. Clustering sharpens the on-off curve of the regulation, and the resting state holds even near the edge where it could tip. A second lens on toughness, built from the spread of the system's states, backs the first. Computer runs match the theory. The lesson may guide the design of hardy synthetic gene circuits.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Daniele Proverbio, Giulia Giordano |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 33 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-03276
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Resilience of the autocatalytic feedback loop for gene regulation Daniele Proverbio, Giulia Giordano Abstract Gene expression in response to stimuli is regulated by transcription factors (TFs) through feedback loop motifs, aimed at maintaining the desired TF concentration despite uncertainties and perturbations. In this work, we consider a stochastic model of the positive gene autoregulating feedback loop and we probabilistically quantify its resilience, i.e. , its ability to preserve the equilibrium associated with a prescribed concentration of TFs, and the corresponding basin of attraction, in the presence of noise. We show that the formation of larger oligomers, corresponding to larger Hill coefficients of the regulation function, and thus to sharper non-linearities, improves the system resilience, even close to critical concentrations of TFs. We also explore a complementary definition of resilience that can be assessed within a stochastic formulation relying on the Fokker-Planck equation. Our formal results are accompanied by numerical simulations. 1 Introduction and Motivation Regulating gene expression in response to stimuli is essential for protein production and cell survival. Assessing the resilience of regulation pathways, i.e. , their ability to withstand random perturbations and preserve crucial cell activities to survive and thrive, sheds light onto key biological mechanisms that sustain life and evolution, and enables the design of biomolecular circuits in synthetic biology. Gene expression pathways, which can be successfully modelled using network motifs and control loops among responsive elements [ 1 , 2 ] , are fundamental to process external and internal stimuli and accordingly regulate crucial cell functions, such as enzymatic activity [ 3 ] or changes in gene expression during cell fate decisions [ 4 ] ; they are also essential building blocks for circuits in synthetic biology. The positive autoregulating feedback loop motif, where a transcription factor (TF) increases its own production, is a simple and powerful model of gene expression regulation that captures essential mechanisms observed in living cells [ 5 ] to guarantee robust adaptation and homeostasis [ 6 ] . The model can exhibit multistability [ 7 ] : admitting multiple stable equilibria is evolutionarily advantageous, as it allows to rapidly switch between concentrations of TFs, thereby responding rapidly and reliably to changes in environmental or physiological conditions. For instance, the system modelling the expression of \beta -galactosidase in E. coli is bistable [ 8 ] : when lactose becomes available in the environment, the response pathway drives the concentration of the lac operon genetic inducer up to a critical threshold, yielding a sudden transition from low (“off” state, which saves energy) to high (“on”) concentrations of the \beta -galactosidase enzyme, which helps metabolise the nutrient and allows to feast on lactose before other bacteria, thus enabling survival. Then, as soon as nutrients deplete, another transition brings the system back to the “off” state, to avoid wasting resources. To efficiently manage gene translation and exploit nutrients to the fullest, transitions between stable equilibria must be tightly controlled and little sensitive to random deviations, environmental disturbances and intrinsic noise [ 9 ] affecting cells. Understanding the mechanisms that improve the system resilience in relation to its “off” and “on” states helps unveil how cells thrive in uncertain environments and inform the development of synthetic pathways. We consider a model for positive autoregulating feedback control of transcription and we investigate its resilience, formally defined as a probabilistic quantification of its ability to preserve a prescribed attractor and its corresponding basin of attraction in spite of stochastic noise [ 10 ] . In particular, we assess the equilibria of the nominal deterministic system and their stability properties: the system is bistable for suitable parameter ranges and undergoes fold bifurcations. Then, we employ a stochastic approach to quantify its resilience, around its asymptotically stable equilibria, in the presence of additive Gaussian white noise. Our analysis identifies factors that help the system cope with stochastic perturbations and avoid undesired random transitions between stable equilibria, thus approximately maintaining the desired TF concentrations, and illustrates how cells can thrive in noisy conditions. Figure 1: Positive genetic autoregulating feedback loop [ 11 ] . The transcription factor TF-A, produced by gene tf-a , forms an oligomer ( n=3 ) that, when phosphorylated (P), increases the transcription rate of tf-a , by promoting responsive DNA sequences. TF-A degrades at a constant rate. 2 Positive Autoregulating Feedback Model The positive autoregulating feedback loop model for gene regulation introduced in [ 11 ] is visualised in Fig. 1 . The single activator TF-A belongs to a pathway mediating cellular responses to stimuli and regulates its own transcription [ 12 ] . If the concentration y\in[0,\infty) of TF-A is negligible, transcription of the tf-a gene occurs at a basal rate r_{a}>0 . TF-A degrades following first-order kinetics, at a constant rate \zeta>0 . Also, TF-A can form oligomers having concentration y^{n} , where n\in\mathbb{N} represents how many monomers form the oligomer, which bind to responsive elements and, when phosphorylated, promote the transcription of tf-a ; phosphorylation can be further regulated by external signals. We assume that binding processes are relatively rapid and close to equilibrium, so that the resulting increase in the transcription rate is captured by a monotonically increasing Hill function, with Hill coefficient n and dissociation constant K>0 of oligomers from the responsive elements, which saturates to a maximal rate \alpha>0 . All parameters are dimensionless, and the model does not explicitly consider the translation of mRNA into proteins. In a deterministic setting, the resulting ordinary differential equation (ODE) is \tfrac{dy(\tau)}{d\tau}=\alpha\frac{y(\tau)^{n}}{K+y(\tau)^{n}}-\zeta y(\tau)+\tilde{r} . Considering the new variable x\doteq y/K^{\frac{1}{n}}\in[0,\infty) and rescaling time as t\doteq\tau/\zeta allows us to rewrite the ODE as \frac{dx(t)}{dt}=f(x(t))=a\frac{x(t)^{n}}{1+x(t)^{n}}-x(t)+r, (1) where a=\alpha/(\zeta K^{\frac{1}{n}})>0 , r=\tilde{r}/(\zeta K^{\frac{1}{n}})>0 , and the saturating Hill function \frac{x^{n}}{1+x^{n}} , for n\to\infty , converges to the Heaviside step function \Theta(x-1) . Model ( 1 ) with r=0 has been thoroughly analysed in [ 13 ] . We assess the system resilience through the lens of the rigorous formal definitions introduced in [ 10 ] for a family of ODE systems consisting of stochastic perturbations of a nominal deterministic system, aimed at probabilistically quantifying its ability to preserve a prescribed attractor A (e.g., an asymptotically stable equilibrium) and the corresponding basin of attraction B(A) in spite of noise. Our system family is \mathcal{F}=\{G_{\lambda}\}_{\lambda\in\mathcal{I}} , with \mathcal{I}=[0,\hat{\lambda}) and \hat{\lambda}>0 , where ( 1 ) is the nominal system G_{\lambda_{0}} , with \lambda_{0}=0 , whereas the generic system G_{\lambda}\in\mathcal{F} is described by the stochastic differential equation (SDE) \tfrac{dx(t)}{dt}=f(x(t))+\lambda\eta(t)=\tfrac{ax(t)^{n}}{1+x(t)^{n}}-x(t)+r+\lambda\eta(t), (2) where \eta(t) is uncorrelated white noise with mean \langle\eta\rangle=0 , variance \sigma_{\eta}^{2}=1 and intensity \lambda\in\mathcal{I} . For biological consistency, we assume the noise is such that positivity of the system is preserved: x(t)\geq 0 for all t . As observed in [ 14 ] , oligomers that require cooperative binding of more TF-A monomers, leading to a larger Hill coefficient n , allow for a better suppression of noise propagation close to the system equilibria. However, no formal results are available for the resilience of system ( 2 ) in relation to its asymptotically stable equilibria, which we investigate in this work. 3 Bistability of the Deterministic Model Figure 2: (a, b) The intersections of functions f_{1}(x)=ax^{n}/(1+x^{n}) and f_{2}(x)=x-r can be either one, two or three, and correspond to the