Input to European Strategy Update for Particle Physics: Sustainability
Veronique Boisvert \aff 1, Daniel Britzger \aff 2, Samuel Calvet \aff 3, Yann Coadou \aff 4, Caterina Doglioni \aff 9, Julien Faivre \aff 5, Patrick Koppenburg \aff 14, Valerie S. Lang \aff 11, Kristin Lohwasser \aff 6, Zach Marshall \aff 7, Rakhi Mahbubani \aff 8, Peter Millington \aff 9, Tomoko Mu · 2025
Read Input to European Strategy Update for Particle Physics: Sustainability by Veronique Boisvert \aff 1, Daniel Britzger \aff 2, Samuel Calvet \aff 3, Yann Coadou \aff 4, Caterina Doglioni \aff 9, Julien Faivre \aff 5, Patrick Koppenburg \aff 14, Valerie S. Lang \aff 11, Kristin Lohwasser \aff 6, Zach Marshall \aff 7, Rakhi Mahbubani \aff 8, Peter Millington \aff 9, Tomoko Mu (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-03012.txt.
Introduction
Veronique Boisvert and co-authors submit a formal input in 2025 to the European Strategy Update for Particle Physics, arguing the field must go green. Big labs and colliders use vast energy and materials. The authors note that six of nine planetary boundaries have already been crossed, with a seventh close behind.
They urge the strategy to set a clear, bold duty to build sustainability into the whole future program. The document backs that call with a list of concrete actions. It frames the duty as both moral and practical: the field should help cut emissions and protect nature, not add to the harm. The input joins others shaping Europe's next decades in the field.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Veronique Boisvert \aff 1, Daniel Britzger \aff 2, Samuel Calvet \aff 3, Yann Coadou \aff 4, Caterina Doglioni \aff 9, Julien Faivre \aff 5, Patrick Koppenburg \aff 14, Valerie S. Lang \aff 11, Kristin Lohwasser \aff 6, Zach Marshall \aff 7, Rakhi Mahbubani \aff 8, Peter Millington \aff 9, Tomoko Mu |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 22 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-03012
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Input to European Strategy Update for Particle Physics: Sustainability Veronique Boisvert \aff 1, Daniel Britzger \aff 2, Samuel Calvet \aff 3, Yann Coadou \aff 4, Caterina Doglioni \aff 9, Julien Faivre \aff 5, Patrick Koppenburg \aff 14, Valerie S. Lang \aff 11, Kristin Lohwasser \aff 6, Zach Marshall \aff 7, Rakhi Mahbubani \aff 8, Peter Millington \aff 9, Tomoko Muranaka \aff 16, Karolos Potamianos \aff 15, Ruth Pöttgen \aff 10, Hannah Wakeling \aff 12, Efe Yazgan \aff 13 Abstract Human activity continues to have an enormous negative impact on the ability of the planet to sustain human and other forms of life. Six out of the nine planetary boundaries have been crossed, a seventh is close to threshold. Prominent manifestations of this development are climate change caused by greenhouse gas emissions, as well as loss of biodiversity. In recognition of the urgency of these problems, several international agreements have been ratified to achieve net-zero emissions and to halt and reverse biodiversity loss. Significant reductions in emissions are required by 2030 to meet international climate targets. The field of particle physics has an obligation and an opportunity to contribute to such mitigation efforts and to avoid causing further harm. This document urges the European Strategy Update in Particle Physics to set a clear and bold mandate for embedding environmental sustainability throughout the future scientific programme, and advocates for a series of actions that will enable this. keywords CERN report; contribution; ESPPU; Strategy Update; Environment; Sustainability. 0.1 The case for sustainability in particle physics The scientific basis for climate change is well established [ ManabeWetherald1967 , Hasselmann1976 , IPCC2021report ] : The increase in CO 2 and other greenhouse gases (GHG) in the atmosphere interferes with Earth’s natural carbon cycle and leads to changes in local and global temperatures [ essd-16-2625-2024 ] . The year 2024 was the hottest, and the last ten years the warmest, on record [ WMO2024 , BerkeleyEarth2024 , NASA2024 , Copernicus2024 ] . Changes in ocean currents and melting of arctic ice are among the observations consistent with the predictions of climate science [ Ripple2024 ] , and the framework of extreme event attribution [ NAP21852 ] indicates that the current level of climate change can be fully attributed to human activity [ IPCC2021reportSPM ] . The resulting changes in weather patterns cause persistent draughts [ draught1 , draught2 ] , heavy storms [ storm1 , storm2 ] , and record levels of precipitation and floods [ flood1 , flood2 ] , leading to numerous deaths, severe disruption, and billions of euros in damage. Global warming of 2.7 ∘ C or more above preindustrial levels will leave a third of the population outside the “human climate niche” for survival and activity [ doi:10.1073/pnas.1910114117 , lenton1 ] . The Paris Agreement [ paris ] aims to keep increases in global average temperatures well below 2 ∘ C compared to preindustrial levels. Achieving its goals requires a reduction of net GHG emissions to zero by 2050. A significant amount of this reduction should be achieved by 2030. This is within the next five years, the same period targeted by the update to the European Strategy for Particle Physics. In addition to changes in global weather patterns, the variety and variability of life on Earth is threatened directly by human activities and indirectly through climate change. This biodiversity is declining faster now than at any other time in human history, and current extinction rates are 100 to 1,000 times higher than the baseline and increasing [ Ceballosbiodiversity , biodiv ] . The degradation of Earth’s ecosystems has a direct impact on humanity, and the cost of replacing their services with artificial solutions is high [ ipbes_2019_6417333 ] . It is clear that there are moral and practical imperatives for particle physics to act: • in climate mitigation: reducing energy and material resource consumption, GHG emissions, and other negative environmental impacts. • in climate adaptation: readying our research infrastructure and practices for the manifold challenges posed by climate change. Moreover, particle physics will be under increasing pressure to justify its impacts, and relying on grid decarbonization will not be enough to guarantee that large-scale experiments will be deemed viable. The emissions from particle physics are sizeable. The 2022 CERN emissions were 361,000 tCO 2 e (tonnes of CO 2 equivalent) [ CERNEnvironment2023 ] . These emissions can be compared with those of a developed country like Liechtenstein (with a population of about 40,000), which emitted 169,000 tCO 2 e [ WIDannualCo2e ] in 2022 1 1 1 CERN’s emissions include all scope 1, scope 2 and scope 3 emissions with the scope 2 emissions calculated over a reference timescale of 100 years. Country GHG emissions include carbon dioxide, methane and nitrous oxide from all sources, including land-use change. They are measured in tonnes of carbon dioxide-equivalents over a 100-year timescale. [ wikiLiechtenstein ] . Not counting the embodied carbon in the civil engineering and machines themselves, the GHG emissions due to 2.5 minutes of CERN operations (1 tCO 2 e) equates to just over 1 year of per capita beef consumption or 1.5 years of per capita dairy consumption [ OWIDfoodaverage , OWIDmilkaverage , OWIDfoodemissions ] , 3.5 years of per capita clothes shopping [ TextileEmissions ] 2 2 2 This is based on average consumption in the EU. , 6,000 km of car travel [ Ritchie_2023 ] , or 10 years of per capita emissions in Rwanda [ RwandaEmissions ] , making clear the insidiousness of climate injustice. Particle physics has made substantial progress in acknowledging the importance of sustainability and estimating GHG emissions and other environmental impacts (see, e.g., [ Bloom:2022gux , Banerjee:2023avd , yHEP2023a , yHEP2023b , Bloom:2024ixe , Lang:2024wpo , Saha:2024prx ] , the CERN Environment reports [ CERNEnvironment2020 , CERNEnvironment2021 , CERNEnvironment2023 ] , and the forthcoming Lab Directors Group guidelines on the Sustainable Assessment of Future Colliders [ LDGWork ] ). This document aims to complement the emphasis given to sustainability in other inputs to the European Strategy in Particle Physics and to urge the Update to give the strongest mandate to embedding environmental sustainability throughout European particle physics: from decision-making through to the design, construction, operation and decommissioning of future experimental infrastructure. Doing so presents both challenges and opportunities, and these are identified below. A list of key measures was identified by the community, and these are provided to inform a significant expansion of the European Strategy Update’s emphasis on sustainability. 0.2 Challenges and opportunities Tackling the climate emergency and the degradation of the world’s ecosystems is a systems problem. Moreover, it is a “wicked” problem [ Rittel1973 ] , that is not immune to economics, politics, geopolitics, sociology, or psychology, and progress requires systemic organizational transformation, alongside behaviour and culture change. However, there are also opportunities that arise from the need to transition the system to a more sustainable mode of operation. For particle physics, the transition is a problem that relies heavily on the provision of resources and funding, and the actions of many external agents: funders, governments, industry partners, and the up- and downstream supply chains. Moreover, the key drivers for particle physics — scientific questions, but also political and sociological