Hofstadter butterflies in phononic structures: commensurate spectra, wave localization and metal-insulator transitions
Bryn Davies, Lorenzo Morini · 2025
Read Hofstadter butterflies in phononic structures: commensurate spectra, wave localization and metal-insulator transitions by Bryn Davies, Lorenzo Morini (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-02594.txt.
Introduction
Bryn Davies and Lorenzo Morini study Hofstadter butterflies in phononic structures. Their 2025 paper presents a simple one-dimensional phononic system whose spectrum exactly matches the Hofstadter butterfly when a parameter is varied.
The system has masses coupled by linear springs, mounted on flexural beams whose cross section, and so stiffness, is modulated. They show this is the simplest version that can give the butterfly exactly, and that local resonances from the beams are essential. They examine Bloch spectra, resonances of finite systems, and transmission through finite sections. Mode localization, measured by the inverse participation ratio, reveals a metal-insulator style phase transition.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Bryn Davies, Lorenzo Morini |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 39 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-02594
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Hofstadter butterflies in phononic structures: commensurate spectra, wave localization and metal-insulator transitions Bryn Davies, Lorenzo Morini Abstract We present a new simple and easy-to-implement one-dimensional phononic system whose spectrum exactly corresponds to the Hofstadter butterfly when a parameter is modulated. The system consists of masses that are coupled by linear springs and are mounted on flexural beams whose cross section (and, hence, stiffness) is modulated. We show that this system is the simplest version possible to achieve the Hofstadter butterfly exactly; in particular, the local resonances due to the beams are an essential component for this. We examine the various approaches to producing spectral butterflies, including Bloch spectra for rational parameter choices, resonances of finite-sized systems and transmission coefficients of sections of finite length. For finite-size systems, we study the localisation of the modes by calculating the inverse participation ratio, and detect a phase transition characterised by a critical value of the stiffness modulation amplitude, where the state of the system changes from mainly extended to localised, corresponding to a metal-insulator phase transition. The obtained results offer a practical strategy to realize experimentally a system with similar dynamical properties. The transmission coefficient for sections of finite length is benchmarked through the comparison with Bloch spectra of the same finite-sized systems. The numerical results for the transmission spectra confirms the evidence of a phase transition in the dynamical state of the system. Our approach opens significant new perspectives in order to design mechanical systems able to support phase transitions in their vibrational properties. Keywords: Hofstadter butterfly spectrum, Quasiperiodic modulation, Localised mode, Inverse participation ratio, Metal-insulator transition. 1 Introduction The recent growth in the exploration of quasiperiodic wave systems has been driven by their ability to support complex, exotic and often fractal spectra. These have the potential to expand the design space for dynamical metamaterials and meta-structures beyond classical periodic configurations, improving their potential in terms of wave control and providing the possibility to exploit different phenomena in future applications, especially for what concerns the so-called topological effects [ 1 , 2 ] . One of the most famous examples of a fractal spectrum is the Hofstadter butterfly [ 3 ] , which has been the inspiration for a wealth of recent studies considering the spectra of structured media with incommensurate periodic modulation. These studies span many different physical domains, including quantum mechanics [ 4 ] , photonics [ 5 , 6 ] , phononics [ 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 , 12 ] and vibro-acoustics [ 13 , 14 ] , but all seek to obtain images of spectra that resemble the Hofstadter butterfly when the modulation parameter is varied. This modulation parameter is usually a geometric parameter which characterises the relative phase of the modulation and captures the system’s periodicity or aperiodicity (typically corresponding to rational or irrational values, respectively). The modulated spectra typically display fractal and self-similar properties, qualitatively reminiscent of Hofstadter’s famous butterfly image [ 3 ] . In his seminal 1976 paper on the energy levels of Bloch electrons in irrational magnetic fields [ 3 ] , Hofstadter obtained the famous “butterfly” spectral pictures by finding the eigenvalues \mathcal{E} of Harper’s equation [ 15 ] : g(n+1)+g(n-1)+\lambda\cos(2\pi\phi n)g(n)=\mathcal{E}g(n),\quad n\in\mathbb{Z}, (1.1) for different values of the parameter \phi , with \lambda=2 . This is often stated with a phase-shift parameter within the cosine, but this just has the effect of translating the spectrum, so we omit it here. As we will see further in this work, varying the value of \lambda can alter the nature of the eigensolutions yielding to states of the system which have different dynamical properties with respect to the most widely studied variant of ( 1.1 ) corresponding to \lambda=2 [ 16 ] . The spectrum of the eigenvalue problem ( 1.1 ) has been studied extensively and has led to some longstanding and notoriously challenging problems in spectral theory [ 17 , 18 , 16 ] . However, several simple properties of the spectrum have been well known since Hofstadter’s original work. For example, any eigenvalue \mathcal{E} of ( 1.1 ) must satisfy -2-\lambda\leq\mathcal{E}\leq 2+\lambda and \mathcal{E} is an eigenvalue if and only if -\mathcal{E} is an eigenvalue. The main recent interest from the mechanical metamaterials and phononics community in designing systems with spectra corresponding to the Hofstadter butterfly has been motivated by the possibility to exploit the fractal nature of these spectra to control different wave phenomena and optimize the associated dynamical properties. The key to producing this type of phononic structures is to modulate their parameters sinusodially, as in ( 1.1 ). Several different quasiperiodic systems have been implemented with Harper-type modulation on the coupling strengths [ 1 , 7 , 2 , 8 , 9 , 11 ] . In these examples, the coupling strength is typically modulated by varying the positions of resonators on a homogeneous substrate (such as an elastic plate or beam). This yields pictures that qualitatively resemble the Hofstadter butterfly, in the sense that they have a pattern of many different spectral gaps that are shifted when the modulation parameter \phi is varied. However, for a system to correspond exactly to ( 1.1 ) (such that we are able to leverage the whole range of mathematical results that have been developed for this operator), we need to perform “on-site” modulations by varying the locally resonant elements themselves. Only a few mechanical systems with on-site modulation have been previously proposed, for example by [ 14 , 13 ] in arrays of coupled acoustic resonators, by [ 10 ] in a LEGO beam, and by [ 19 ] in granular chains with local resonances provided by either an external restitution mechanism or an internal single-degree-of-freedom resonance. The other important practical question is, given a model for a physical system (with suitable modulation), how to generate images reminiscent of the Hofstadter butterfly spectrum from ( 1.1 ). A common strategy in the literature is to compute the eigenmodes of a finite-sized sample. However, the introduction of boundaries adds additional eigenvalues to the spectrum, corresponding to edge modes [ 1 , 2 , 9 , 14 ] . Although these modes, which are localised at one of the boundaries of the system, are interesting in their own right ( e.g. they have interesting topological properties [ 1 , 2 , 9 , 14 ] ), it is often desirable to remove them to recover the classical, unpolluted butterfly. Algorithms have been proposed for identifying edge modes (by studying their profiles) and removing them from the spectrum [ 20 ] , but this is computationally expensive for high-resolution plots. In this paper, we will show further how the restriction to rational modulation parameters \phi is sufficient to produce high-resolution butterfly spectra with and is significantly more computationally efficient. This is because any rational \phi will yield a periodic system (albeit potentially with a very large unit cell), meaning conventional methods ( e.g. transfer matrices) can be used to compute the Bloch spectra. We will also show how both these spectra (finite eigenvalues and Bloch spectra) are reproduced by studying the transmission coefficients of finite-sized sections of the phononic system, with a resolution that increases with the length.