GPT Adoption and the Impact of Disclosure Policies
Cathy Yang, David Restrepo Amariles, Leo Allen, Aurore Troussel · 2025
Read GPT Adoption and the Impact of Disclosure Policies by Cathy Yang, David Restrepo Amariles, Leo Allen, Aurore Troussel (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-01566.txt.
Introduction
Cathy Yang and co-authors study how rules about disclosing ChatGPT use shape its uptake at work, in a research paper from 2025. They focus on legal, audit, and advisory staff in consulting firms. Firms gain from these tools, but legal risk leads some staff to hide their use.
The team ran a survey experiment framed by agency theory, which deals with gaps between what workers know and what managers see. Without a firm AI policy, those gaps create costs that limit the gains from the tools. Disclosure rules narrowed the knowledge gap but did not cut total costs much, since managers valued work less when they knew a tool helped. The authors also review disclosure law in Europe and the United States and discuss fair ways to share risk.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Cathy Yang, David Restrepo Amariles, Leo Allen, Aurore Troussel |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 74 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-01566
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
GPT Adoption and the Impact of Disclosure Policies Cathy Yang, David Restrepo Amariles, Leo Allen, Aurore Troussel Abstract Generative Pre-trained Transformers (GPTs), particularly Large Language Models (LLMs) like ChatGPT, have proven effective in content generation and productivity enhancement. However, legal risks associated with these tools lead to adoption variance and concealment of AI use within organizations. This study examines the impact of disclosure on ChatGPT adoption in legal, audit and advisory roles in consulting firms through the lens of agency theory. We conducted a survey experiment to evaluate agency costs in the context of unregulated corporate use of ChatGPT, with a particular focus on how mandatory disclosure influences information asymmetry and misaligned interests. Our findings indicate that in the absence of corporate regulations, such as an AI policy, firms may incur agency costs, which can hinder the full benefits of GPT adoption. While disclosure policies reduce information asymmetry, they do not significantly lower overall agency costs due to managers undervaluing analysts’ contributions with GPT use. Finally, we examine the scope of existing regulations in Europe and the United States regarding disclosure requirements, explore the sharing of risk and responsibility within firms, and analyze how incentive mechanisms promote responsible AI adoption. Keywords: Human-GPT collaboration, GPT disclosure, agency theory, content evaluation, survey experiment 1 Introduction The rapid adoption of generative artificial intelligence (GENAI) technologies, driven by advanced Large Language Models (LLMs) such as GPT, Claude, and Mistral, presents organizations with unprecedented opportunities. However, it also introduces complex legal and risk management challenges that demand careful consideration. A landmark ruling by the Hamburg Labor Court (Arbeitsgericht Hamburg) on January 16, 2024, addressed one of those crucial legal questions: Does an employer engage in employee monitoring when allowing the use of ChatGPT in the workplace via personal accounts? The Court ruled that as long as the employer has no knowledge of which employees are using ChatGPT, when, how, or to what extent, no monitoring occurs ( BVGa 1/24., 2024a ) . This ruling brings attention to a broader challenge, as organizations often struggle to monitor whether and how employees are using generative AI tools. We define the undisclosed use of AI tools in the workplace as “shadow adoption.” To systematically analyze this issue, we propose using agency theory as an analytical framework. Despite the expanding body of literature and experiments aimed at understanding the impact of generative AI in the workplace, there is a notable lack of empirical research analyzing this impact through the lens of agency theory. This gap is surprising, as the principal-agent problem can elucidate several critical issues identified in current research. These issues include the motivations and contexts under which employees adopt tools like ChatGPT ( Dell’Acqua et al., 2023a ; Brynjolfsson et al., 2023a ; Peng et al., 2023a ) , the conditions that give rise to specific legal risks and strategies for managing these risks ( Gupta et al., 2023a ; Hacker et al., 2023a ; Charfeddine et al., 2024a ) , and the types of monitoring systems and incentives that can be implemented to promote the responsible use of generative AI in firms ( Humlum & Vestergaard, 2024a ) . In this article, we argue that examining the adoption of ChatGPT and similar generative AI software in the workplace through the lens of the principal-agent problem offers valuable insights for developing effective corporate AI policies. Such policies are essential for managing legal risks and promoting responsible AI usage ( Chiu & Lim, 2021a ) . Our framework specifically highlights the organizational risks associated with individual and team-level adoption of generative AI within professional service firms. By analyzing the principal-agent relationship, we investigate how key factors—namely, information asymmetry, and moral hazard, incentives—shape the risks emerging from the adoption of ChatGPT and generative AI in firms. Accordingly, we later discuss why corporate AI policies are necessary to address these issues and how they can leverage solutions proposed in the agency literature. Specifically, we explore the implementation of control measures, incentive mechanisms, and risk management strategies as effective approaches. The literature widely acknowledges that an agency relationship is established when a principal hires an agent to perform tasks on the principal’s behalf ( Jensen & Meckling, 1976a ; Fama, 1980a ; Zeckhauser & Pratt, 1985a ) . The principal-agent scholarship focuses on addressing issues that arise from this relationship. These issues typically stem from three fundamental assumptions in agency theory ( Eisenhardt, 1989a ; Bosse & Phillips, 2016a ) . Firstly, issues arise from a misalignment of interests, wherein agents prioritize their self-interest over the objectives of principals ( Harris & Raviv, 1979a ; Bosse & Phillips, 2016a ) . Secondly, problems also emerge due to information asymmetry, as agents, who are the primary task performers, possess more information than principals ( Zeckhauser & Pratt, 1985a ; Bergen et al., 1992a ) . Thirdly, discrepancies in risk preferences between principals and agents lead to divergent actions (moral hazard), with agents generally exhibiting greater risk aversion compared to principals ( Harris & Raviv, 1979a ; Bosse & Phillips, 2016a ) . Agency theory posits that effective monitoring and incentive structures are essential for addressing these issues and ensuring risk-sharing that aligns the agent’s risk attitudes and behaviors with the principal’s interests ( Jensen & Meckling, 1976a ; Shavell, 1979a ; Eisenhardt, 1988a ; Miller, 2005a ) . While the implementation of monitoring and incentive mechanisms constitutes agency costs for the principal ( Eisenhardt, 1989a ) , principals may prefer to incur these expenses rather than face potentially higher costs associated with diminished work quality and inadequate risk management. Agency theory frequently conceptualizes the relationship between principals and agents using the metaphor of a contract ( Jensen & Meckling, 1976a ; Keeley, 1980a ; Eisenhardt, 1988a ) . Through this contract, the principal delegates tasks and decision-making authority to the agent ( Jensen & Meckling, 1976a , p. 308) . This perspective aligns with the modern theory of the firm, which defines firms as a nexus of contracts, where production results from coordinated efforts of a group of individuals ( Fama, 1980a ; 2 ) . Within this nexus, the ultimate principal is the shareholder, and the executives are the agents. Further down the line, managers and employees are linked by principal-agent relationships throughout the production chain ( Langevoort, 2003a ) . As Zeckhauser notes, whenever one individual depends on the actions of another to produce value, an agency relationship arises: “The consultant is the agent, the client the principal. The absence of a formal contractual agreement directly binding managers and employees does not impede the establishment of a principal-agent relationship ( Spremann, 1987a ) , as they are functionally interconnected and linked through the nexus of contracts constituting the firm. In other words, the contracting relationship between principal and agent may be either implicit or explicit ( Jensen & Meckling, 1976a , p. 308) . The chain of agency relationships within the corporation has been extensively discussed in legal scholarship ( Easterbrook & Fischel, 1989a ; Brudney, 1996a ; Langevoort, 2003a ) . Langevoort provides a thorough examination of what he terms “agency law within the corporation” to elucidate the duties of employees throughout the organization through the lens of principal-agent