On the bouncing completion of eternal inflation

Alexsandre L. Ferreira Jr, Nelson Pinto-Neto, Vanessa N. Xavier · 2025

Read On the bouncing completion of eternal inflation by Alexsandre L. Ferreira Jr, Nelson Pinto-Neto, Vanessa N. Xavier (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-01224.txt.

Introduction

Alexsandre Ferreira, Nelson Pinto-Neto, and Vanessa Xavier study in 2025 whether eternal inflation can be completed by a bounce. A known theorem says a spacetime with average positive expansion cannot extend forever into the past. Past eternal inflation would thus seem to need a singular start.

Using frames of non-comoving observers in flat de Sitter space, the authors test all options the theorem allows. Either a curvature singularity must occur, or the past must approach a de Sitter state. In the second case, an extension exists that respects energy rules. That extension, they show, must contain a bounce.

Catalog record

CREATORAlexsandre L. Ferreira Jr, Nelson Pinto-Neto, Vanessa N. Xavier
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE31 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-01224

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

On the bouncing completion of eternal inflation Alexsandre L. Ferreira Jr, Nelson Pinto-Neto, Vanessa N. Xavier Abstract Using a purely kinematical argument, the Borde-Guth-Vilenkin (BGV) theorem N3 states that any maximal space-time with average positive expansion is geodesically incomplete, hence past eternal inflation would be necessarily singular. Recently, discussions about the broadness of this theorem have been resurfaced by applying it to new models and/or challenging the space-time maximality hypothesis. In the present work, we use reference frames of non co-moving observers and their kinematical properties in order to inquire into the nature of such possible singular beginnings. Using the spatially flat de Sitter (dS) space-time as a laboratory, this approach allows us to exhaust all possibilities bounded by the BGV theorem in the case of general spatially flat Friedmann-Lemaître-Robertson-Walker (FLRW) geometries. We show that either there exists a scalar or parallelly propagated curvature singularity, or the space-time must be past asymptotically dS (with a definite non-zero limit of the Hubble parameter when the scale factor becomes null, hence excluding certain cyclic models) in order to be extensible. We are able to present this local extension without violating the null energy condition, and we show that this extension must contain a bounce. This is a mathematical result based on purely kinematical arguments and intuition. The possible physical realization of such extensions are also discussed. As a side product, we present a new chart that covers all de Sitter space-time. I Introduction In spatially flat Friedmann-Lemaître-Robertson-Walker (FLRW) space-times, in which the scale factor vanishes only when cosmic time goes to minus infinity, free-falling co-moving observers are geodesically complete, experiencing an apparently eternal Universe. However, this happens due to a kinematical effect. In such space-times, non co-moving observers tend to be light-like as the scale factor shrinks, inducing an infinite time dilation of the cosmic time with respect to the finite time measure of the non co-moving clock. These non co-moving geodesics are, therefore, incomplete. This was perceived by Borde, Guth and Vilenkin, who contrived it into the BGV theorem N3 ; Borde_1994 , providing a route to verify incompleteness: if the average expansion of the spatial sections is positive, the geometry is geodesically incomplete. Recently, the theorem gained renewed attention as cyclic cosmologies IS19 ; IS21 ; P10 were shown to be incomplete KS22 ; N4 . Further, counter-examples were found due to the existence of loopholes in the construction of the average expansion LED23 , afterwards amended in a re-proposal GHZ24 . Still, past eternal inflation must be modified and, together with any eternal Universe proposal, can only be complete at the cost of breaking the null energy condition EL24a ; EL24b ; carballorubio2024 . However, a fundamental assumption in all approaches is that the space-time geometry is inextensible N2 ; Wald1984rg ; Penrose65 ; GEROCH1968526 ; Hawking66-I ; Hawking66-II ; Hawking67-III ; Hawking-Penrose ; Ellis1977 ; Senovilla_2015 . Thus, the question of whether an averaged expanding space-time can be past eternal depends on whether it admits an extension or not, which enters as an hypothesis in the BGV theorem. Along this route, extendibility conditions for singular space-times were pursued in Clarke-local-extensions ; Clarke-local-extensionsII ; Clarke-singularities-hyperbolicST , and for flat FLRW in Klein_2017 ; LP17 ; YQ18 ; HISC22 ; Nomura_2021 , through co-moving coordinates, curvature tensors in parallelly propagated tetrads and/or null-like coordinates for the case of quasi-de Sitter N5 . The aim of this paper is to propose an alternative extension of such space-times through the construction of a physically motivated chart given by the non co-moving observer reference frame. As an intuitive argument note that, together with the infinite time dilation of the co-moving observer clock, there must be an infinite contraction of their spatial rulers, inducing a zero spatial volume in this asymptotic limit. Hence, the spatial volume seen by the non co-moving observers in this asymptotic limit may be finite, allowing its extension. Indeed, this approach allows us to exhaust all possible cases in flat FLRW space-times, showing that only past asymptotic de Sitter (dS) can be extended (excluding the cyclic models presented in Refs. IS19 ; IS21 ). There, the non co-moving observer sees his co-moving volume reaching a velocity dependent finite minimum, before growing again: the extension must contain a bounce. This paper is organized as follows: In Section II we revisit the BGV theorem, restating its assumptions, some loopholes, and the revised proposal. In section III we present a local analytic extension to non co-moving observers in the spatially flat dS space-time. In section IV we derive necessary conditions for a \mathcal{C}^{2} metric extension of an arbitrary spatially flat FLRW space. We conclude in section V . II The Borde-Guth-Vilenkin Theorem The starting point of the BGV theorem is the metric of a spatially flat FLRW: \textrm{d}s^{2}=-\textrm{d}t^{2}+a^{2}(\textrm{d}r^{2}+r^{2}\textrm{d}\Omega^{2}), (1) with geodesic equations: \left(\frac{\textrm{d}t}{\textrm{d}s}\right)^{2}-a^{2}\left(\frac{\textrm{d}\vec{x}}{\textrm{d}s}\right)^{2}=\mbox{const},\hskip 14.22636pta^{2}\frac{\textrm{d}\vec{x}}{\textrm{d}s}=v_{0}. (2) The former states that the vector tangent to the geodesics, u^{\mu} , has constant norm, either u^{2}=-1 or u^{2}=0 , for the time-like or null case, respectively. The latter equation introduces an integration constant, v_{0} , which defines a congruence of geodesics. When v_{0}=0 the geodesics are the trajectories of co-moving observers w.r.t. the cosmological background. The fractional expansion of such congruence, as seen by a geodesic “observer” u_{0}^{\mu} , with affine parameter s , is given by the generalized Hubble factor, defined as H_{BGV}(s)=\frac{-u^{\mu}_{0}}{\sigma^{2}+\kappa}\frac{Du_{\mu}}{\textrm{d}s}=\frac{-1}{\sigma^{2}+\kappa}\frac{\textrm{d}\sigma}{\textrm{d}s}=-\frac{\textrm{d}}{\textrm{d}s}F(\sigma), (3) being \sigma=u_{0}^{\nu}u_{\nu} and \kappa=u_{0}^{\nu}u_{0\nu} . For a time-like u^{\mu}_{0} , \sigma represents the relative Lorentz factor and \kappa=-1 , while for a light-like u^{\mu}_{0} , \sigma=\textrm{d}t/\textrm{d}s , the change of time w.r.t. the affine parameter, and \kappa=0 . Moreover, F(\sigma)=\begin{cases}\sigma^{-1}&\text{when $\kappa=0$,}\\ \frac{1}{2}\mathrm{ln}\frac{\sigma+1}{\sigma-1}&\text{when $\kappa=-1$.}\\ \end{cases} (4) Notice that the generalized Hubble parameter reduces to the usual one H=(1/3)u^{\mu};_{\mu} when smeared over all directions of u^{\mu}_{0} N3 . Further, defining the averaged expansion rate \mathcal{H}_{avg} as \mathcal{H}_{avg}\int^{s}_{s_{i}}\textrm{d}s=\int^{s_{f}}_{s_{i}}H_{BGV}\,\textrm{d}s, (5) where \Delta s=s_{f}-s_{i} is the parameter interval, the BGV theorem states that, if the averaged expansion rate is positive (negative), the space-time is geodesically past (future) incomplete N3 . The proof follows by direct integration of the generalized Hubble factor, giving \int^{s_{f}}_{s_{i}}H_{BGV}\,\textrm{d}s=F(\sigma_{f})-F(\sigma_{i})\leq F(\sigma_{f}). (6) Then, if \mathcal{H}_{avg}>0 : 0<\mathcal{H}_{avg}\leq\frac{F(\sigma_{f})}{\Delta s}, (7) which means that s_{i}>-\infty , and that the space-time is past incomplete. Future incompleteness proceed analogously for \mathcal{H}_{avg}<0 . In Ref. LED23 , counter-examples to the BGV theorem were constructed – complete space-times where \mathcal{H}_{avg}>0 – due to the fact that the interval \Delta s and, consequently, \mathcal{H}_{avg} , are not well defined for complete geodesics, i.e., when s_{i}\to-\infty or s_{f}\to\infty . Such loophole can be amended by redefining the averaged expansion as \mathcal{H}_{0}=\frac{1}{s_{f}-s_{0}}\int^{s_{f}}_{s_{0}}H_{BGV}\,\textrm{d}s, (8) where now s_{0}\in(s_{i},s_{f}) , which cannot be taken strictly equal to minus infinity. Thence, whenever exists \Delta>0 , so that \mathcal{H}_{0}\geq\Delta for all s_{0}\in(s_{i},s_{f}) , the space-time is past incomplete, without the presence of loopholes, see Ref. GHZ24 for details. Nonetheless, the present work intends to scrutinize a different aspect of the BGV theorem, namely, the assumption that the space-time is inextensible. Important works have been done in this direction Klein_2017 ; LP17 ; YQ18 ; HISC22 ; Nomura_2021 . However, here we seek a different approach by constructing a chart adapted to the incomplete non co-moving observer, allowing us to grasp some physical intuition on possible extensions and the

Read the complete text