Review of “Just Plain Wrong: The Dalliance of Quantum Theory with the Defiance of Bell’s Inequality”
W.M. Stuckey, Timothy McDevitt, Michael Silberstein · 2025
Read Review of “Just Plain Wrong: The Dalliance of Quantum Theory with the Defiance of Bell’s Inequality” by W.M. Stuckey, Timothy McDevitt, Michael Silberstein (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-01056.txt.
Introduction
Stuckey, McDevitt, and Silberstein review, in a 2025 piece, Frank Lad's book Just Plain Wrong, published in 2024 by Austin Macauley. The book takes aim at how quantum theory treats Bell's inequality, a famous test that separates quantum predictions from those of local hidden-variable theories. The review's abstract is brief, giving the book's scope rather than the reviewers' full verdict, so readers should turn to the review itself for its detailed assessment of Lad's case.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | W.M. Stuckey, Timothy McDevitt, Michael Silberstein |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 39 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-01056
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Review of “Just Plain Wrong: The Dalliance of Quantum Theory with the Defiance of Bell’s Inequality” W.M. Stuckey, Timothy McDevitt, Michael Silberstein Abstract This is a review of Frank Lad’s book “Just Plain Wrong: The Dalliance of Quantum Theory with the Defiance of Bell’s Inequality” (Austin Macauley Publishers, 2024). In the Preface of his book, Frank Lad writes ( Lad2024 , p. 10) : The book you are holding corrects a mistake that … concerns specific influential arguments regarding the defiance of Bell’s inequality that are just plain wrong, embedding a mathematical error that will be understandable to most anyone. The error has deep consequence, leading the community of quantum physicists to reject the principle of local realism, and to proclaim bizarre features of quantum phenomena that the theory does not actually support. Proponents of the error have now been deservedly feted with the award of the Nobel Prize in Physics, 2022, by a Committee who have been taken in by it. Shamelessly, but with due respect, I make bold to call them all to account. Yes, Lad claims to have found an error in what “Literally thousands upon thousands of people” (p. 202) believe about quantum entanglement and the violation of Bell inequalities (all bare page references are for Lad’s book on Kindle Lad2024 ). On pp. 12-13 he writes: The error occurs in assessing a gedankenexperiment , a thought experiment designed to assess the validity of Einstein’s insisted principle of local realism. My exposition of the error was first published in the Journal of Modern Physics in 2021. [Italics in original.] What Lad found are “functional relations” in a “realm matrix” of hidden variables explaining Bell state entanglement that Lad claims negate what the entire quantum foundations community believes about the violation of Bell inequalities. He accuses the quantum foundations community of committing an “error of neglect” (p. 13) by “neglecting [these] functional relations embedded in a gedankenexperiment” (p. 14). In order to keep this review from becoming a book itself, we will simply respond to Lad’s accusation as he presents it in his Journal of Modern Physics paper lad2021 , “Quantum Mysteries for No One,” and in Chapter 4 (p. 193), “MORE HOOJUMS THAN BOOJUMS: Quantum Mysteries for No one [sic].” The paper and chapter title refer to “Quantum Mysteries for Anyone” mermin1981a as reprinted in Mermin’s book “Boojums All the Way through: Communicating Science in a Prosaic Age” mermin1991 . Referring to another version of that paper mermin1981 , Feynman wrote ( feynman , p. 366-7) , “One of the most beautiful papers in physics that I know of is yours in the American Journal of Physics.” [Because these two papers mermin1981a ; mermin1981 make the exact same point for the “general reader,” we will refer to them collectively as “Mermin’s paper” hereafter.] Concerning “hoojums” Lad writes (p. 195), “My own allusion now to ‘hoojums’ comes from memory of my mother’s usage, referring to ‘hoojums and boojums’ as quasi-mysterious claims that amount to nonsense.” As we will show, Lad’s purported ‘discovery’ does not refute Mermin’s introduction to the mystery of quantum entanglement for the “general reader,” but actually supports it in an obfuscated fashion. Unfortunately, Lad makes two mistakes regarding the physics of Bell state entanglement which lead him to believe that the results of his “quantum gedanken simulation” are only “reminiscent of the frequency behaviour of [Mermin’s] encoded balls” (p. 229) when in fact his results are totally explicable via Mermin’s “encoded balls.” These mistakes are the source of Lad’s “bold” claim that the quantum foundations community is “just plain wrong” in the way it analyzes the violation of Bell inequalities. We will start by reviewing Mermin’s result, but before doing so it is important to explain what he did not claim. Mermin’s result has nothing to do with experimental tests of Bell’s inequality, e.g., ruling out violations of statistical independence regarding hidden variables or ruling out all forms of “local realism.” Mermin defines precisely a hypothetical underlying (hidden) physical situation in a reasonable attempt to account for the correlations of spin-entangled particles that, given well-defined assumptions, would produce experimental outcomes that do not agree with the prediction of quantum mechanics (QM) for Bell state entanglement. Whether or not his theoretical situation can be instantiated physically or tested experimentally is absolutely irrelevant to his result. In other words, as long as one does not dispute how to compute and understand measurement outcome probabilities per textbook QM, Mermin’s result is a mathematical fact that cannot be refuted. Herein, we assume the standard textbook understanding of QM and note that Lad does not dispute this in his book. With that caveat, let us start with an overview of Mermin’s “Quantum Mysteries for Anyone.” In his paper mermin1981 , Mermin introduces a device (Figure 1 ) and explains how it is operated and what it produces. The reader does not need to understand anything about QM to appreciate that this device is indeed mysterious. We will relate the operation of this device immediately to measurements of a Bell spin- \frac{1}{2} singlet state (or “singlet state” for short), since this review is written for those with a knowledge of the physics rather than for a “general reader.” Figure 1: The Mermin Device . Alice has her measuring device on the left set to 2 and Bob has his measuring device on the right set to 1. The particles have been emitted by the source in the middle and are en route to the measuring devices. Figure reproduced from Stuckey et al. MerminChallenge . The Mermin device contains a source (middle box in Figure 1 ) that emits a pair of spin- \frac{1}{2} -entangled particles in the singlet state in each trial of the experiment that is measured by Alice and Bob using Stern-Gerlach (SG) magnets (Figure 2 ). The two detectors (boxes on the left and right in Figure 1 ) controlled by Alice and Bob make measurements at detector settings (1, 2, or 3) corresponding to one of three coplanar SG magnet angles (0^{\circ},120^{\circ},\text{or}-120^{\circ}) (Figure 3 ). The detector settings (1, 2, 3) are selected randomly and independently by Alice and Bob, so we can assume each of the nine detector setting pairs (11, 12, 13, 21, 22, 23, 31, 32, 33) accounts for about \frac{1}{9} of the data. Each measurement at each detector in each trial produces either a result of R (red) or G (green), corresponding to spin up(down) or spin down(up) for Alice(Bob). Here are the two quantum-mechanical facts that produce the “Quantum Mysteries for Anyone”: Fact 1. When Alice and Bob’s settings happen to be the same in a given trial (“case (a)”), their outcomes are always the same, \frac{1}{2} of the time RR (Alice’s outcome is R and Bob’s outcome is R) and \frac{1}{2} of the time GG (Alice’s outcome is G and Bob’s outcome is G). Fact 2. When Alice and Bob’s settings happen to be different in a given trial (“case (b)”), the outcomes are the same \frac{1}{4} of the time, \frac{1}{8} RR and \frac{1}{8} GG. Per Fact 1, the Mermin device has totally correlated R-G device outcomes for case (a) corresponding to the totally anti-correlated up-down spin outcomes of the