Universal Structure of Computing Moments for Exact Quantum Dynamics: Application to Arbitrary System-Bath Couplings

Rui-Hao Bi, Wei Liu, Wenjie Dou · 2025

Read Universal Structure of Computing Moments for Exact Quantum Dynamics: Application to Arbitrary System-Bath Couplings by Rui-Hao Bi, Wei Liu, Wenjie Dou (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-00649.txt.

Introduction

Rui-Hao Bi, Wei Liu, and Wenjie Dou present a universal way to compute moments of correlation functions for exact quantum dynamics in open systems. Their 2025 paper extends recent work on memory kernel coupling theory.

Their method works for arbitrary system-bath coupling that can be written as a polynomial in the bath coordinate. They show that recursive commutators of a system operator obey a universal hierarchy. With that structure, higher-order moments come from evaluating system and bath expectations apart. Bath values come from derivatives of a generating function. They apply the method to the dipole autocorrelation function for the spin-boson model, with linear and quadratic coupling.

Catalog record

CREATORRui-Hao Bi, Wei Liu, Wenjie Dou
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE39 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-00649

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Universal Structure of Computing Moments for Exact Quantum Dynamics: Application to Arbitrary System-Bath Couplings Rui-Hao Bi, Wei Liu, Wenjie Dou Abstract We introduce a general procedure for computing higher-order moments of correlation functions in open quantum systems, extending the scope of our recent work on Memory Kernel Coupling Theory (MKCT) [ W. Liu, Y. Su, Y. Wang, and W. Dou, arXiv:2407.01923 (2024) ]. This approach is demonstrated for arbitrary system-bath coupling that can be expressed as polynomial, H S ​ B = V ^ ​ ( α 0 + α 1 ​ q ^ + α 2 ​ q ^ 2 + … ) H_{SB}=\hat{V}(\alpha_{0}+\alpha_{1}\hat{q}+\alpha_{2}\hat{q}^{2}+\dots) , where we show that the recursive commutators of a system operator obey a universal hierarchy. Exploiting this structure, the higher-order moments are obtained by evaluating the expectation values of the system and bath operators separately, with bath expectation values derived from the derivatives of a generating function. We further apply MKCT to compute the dipole autocorrelation function for the spin-boson model with both linear and quadratic coupling, achieving agreement with the hierarchical equations of motion approach. Our findings suggest a promising path toward accurate dynamics for complex open quantum systems. I Introduction The two-time correlation function, C_{AA}(t)=C_{AA}(t,0)\equiv\Tr\left(e^{\textup{i}\hat{H}t}\hat{A}e^{-\textup{i}\hat{H}t}\hat{A}\hat{\rho}_{0}\right), (1) captures the quantum dynamics of the operator \hat{A} under the Hamiltonian \hat{H} , starting from an initial state \hat{\rho}_{0} . It is fundamental to various experimental observables [ 1 ] and has recently gained significance in polaritonic chemistry [ 2 , 3 , 4 ] , spectroscopy [ 5 , 6 , 7 ] , and transport phenomena [ 8 , 9 ] . In these contexts, the quantum system interacts with a condensed-phase environment consisting of electronic and vibrational degrees of freedom, which can be described by the open quantum system Hamiltonian [ 10 ] : \hat{H}=\hat{H}_{S}+\hat{H}_{B}+\hat{H}_{SB}, (2) where \hat{H}_{S} represents the system, \hat{H}_{B} the bath, and \hat{H}_{SB} their interaction. The significance of C_{AA}(t) in open quantum systems has driven the development of numerous methods, each striking a different balance between accuracy and computational cost. At the high-accuracy end, exact methods [ 11 , 12 , 13 , 14 ] can solve small model problems but are computationally prohibitive for larger systems. To enable simulations of more complex and realistic models, various approximation methods have been developed, including perturbative approaches [ 15 , 16 ] , mode-coupling theory [ 17 , 18 ] , semi-classical methods [ 19 , 20 , 21 ] , and mixed quantum-classical methods [ 22 , 23 , 24 , 25 ] . Despite these advancements, no single approach has achieved the ideal balance between accuracy and efficiency, and the search for improved methods remains an active area of research. Projection operator techniques [ 26 , 27 , 28 , 29 ] are powerful tools for studying open quantum system dynamics. The Mori projection [ 29 ] , in particular, simplifies the problem by projecting onto the operator of interest, \hat{A} , to reduce the dimensionality. This reformulates the computation of C_{AA}(t) into finding the memory kernel, which offers a key advantage in dissipative systems: it typically decays faster than the correlation function itself [ 30 , 31 ] . However, this approach presents a challenge–the memory kernel depends on the projected propagator [ 32 ] , which is inherently difficult to handle. Significant efforts have been made to compute the memory kernel [ 33 ] , including numerically “exact” approaches [ 34 , 30 , 35 , 36 ] and various approximation methods [ 37 , 38 , 32 , 39 , 40 ] . In a recent study [ 41 ] , we introduced Memory Kernel Coupling Theory (MKCT), a novel approach for computing the memory kernel. MKCT defines a set of auxiliary higher-order memory kernels whose evolution is governed solely by the higher-order moments of the correlation function. Since the higher-order moments are pure static quantities, this means MKCT allows us to obtain the correlation function without explicitly evolving the open quantum system. However, our previous implementation relied on the Liouvillian superoperator from Dissipaton Equations of Motion (DEOM) [ 14 ] to compute the moments, limiting the broader applicability of MKCT. In this article, we present a general procedure for computing correlation function moments to arbitrary order, expanding the applicability of MKCT. We demonstrate our approach using a polynomial bosonic interaction and uncover a universal hierarchy of the recursive commutators of a system operator that determines the moments. The article is structured as follows: In Sec. II.1 , we revisit the MKCT framework and introduce a new Padé approximant-based truncation scheme. Sec. II.2 presents our novel higher-order moments computation procedure. In Sec. III , we apply our method to the spin-boson model with linear, quadratic, and combined linear–quadratic coupling. Finally, we conclude in Sec. IV . II Theory II.1 Memory Kernel Coupling Theory Following Mori’s projection approach, [ 29 ] the correlation function in Eq. 1 satisfies the generalized quantum master equation (GQME): \dot{C}_{AA}(t)=\Omega C_{AA}(t)+\int_{0}^{t}\differential{\tau}K(t-\tau)C_{AA}(\tau), (3) where the scalar \Omega and the kernel function K(t) are derived from the Mori-Zwanzig formalism: \Omega=(\textup{i}\mathcal{L}\hat{A},A)(\hat{A},\hat{A})^{-1}, (4) K(t)=(\textup{i}\mathcal{L}e^{\textup{i}t\bm{\mathcal{Q}}\mathcal{L}}\bm{\mathcal{Q}}\textup{i}\mathcal{L}\hat{A},\hat{A})(\hat{A},\hat{A})^{-1}. (5) Here, the Mori-product notation (\hat{A},\hat{B}) denotes an appropriate inner product. The Liouville operator acts on an arbitrary operator \hat{X} as \mathcal{L}\hat{X}\equiv\frac{1}{\hbar}\commutator{\hat{H}}{\hat{X}} . The projection operator is defined as \bm{\mathcal{P}}\hat{X}=(\hat{X},\hat{A})\hat{A}(\hat{A},\hat{A})^{-1} , and the complementary projection operator is \bm{\mathcal{Q}}=\bm{1}-\bm{\mathcal{P}} . In practice, \Omega is readily available and many existing works have introduced methods to approximate the kernel function K(t) . [ 38 , 32 , 42 ] Recently, we have introduced a novel method called Memory Kernel Coupling Theory (MKCT) to compute K(t) efficiently. [ 41 ] Our key idea is to extend the definition of \Omega and K(t) in the Mori GQME and introduce the higher-order moments \Omega_{n}\equiv((\textup{i}\mathcal{L})^{n}\hat{A},\hat{A})(\hat{A},\hat{A})^{-1}, (6) and the corresponding auxiliary kernels K_{n}(t)\equiv((\textup{i}\mathcal{L})^{n}\hat{f}(t),\hat{A})(\hat{A},\hat{A})^{-1}, (7) where the random fluctuation operator is \hat{f}(t)=e^{\textup{i}t\bm{\mathcal{Q}}\mathcal{L}}\bm{\mathcal{Q}}\textup{i}\mathcal{L}\hat{A} . We have shown in Ref. [ 41 ] that the higher-order kernels satisfy the following coupled ordinary differential equation (ODE): \dot{K}_{n}(t)=K_{n+1}(t)-\Omega_{n}K_{1}(t), (8) with initial conditions K_{n}(0)=\Omega_{n+1}-\Omega_{n}\Omega_{1} . This result is compelling as it reveals that the quantum dynamics can be fully encoded in a system of interconnected ODEs for the higher-order kernels. Notably, the only parameters needed to integrate \{K_{n}(t)\} are \{\Omega_{n}\} , meaning that our MKCT framework eliminates the need to explicitly evolve the operator \hat{A} within the open quantum system. However, a caveat of Eq. 8 is that the equation extends to infinite order, and there is no straightforward method to truncate it at a finite order. From our experience, a hard truncation can lead to numerical instabilities. To this end, we introduce a novel truncation scheme with Padé approximant. To begin with, notice that the m -th derivative of kernel K_{n}(t) evaluated at t=0 is K_{n}^{(m)}\equiv((\textup{i}\mathcal{L})^{n}(\bm{\mathcal{Q}}\textup{i}\mathcal{L})^{m+1}\hat{A},\hat{A})(\hat{A},\hat{A})^{-1}. (9) A recursion relation can be found by expanding \bm{\mathcal{Q}}=\bm{1}-\bm{\mathcal{P}} that K_{n}^{(m)}=K_{n+1}^{(m-1)}-\Omega_{n}\tilde{\Omega}_{m}, (10) where we have introduced the auxiliary moment \tilde{\Omega}_{m}=(\textup{i}\mathcal{L}(\bm{\mathcal{Q}}\textup{i}\mathcal{L})^{m}\hat{A},\hat{A})(\hat{A},\hat{A})^{-1}. (11) Recursively applying Eq. 10 eventually leads the following expression: K_{n}^{(m)}=\Omega_{m+n+1}-\Omega_{n}\tilde{\Omega}_{m}-\dots-\Omega_{m+n}\tilde{\Omega}_{0}, (12) that K_{n}^{(m)} can be expressed with moments and auxiliary moments. Similarly, the auxiliary moments themselves have recursions \displaystyle\tilde{\Omega}_{m} \displaystyle=(\textup{i}\mathcal{L}(\bm{\mathcal{Q}}\textup{i}\mathcal{L})^{m-1}\textup{i}\mathcal{L}\hat{A},\hat{A})(\hat{A},\hat{A})^{-1}-\tilde{\Omega}_{m-1}\Omega_{1}, (13) \displaystyle=\Omega_{m+1}-\tilde{\Omega}_{m-1}\Omega_{1}-\dots\tilde{\Omega}_{0}\Omega_{m}, which means the auxiliary moments \{\tilde{\Omega}_{m}\} can be readily obtained by the moments \{\Omega_{n}\} . The series expansion for the n -th order kernel can then

Read the complete text