Dynamical Similarity in Higher - Order Classical Symplectic Systems

Callum Bell, David Sloan · 2025

Read Dynamical Similarity in Higher - Order Classical Symplectic Systems by Callum Bell, David Sloan (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-00498.txt.

Introduction

Callum Bell and David Sloan study special symmetries in classic physical theories in a 2025 study. Many Hamiltonian theories stay unchanged under transformations called dynamical similarities, which are not quite canonical. Such a symmetry lets theorists remove one degree of freedom tied to overall scale, a step known as contact reduction.

After reduction, the remaining observable quantities form a closed system that evolves in a friction-like way. Bell and Sloan show the same procedure extends naturally to higher-order theories, where equations involve more derivatives. Worked examples carry the argument, and the authors discuss what the extension means for physical models.

Catalog record

CREATORCallum Bell, David Sloan
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE106 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-00498

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Dynamical Similarity in Higher - Order Classical Symplectic Systems Callum Bell, David Sloan Abstract Many theories of physical interest, which admit a Hamiltonian description, exhibit symmetries under a particular class of non - strictly canonical transformation, known as dynamical similarities. The presence of such symmetries allows a reduction process to be carried out, eliminating a single degree of freedom from the system, which we associate with an overall scale. This process of ‘contact reduction’ leads to theories of a frictional nature, in which the physically - observable quantities form an autonomous subsystem, that evolves in a predictable manner. We demonstrate that this procedure has a natural generalisation to theories of higher order; detailed examples are provided, and physical implications discussed. I Introduction In general, it is customary to adopt the viewpoint that isolated systems should be afforded a privileged status within the framework used to describe physical law [ 1 ] . We confer particular importance to such systems, deeming them more fundamental than their open counterparts. Indeed, when describing systems exhibiting dissipative effects, we choose to subsume this within our closed - system approach, treating open systems as part of a larger entity, comprising the original system coupled to some ‘environment’. Matter, energy, and information may be freely exchanged between the two subsystems, but the full ‘system plus environment’ complex is still considered to be closed. It was argued by Leibniz that the universe as a whole is the only truly closed system [ 2 ] ; consequently, if we dogmatically insist that closed systems are fundamental, we must logically conclude that the universe is the only fundamental entity that exists [ 3 ] . When studying symmetry - reduced solutions of the Einstein field equations, particularly within the context of Friedmann - Lemaître - Robertson - Walker (FLRW) cosmologies, we do indeed treat the universe as a closed system; however, as highlighted in [ 4 ] , this is little more than an idealisation used to reduce calculational complexity. A particularly noteworthy example of this, is the use of the scale factor, which, despite its pivotal role in the geometrical description offered by General Relativity, is generally taken to carry no physical meaning [ 5 ] . Moreover, it is possible to excise completely this unphysical degree of freedom from our cosmological ontology, leaving a purely relational description. It has been proposed that, when constructing a theory, we should first find a framework which amply admits the phenomena we wish to describe, before imposing successively more restrictive conditions, so as to reduce the amount of superfluous structure present [ 6 ] . In the current context, we posit that the notion of superfluous structure may be cast as a precise set of dynamical criteria, captured by the so - called Principle of Essential and Sufficient Autonomy (PESA) [ 7 ] . We seek a minimal ontology that closes the dynamical algebra of observables, and any structure which is not contained within this ontology is deemed surplus; since the only degrees of freedom accessible via empirical methods are dimensionless ratios, we are pushed towards a relational description of nature. This is quite a radical step, to claim that we should seek a description of reality based entirely on relational terms, and we ought to provide some additional motivation. As argued by Poincaré, a hypothetical scenario, in which all distances within our universe were suddenly increased to twice their original values, would be entirely indistinguishable from the initial configuration. This follows from the fact that our ability to deduce any such changes of scale relies upon a set of measuring instruments, which have undergone an identical doubling in size [ 8 ] . Detractors of this viewpoint, such as Galileo, and later Delboeuf [ 9 , 10 ] , reason that this argument is flawed, since fundamental parameters, such as Newton’s gravitational constant, may be used to infer that a change of scale has occurred, through the fact that biological systems, for example, would be unable to support their enlarged skeletal structures. However, we argue that the fundamental constants of nature are necessarily deduced through experiment and observation: for the case of Newton’s gravitational constant, for example, this required the use of the torsion balance, pioneered by Cavendish [ 11 ] . Consequently, it is entirely logical to consider that the artifice producing this hypothetical change of scale should also act on the parameters of our theory, thereby restoring our ability to provide a wholly relational description of nature. This issue is further explored in section ( VIII ). Despite the fact that the Lagrangian and Hamiltonian formulations of classical mechanics have been studied extensively throughout history [ 12 , 13 , 14 , 15 ] , it was not until relatively recently, with the work of mathematicians such as Souriau and Tulczyjew [ 16 , 17 , 18 , 19 ] , that these theories were placed on a geometrical footing, allowing the powerful tools of differential geometry to be applied to the study of mechanical systems [ 20 ] . In seeking a relational description of the laws governing our universe, we shall find that we are forced to work with manifolds on which phase space volumes are not conserved, and mechanical energy lost. In this way, by arguing that a minimalist approach should be taken, when attempting to formulate physical law, we are (indirectly) advocating that open systems should in fact be granted privileged status as more fundamental. In this article, we commence by presenting an introduction to higher - order geometrical mechanics, in both the Lagrangian and Hamiltonian settings. We favour the geometrical approach over the more familiar variational formulation, as our ultimate goal will be to extend our formalism to those theories whose dynamical objects are fields. This, while possible, is more difficult to do using traditional variational methods. For readers unfamiliar with the geometrical methods described, we shall present a running example, in which the underlying concepts may be understood, in a more mathematically - amenable setting. We also include an appendix, in which the variational approach is shown to produce equivalent results. In section ( IV ), we illustrate the mechanism by which the changes in scale discussed above may be implemented, before exploring how symmetry under these transformations provides a natural way in which to eliminate overall scale from our ontology. Original results, on the generalisation of this reduction process to higher - order theories are then presented in section ( VI ). Finally, we conclude with a number of examples, discussing both the utility and physical significance of our findings. II Higher - Order Symplectic Mechanics II.1 Lagrangian Formalism A geometric formulation of theories of higher order requires the introduction of a class of manifold known as higher - order tangent bundles [ 21 ] . In general, if Q is an n - dimensional smooth manifold, with bundle structure \pi:TQ\rightarrow Q , we define the n(k+1) - dimensional space T^{k}Q as the collection of all k - jets from 0\in\mathbb{R} to Q [ 22 , 23 ] , which we express as T^{k}Q\equiv J_{0}(\mathbb{R},Q)=\bigcup\limits_{q\,\in\,Q}\{j^{k}_{0}\phi\;|\;\phi:I\subset\mathbb{R}\rightarrow Q\} in which j^{k}_{0}\phi denotes the k - jet of the curve \phi:I\subset\mathbb{R}\rightarrow Q . The

Read the complete text