Demystifying CO 2 : lessons from nutrition labeling and step counting Conference: ; May 11–16, 2024; Honolulu, HI, USA
Alexandre Filipowicz, David A. Shamma, Vikram Mohanty, Candice L. Hogan · 2025
Read Demystifying CO 2 : lessons from nutrition labeling and step counting Conference: ; May 11–16, 2024; Honolulu, HI, USA by Alexandre Filipowicz, David A. Shamma, Vikram Mohanty, Candice L. Hogan (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-00333.txt.
Introduction
Alexandre Filipowicz and co-authors ask how to make carbon dioxide numbers feel real to the public. Their 2025 position piece notes that CO2 units are abstract, so people struggle to weigh the impact of daily choices. Two older fields faced the same snag: food calories and step counts.
Studies in those fields show that steady, wide-spread messaging makes an abstract unit familiar. People then think about it with more care. But sharper understanding alone does not promise changed behavior. The authors argue that the same steady messaging could ground CO2 for the public. That grounding may then help programs that aim at greener habits.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Alexandre Filipowicz, David A. Shamma, Vikram Mohanty, Candice L. Hogan |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 22 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-00333
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Demystifying CO 2 : lessons from nutrition labeling and step counting Conference: ; May 11–16, 2024; Honolulu, HI, USA Alexandre Filipowicz, David A. Shamma, Vikram Mohanty, Candice L. Hogan Abstract . There is growing concern about climate change and increased interest in taking action. However, people have difficulty understanding abstract units like CO 2 and the relative environmental impact of different behaviors. This position piece explores findings from nutritional labeling and step counting research, two domains aimed at making abstract concepts (i.e., calories and exercise) more familiar to the general public. Research in these two domains suggests that consistent, widespread communication can make people more familiar and think more precisely about abstract units, but that better communication and understanding does not guarantee behavior change. These findings suggest that consistent and ubiquitous communication can make CO 2 units more familiar to people, which in turn could help interventions aimed at encouraging more sustainable behaviors. 1. Introduction People around the world are growing increasingly concerned about their impact on the climate. A 2024 international survey identified that 86% of respondents agreed that people in their countries should fight climate change ( Andre et al. 2024 ) . People also want to take action – 69% of respondents in the same survey were willing to donate 1% of their annual salary if it could help tackle climate change ( Andre et al. 2024 ) . However, knowing which behaviors to change and in what respect can be challenging. People have difficulty estimating the real climate impact of their behaviors, tending to overestimate the impact of relatively-low intensity behaviors (e.g., turning off lights) and underestimating the impact of higher-intensity behaviors (e.g., long flights) ( Attari et al. 2010 ; Nielsen et al. 2021 ; Wynes et al. 2018 ) . This misunderstanding of the relative impact of different behaviors can thus lead individuals to focus their efforts on changing behaviors that do relatively little to mitigate their overall impact on the environment ( Nielsen et al. 2021 ) . To improve people’s understanding of their impact on the environment, user interface designers have explored ways to improve carbon literacy ( Sanguinetti et al. 2018 ; Nielsen et al. 2021 ; Mohanty et al. 2023 ; West et al. 2016 ; EPA 2022a ; Mulrow et al. 2019 ) . Carbon footprint calculators have been designed to help people see and track the environmental impact of different behaviors ( West et al. 2016 ; EPA 2022a ; Mulrow et al. 2019 ) . Additionally, interface designers are increasingly interested in displaying carbon information like CO 2 at decision points to encourage people to make more sustainable choices. These types of interventions have shown some promise: displaying information about carbon emissions can successfully help people choose less carbon intensive flights ( Sanguinetti and Amenta 2022 ) , ground transportation choices ( Mohanty et al. 2023 ; Filipowicz et al. 2023 ) and items on a food menu ( Beyer et al. 2024 ) . Although many of these efforts have shown that information about carbon can influence people’s choices, this is not sufficient to improve people’s carbon literacy. Mohanty and colleagues ( Mohanty et al. 2023 ) found that although information about CO 2 helped people make more sustainable transportation choices, and people preferred information about CO 2 over many other equivalencies (e.g., trees or gallons of gasoline), metrics like CO 2 are too abstract and people expressed that they did not have a good understanding of how different quantities of CO 2 relate to climate change. In this position piece we explore findings from two other domains, nutrition labeling and step counting, that encountered similar issues of trying to communicate abstract metrics (e.g., calories, physical activity) to the general public. We examine the aspects of these efforts that worked and those that failed and relate these to current efforts aimed at improving carbon literacy. From this work, we derive a set of recommendations about ways in which interfaces can help improve carbon literacy and lead people to make more consistent sustainable choices. 2. Related work There are a number of systems that aim to educate and help people track the environmental impact of different behaviors. Carbon footprint calculators are a common interface used to help improve carbon literacy ( West et al. 2016 ; EPA 2022a ; Mulrow et al. 2019 ) . These calculators aim to help people track the emission intensity of everyday behaviors (e.g., home energy usage, food consumption, and transportation), visualize the impact of these different behaviors, and in some cases provide behavioral recommendations to reduce people’s impact on the environment ( West et al. 2016 ; Mulrow et al. 2019 ) . However, carbon calculators can be difficult to use effectively. They can require considerable effort on the part of the user (e.g., frequent input), are not always comprehensive (e.g., focus on home energy but not transportation), and do not always provide the information people need to remain motivated ( Mulrow et al. 2019 ) . Consequently, people using carbon calculators tend not to remember the insights these tools provide and lose motivation for their usage ( Mulrow et al. 2019 ) . Designers have also explored ways of embedding different forms of eco-feedback into user interfaces to notify users of the actual or potential CO 2 emissions related to their behaviors, and encourage more sustainable choices ( Sanguinetti et al. 2018 ; Mohanty et al. 2023 ; Filipowicz et al. 2023 ; Sanguinetti and Amenta 2022 ) . Sanguinetti and colleagues ( Sanguinetti et al. 2018 ) offer a comprehensive framework to help designers identify factors needed for effective eco-feedback, including the properties of the information being presented, the information timing, and the type of display. Eco-feedback interfaces tend to focus on a specific behavior, such as when a person is driving ( Fafoutellis et al. 2020 ) , or when a particular choice is being made (e.g., using a website or app to select a flight ( Sanguinetti and Amenta 2022 ) ). Interfaces using eco-feedback are generally effective at encouraging more sustainable behaviors. For example, displaying information about emissions in vehicle encourages more efficient driving ( Fafoutellis et al. 2020 ) and interfaces that display the carbon intensity of different options can lead to less carbon intensive choices related to flights ( Sanguinetti and Amenta 2022 ) , ride-sharing and vehicle rental services ( Mohanty et al. 2023 ) , electric vehicle charging schedules ( Filipowicz et al. 2023 ) , and food menu items ( Beyer et al. 2024 ) . However, although people prefer lower carbon intensity options, they do not have a point of reference to compare different metrics of carbon. How much is 1 kg of CO 2 ? What does this amount mean for climate change? Mohanty and colleagues ( Mohanty et al. 2023 ) found that although people prioritized ride-sharing and rental vehicle choices that were less carbon intensive, their choices were not influenced by the numeric CO 2 values. This suggests that people use information about carbon as more of a heuristic, preferring lower CO 2 alternatives without knowing whether this lower CO 2 alternative is “low enough” compared to