Localization of GW190521 and reconstruction of the spin-2 gravitational-wave polarization modes

Osvaldo M. Moreschi · 2025

Read Localization of GW190521 and reconstruction of the spin-2 gravitational-wave polarization modes by Osvaldo M. Moreschi (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-00207.txt.

Introduction

Osvaldo Moreschi localizes a gravitational wave event and reconstructs its polarization modes with an independent method, in a paper from 2025. The event was recorded by three observatories and is a key heavy merger case. Independent checks of sky position strengthen trust in the standard pipeline.

His procedure uses timing rings from detector pairs to pin the source on the sky. The source falls near a crossing of two delay rings, as the method predicts. Results agree with the main collaboration findings, which supports the approach. He also presents a direct measurement of the spin-two polarization modes carried by the wave.

Catalog record

CREATOROsvaldo M. Moreschi
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE39 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-00207

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Localization of GW190521 and reconstruction of the spin-2 gravitational-wave polarization modes Osvaldo M. Moreschi Abstract We report on the new developments of the procedure L2D+PMR for sky localization ( Abbott et al 2020a ) using data from two gravitational-wave detectors and the reconstruction of gravitational-wave polarization modes ( Poisson and Will 2014 ) , which we have previously presented ( Moreschi 2025 ) . In this case we apply our methods to the GW190521 ( Abbott et al 2020b ) event, which was recorded by three gravitational-wave observatories. We find the localization of the source close to one of the crossings of two delay rings, as expected. Thus, our results corroborate the consistency of the procedure. We compare our findings with those obtained by the LIGO/Virgo Collaborations, providing an independent assessment of gravitational-wave localization. We present the second direct measurement of spin-2 gravitational-wave polarization modes. keywords Gravitational waves, Gravitational wave astronomy, Astronomy data analysis 1 Introduction This is the second article in a series dedicated to the application and examination of the L2D+PMR procedure, originally introduced in Moreschi 2025 . This method enables the sky localization of a gravitational-wave source using data from only two observatories while also allowing for the reconstruction of the spin-2 polarization modes (PMs) of the detected gravitational wave (GW). By further validating and refining this procedure, we aim to demonstrate its robustness and applicability to real gravitational-wave events. The problem of localizing the sky position of a gravitational-wave source ( Abbott et al 2020a ) changes significantly when more than two detectors record the signal, compared to the case where only two detectors are involved. This is the case of the event GW190521 ( Abbott et al 2020b ) , where the two LIGO, Hanford and Livingston and the Virgo detectors have recorded the signals. This allows for improving the basic localization technique supported on the information of time delays among the observatories. With only two detectors, the source is typically constrained to a ring-like region on the celestial sphere, defined by the possible arrival-time delays between the two observatories. However, with a third detector, the localization is improved: instead of an extended ring, the source is now constrained to two possible points, determined by the intersection of two delay rings. This improved localization provides a stronger foundation for multi-messenger follow-up observations and enhances the astrophysical interpretation of the event. Therefore, if an independent localization method is applied, it should yield a position close to one of the two possible points determined by the delay ring intersections. This is precisely one of the key results we present in this article. When applying the L2D+PMR procedure, which we previously introduced in ( Moreschi 2025 ) , to the event GW190521, our method provides a localization close to the southern intersection point of the Hanford–Livingston (H-L) delay ring and the Virgo–Livingston (V-L) delay ring. This result is in excellent agreement with expectations and serves as a strong corroboration of the accuracy and reliability of our method. Our techniques do not rely on the parameters of a specific physical model of the source. Instead, they are based purely on the fundamental spin-2 polarization properties of GWs ( Eardley et al 1973b ; Eardley et al 1973a ; Poisson and Will 2014 ) . This intrinsic approach allows for a more model-independent analysis, avoiding biases introduced by assumed astrophysical parameters. As a result, our method not only enables precise source localization using just two detectors but also facilitates the direct reconstruction of the two PMs of the gravitational-wave signal. This is a crucial result, as it allows for a direct observational test of General Relativity’s prediction that GWs of astrophysical origin exhibit only two tensorial polarization states(See discussion in Moreschi 2025 .). Accordingly, in this work, we present the second-ever direct measurement of the + (plus) and \times (cross) polarization modes of a GW. This article focuses on the application of the L2D+PMR procedure to the GW190521 event. Rather than explore the detailed astrophysical parameters of a specific source model, our primary objective is to provide localization results and PM reconstruction using only the fundamental theoretical framework of a spin-2 GW. This approach ensures that our results remain as model-independent as possible. The GW190521 event, which was observed during the O3a LIGO/Virgo run, has strong enough signals which allow us to apply our procedure, and enables us to not only perform an independent localization of the source but also to extract the spin-2 PM of the detected GW. In Abbott et al 2020c the LIGO and Virgo Collaborations presented a detailed analysis of the gravitational-wave signals of the GW190521 event, and concluded that it was consistent with a binary black hole merger at redshift 0.8 with high component masses of 85M_{\odot} and 66M_{\odot} . However these values were later updated on May 13, 2022, on the official event webpage gwosc.GW190521 , which revised the estimates to a redshift of 0.56 with component masses of 98.4M_{\odot} and 57.2M_{\odot} . In this work, we compare our localization results with those reported in Abbott et al 2020c , providing an independent assessment of the sky position of the source. The subject of localization has also been explored in Szczepańczyk et al 2021 , where their sky maps exhibit localization regions that closely resemble those reported by the LIGO/Virgo Collaborations. This article is organized as follows. In section 2 we recall the basic equation that relates the recorded signal in each gravitational-wave detector with the spin-2 polarization modes. The characteristics of the strain for this event are mentioned in section 3 . The way in which we obtained the relatives time delays for this event is described in section 4 . In section 5 we present the results of applying the denoising techniques to this case. The study of the strains in the time-frequency domain is presented in section 6 ; where both scalograms are shown. The description of the universal fitting process along with its results is presented in section 7 . The localization of the source of GW190521 is shown in section 8 along with its comparison with LIGO results. The reconstruction of the gravitational-wave PM for this event is presented in section 9 ; which is shown in several polarization frames. In section 10 we test the possible content in this strains from other spin PMs. We reserve section 11 for final comments. 2 Gravitational wave in terms of the spin-2 polarization modes The content of a gravitational-wave signal detected by an observatory X is shaped by the detector’s response, which is modulated by its antenna pattern functions. These functions account for the detector’s sensitivity to different polarization modes depending on the source’s sky position, inclination, and polarization angle. This modulation is mathematically described in Equation 1 , where the recorded signal is expressed as a linear combination of the two spin-2 polarization modes weighted by the detector’s pattern functions. The pattern functions depend on the relative orientation of the detector’s arms with respect to the incoming GW, which introduces directional dependence into the observed signal; and also depend on the angle of the polarization frame, discussed in Moreschi 2025 . As a result, different detectors will record a particular

Read the complete text