BOWIE-ALIGN: Sub-stellar metallicity and carbon depletion in the aligned TrES-4b with JWST NIRSpec transmission spectroscopy

Annabella Meech, Alastair B. Claringbold, Eva-Maria Ahrer, James Kirk, Mercedes López-Morales, Jake Taylor, Richard A. Booth, Anna B.T. Penzlin, Lili Alderson, Duncan A. Christie, Emma Esparza-Borges, Charlotte Fairman, Nathan J. Mayne, Mason McCormack, James E. Owen, Vatsal Panwar, Diana Powell, De · 2025

Read BOWIE-ALIGN: Sub-stellar metallicity and carbon depletion in the aligned TrES-4b with JWST NIRSpec transmission spectroscopy by Annabella Meech, Alastair B. Claringbold, Eva-Maria Ahrer, James Kirk, Mercedes López-Morales, Jake Taylor, Richard A. Booth, Anna B.T. Penzlin, Lili Alderson, Duncan A. Christie, Emma Esparza-Borges, Charlotte Fairman, Nathan J. Mayne, Mason McCormack, James E. Owen, Vatsal Panwar, Diana Powell, De (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-24280.txt.

Introduction

Annabella Meech and co-authors read the air of a hot Jupiter in this 2025 paper. The planet, TrES-4b, circles its star in step with the star's spin, and the team watched starlight filter through its atmosphere with the Webb telescope.

Water vapor showed up clearly, with hints of carbon monoxide and a trace of carbon dioxide. The carbon to oxygen ratio landed between 0.30 and 0.42, and the air's metal content measured only about half the Sun's, below its star. Those lean values strain standard formation stories. The authors suggest the planet drank oxygen rich gas, or mixed poor gas with carbon poor solids. The work feeds a program comparing aligned and tilted hot Jupiters.

Catalog record

CREATORAnnabella Meech, Alastair B. Claringbold, Eva-Maria Ahrer, James Kirk, Mercedes López-Morales, Jake Taylor, Richard A. Booth, Anna B.T. Penzlin, Lili Alderson, Duncan A. Christie, Emma Esparza-Borges, Charlotte Fairman, Nathan J. Mayne, Mason McCormack, James E. Owen, Vatsal Panwar, Diana Powell, De
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE94 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-24280

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

BOWIE-ALIGN: Sub-stellar metallicity and carbon depletion in the aligned TrES-4b with JWST NIRSpec transmission spectroscopy Annabella Meech, Alastair B. Claringbold, Eva-Maria Ahrer, James Kirk, Mercedes López-Morales, Jake Taylor, Richard A. Booth, Anna B.T. Penzlin, Lili Alderson, Duncan A. Christie, Emma Esparza-Borges, Charlotte Fairman, Nathan J. Mayne, Mason McCormack, James E. Owen, Vatsal Panwar, Diana Powell, Denis E. Sergeev, Daniel Valentine, Hannah R. Wakeford, Peter J. Wheatley, Maria Zamyatina Abstract The formation and migration history of a planet is expected to be imprinted in its atmosphere, in particular its carbon-to-oxygen (C/O) ratio and metallicity. The BOWIE-ALIGN programme is performing a comparative study of JWST spectra of four aligned and four misaligned hot Jupiters, with the aim of characterising their atmospheres and corroborating the link between the observables and the formation history. In this work, we present the 2.8 − 5.2 2.8-5.2 micron transmission spectrum of TrES-4 b, a hot Jupiter with an orbit aligned with the rotation axis of its F-type host star. Using free chemistry atmospheric retrievals, we report a confident detection of H 2 O at an abundance of log ⁡ X H 2 ​ O = − 2.98 − 0.73 + 0.68 \log X_{\mathrm{H_{2}O}}=-2.98^{+0.68}_{-0.73} at a significance of 8.4 ​ σ 8.4\sigma . We also find evidence for CO and small amounts of CO 2 , retrieving abundances log ⁡ X CO = − 3.76 − 1.01 + 0.89 \log X_{\mathrm{CO}}=-3.76^{+0.89}_{-1.01} and log ⁡ X CO 2 = − 6.86 − 0.65 + 0.62 \log X_{\mathrm{CO_{2}}}=-6.86^{+0.62}_{-0.65} ( 3.1 ​ σ 3.1\sigma and 4.0 ​ σ 4.0\sigma respectively). The observations are consistent with the the atmosphere being in chemical equilibrium; our retrievals yield C / O \mathrm{C/O} between 0.30 − 0.42 0.30-0.42 and constrain the atmospheric metallicity to the range 0.4 − 0.7 × 0.4-0.7\times solar. The inferred sub-stellar properties (C/O and metallicity) challenge traditional models, and could have arisen from an oxygen-rich gas accretion scenario, or a combination of low-metallicity gas and carbon-poor solid accretion. 2026 BOWIE-ALIGN: Sub-stellar metallicity and carbon depletion in the aligned TrES-4b with JWST NIRSpec transmission spectroscopy – 20 1 Introduction In the field of exoplanet atmospheres, we are in the era of exquisite data sensitivity, sufficient to probe chemical abundances and derive precise carbon-to-oxygen ( \mathrm{C/O} ) ratios and atmospheric metallicities, thanks to the resolution and near-infrared wavelength coverage of the instruments on JWST ( 89 ; 78 ; 25 ; 3 ; 1 ) . The challenge is now to interpret these measurements, linking them to exoplanet formation and evolution history. Early ideas ( Öberg et al., 2011 ; Madhusudhan, 2012 , e.g.,) suggested that atmospheric \mathrm{C/O} can be used to inform where a planet formed in the protoplanetary disc with respect to snow lines of the dominant volatiles, such as \text{H}{\vphantom{\text{X}}}_{\smash[t]{\text{2}}}\text{O} , CO and \text{CO}{\vphantom{\text{X}}}_{\smash[t]{\text{2}}} . However, more recent studies have challenged that idea. For example, the radial composition profile of the disc varies between systems ( Law et al., 2021 ) , with different initial metallicities and host stars. Also, the radial location of snowlines in protoplanetary discs evolve over time ( Morbidelli et al., 2016 ; Owen, 2020 ; Eistrup et al., 2018 ) , and volatile-carrying solids drift through the discs ( Booth et al., 2017 ; Schneider & Bitsch, 2021 , e.g.,) . More recently, 70 demonstrated that the highly unconstrained nature of key planet formation and disc parameters – e.g., temperature profile, dust-to-gas ratio and chemical composition within the disc – make it difficult to precisely predict the atmospheric composition of individual exoplanets from formation models. However, the key insight from 70 is that comparing populations of planets (as opposed to single systems) with different migration histories could constrain planet formation models. Specifically, they show that the C/O and metallicity of close-in exoplanets that evolve through migration in a disc should be different from close-in exoplanets that undergo disc-free migration, after formation at another location in the disc. Table 1: Adopted system parameters. Parameter [Unit] Value Star T_{*} [K] 6295\pm 65 M_{*}\,[M_{\odot}] 1.45\pm 0.05 R_{*}\,[R_{\odot}] 1.81\pm 0.08 \log g_{*} [cgs] 4.09\pm 0.03 \mathrm{[Fe/H]} 0.28\pm 0.09 Planet P [days] 3.55392889\pm 0.00000044^{\dagger} M_{\mathrm{p}}[M_{\mathrm{J}}] 0.494\pm 0.035 R_{\mathrm{p}}[R_{\mathrm{J}}] 1.838{\begin{subarray}{c}+0.081\\ -0.090\end{subarray}} T_{\mathrm{eq}} [K] 1795{\begin{subarray}{c}+35\\ -39\end{subarray}} e\cos\omega 0.0010{\begin{subarray}{c}+0.0022\\ -0.0017\end{subarray}} e\sin\omega 0{\begin{subarray}{c}+0.012\\ -0.022\end{subarray}} \dagger All values from Sozzetti et al. (2015) , with the exception of the period, P , from Kokori et al. (2023) . The BOWIE-ALIGN survey (Bristol, Oxford, Warwick, Imperial, Exeter - A spectral Light Investigation into gas Giant origiNs; JWST GO 3838; PIs: Kirk & Ahrer) seeks to characterise the atmospheres of eight hot Jupiters in order to test tracers of planet formation. The prudently curated sample consists of four planets believed to have migrated through a disc, and four believed to have undergone disc-free migration, based on the current alignments of their orbital planes with respect to the rotational plane of their host stars. The targets are considered ‘aligned’ if their sky-projected obliquity |\lambda|<30^{\circ} , and ‘misaligned’ if |\lambda|>45^{\circ} , based on the definition in Spalding & Winn (2022) . The main objectives, methods, and target selection for this programme are outlined in the survey paper, Kirk et al. (2024a) , while the theoretical basis is explored in 70 . To date, the transmission spectrum of one target from this program has been published, the misaligned hot Jupiter WASP-15 b. In Kirk et al. (2025) , we found WASP-15 b to host a super-stellar metallicity atmosphere, with a solar C/O, and evidence of \text{SO}{\vphantom{\text{X}}}_{\smash[t]{\text{2}}} absorption, the combination of which points to late planetesimal accretion. Here we present the transmission spectrum of the second target in the BOWIE-ALIGN sample, TrES-4 b. The hot Jupiter TrES-4 b ( Sozzetti et al., 2015 , R_{\mathrm{p}}=1.838{\begin{subarray}{c}+0.081\\ -0.090\end{subarray}}\,R_{\mathrm{J}} , M_{\mathrm{p}}=0.494\pm 0.035\,M_{\mathrm{J}} , T_{\mathrm{eq}}=1795 K;) , discovered by Mandushev et al. (2007) , is one of the four aligned planets in the sample. It orbits an F-type host star ( Mandushev et al., 2007 ) , which is crucially above the Kraft break, as are all of the targets in the programme. The ‘Kraft break’, at T_{\mathrm{eff}}\simeq 6100 K, is a distinct shift in the rotation rates of stars, thought to occur due to the magnetic braking contribution of the convective zone in cooler stars ( Kraft, 1967 ; Beyer & White, 2024 ) . It was later observed that the hotter stars above the Kraft break are seen to host hot Jupiters with various orbital obliquities, while the cooler stars below show predominantly low stellar obliquities ( Winn et al., 2010 ; Albrecht et al., 2012 ) . Regarding the latter, misaligned hot Jupiters are thought to invoke stellar tides which can act to realign the stellar spin axis with the planet orbital plane. This is more efficient for the cooler stars; with deeper surface convective zones and consequent stronger magnetic braking, these stars have lower angular momentum which can be overcome by the planet ( Lin & Ogilvie, 2017 ; Dawson, 2014 ) . On the reverse, stars above the Kraft break have thin surface convective zones, which do not produce efficient tides. There is a period in which stars above the Kraft break (with masses 1.2\,M_{\odot}<M_{*}\lesssim 5\,M_{\odot} 1 1 1 Stars more massive than 4-5 M ⊙ become radiative on the

Read the complete text