TOPz: Photometric redshifts using template fitting applied to the GAMA survey

E. Tempel, J. Laur, Z. R. Jones, R. Kipper, L. J. Liivamägi, D. Pandey, G. Sakteos, A. Tamm, A. N. Triantafyllaki, T. Tuvikene · 2025

Read TOPz: Photometric redshifts using template fitting applied to the GAMA survey by E. Tempel, J. Laur, Z. R. Jones, R. Kipper, L. J. Liivamägi, D. Pandey, G. Sakteos, A. Tamm, A. N. Triantafyllaki, T. Tuvikene (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-24039.txt.

Introduction

E. Tempel, J. Laur, and colleagues present a code that estimates galaxy distances from colors alone in a 2025 astronomy study. Spectroscopic redshifts are exact but slow, so large surveys lean on photometric estimates fitted against template spectra. Their code, built at Tartu Observatory, was applied to a major galaxy survey catalogue with photometry in nine bands.

Estimated redshifts are checked against the spectroscopic values available for the same galaxies. Accuracy statistics tell cosmologists how much weight the photometric distances can bear in studies of galaxy evolution. Reliable cheap distances multiply the value of every wide imaging survey.

Catalog record

CREATORE. Tempel, J. Laur, Z. R. Jones, R. Kipper, L. J. Liivamägi, D. Pandey, G. Sakteos, A. Tamm, A. N. Triantafyllaki, T. Tuvikene
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE107 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-24039

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

TOPz: Photometric redshifts using template fitting applied to the GAMA survey E. Tempel, J. Laur, Z. R. Jones, R. Kipper, L. J. Liivamägi, D. Pandey, G. Sakteos, A. Tamm, A. N. Triantafyllaki, T. Tuvikene Abstract Context. Accurate photometric redshift (photo-z) estimation is crucial for cosmological and galaxy evolution studies, especially with the advent of large-scale photometric surveys. Aims. We developed a photo-z estimation code called TOPz (Tartu Observatory Photo-z) and applied it to the GAMA photometric catalogue. Using nine-band photometric data from the GAMA project, we assessed the accuracy of TOPz by comparing its photo-z estimates to available spectroscopic redshifts from GAMA and DESI DR1. The latter extends to z < 2 z<2 and m Z < 24 m_{Z}<24 , allowing the photo-z accuracy to be validated beyond the GAMA limits. Methods. TOPz employs a Bayesian template-fitting approach to estimate photo-z from marginalised redshift posteriors. We generated synthetic galaxy spectra using the CIGALE software and ran template set optimisation. We improved the photometry by applying flux and flux uncertainty corrections. An analytical prior was then imposed on the resulting posteriors to refine the redshift estimates. Results. The photo-z estimates produced by TOPz show good agreement with the spectroscopic redshifts in the low-redshift regime ( z < 0.5 z<0.5 ) where the majority (95%) of the GAMA spectroscopic redshifts are. We demonstrate the redshift accuracy across various magnitude bins and tested how the flux corrections and posteriors reflect the actual uncertainty of the estimates. For the GAMA sample, the σ NMAD = 0.012 \sigma_{\mathrm{NMAD}}=0.012 for m Z < 18 m_{Z}<18 and increases to σ NMAD = 0.021 \sigma_{\mathrm{NMAD}}=0.021 for m Z > 19 m_{Z}>19 . The outlier fraction ( | Δ ​ z | / ( 1 + z ) > 0.1 |\Delta z|/(1+z)>0.1 ) in the same magnitude bins increases from 1% to 5%. We show that the TOPz results are consistent with those obtained from other photo-z codes (EAZY and SFM) applied to the same data set. Additionally, TOPz estimates stellar masses as a by-product, comparable to those calculated by other methods. We have made the full GAMA photo-z catalogue and all the codes and scripts used for the analysis and figures publicly available. Conclusions. TOPz is an advanced photo-z estimation code that integrates flux corrections, physical priors, and template set optimisation to provide state-of-the-art photo-z among competing template-based redshift estimators. Future work will focus on incorporating additional photometric data and applying the TOPz algorithm to the J-PAS narrow-band survey, further validating and enhancing its capabilities. 1 Introduction Photometric redshifts (photo-z) are essential in cosmology and galaxy evolution studies, allowing the expansion of galaxy samples limited by spectroscopic surveys. New surveys such as the Rubin Observatory, Euclid, and Roman Space Telescope will provide deep photometry over large sky areas that allow the inclusion of faint galaxies in the analysis. Estimating accurate photo-z for them is crucial since the number of objects is too numerous for spectroscopic follow-up. Salvato et al. (2019) and Newman & Gruen (2022) provide an excellent overview of how current photo-z codes have to be improved to take advantage of the next-generation photometric surveys. A wide variety of methods have been developed for estimating photo-z. They are divided into two primary categories based on machine learning or template fitting. Machine-learning methods include neural networks ( Sadeh et al. 2016 ; Bilicki et al. 2018 ; D’Isanto & Polsterer 2018 ; Pasquet et al. 2019 ; Schuldt et al. 2021 ; Jones et al. 2024 ; Treyer et al. 2024 ; Pathi et al. 2025 ) , random forests or decision trees ( Gerdes et al. 2010 ; Carrasco Kind & Brunner 2013 ) , Gaussian processes ( Almosallam et al. 2016a ; Almosallam et al. 2016b ; Soo et al. 2021 ) , a genetic algorithm ( Hogan et al. 2015 ) , or other machine-learning approaches ( Hatfield et al. 2020 ; Ansari et al. 2021 ; Razim et al. 2021 ; Duncan 2022 ) . In the machine-learning approach, there is a need for a spectroscopic training sample, which is also used in methods using direct neighbourhood fitting ( De Vicente et al. 2016 ) or scaled flux matching ( Baldry et al. 2021 ) . While these methods provide excellent results, they are limited to the set of galaxy types and redshift ranges covered by the spectroscopic training set ( Hildebrandt et al. 2008 ; Beck et al. 2017 ; Toribio San Cipriano et al. 2024 , e.g.) . Solutions to overcome this are proposed by augmenting the spectroscopic samples with simulated data ( Moskowitz et al. 2024 ) or aiding the photo-z estimation with a classification algorithm ( Fotopoulou & Paltani 2018 ) . Template-fitting-based photo-z estimation overcomes many problems related to methods that use spectroscopic samples as a training set. Template fitting in its general form allows a Bayesian inference ( Laplace 1774 ) to estimate photo-z posteriors. However, not all template-fitting algorithms are Bayesian in nature. Additionally, when input templates are physical, template-fitting methods can provide a rough estimate for the physical properties of galaxies. Examples of template-fitting application include the following: EAZY ( Brammer et al. 2008 ) , LePhare ( Arnouts et al. 1999 ; Ilbert et al. 2006 ) , BPZ ( Benítez 2000 ) , ZEBRA ( Feldmann et al. 2006 ) , HyperZ ( Bolzonella et al. 2000 ) , and TOPz ( Laur et al. 2022 ) . Lately, hybrid methods that combine machine learning and template fitting are emerging ( Hatfield et al. 2022 ; Tanigawa et al. 2024 ) or hybrid techniques that combine spectroscopic training sets with template fitting ( Beck et al. 2016 ) that improve the photo-z accuracy ( Cavuoti et al. 2017 ) . Many factors influence the accuracy and performance of different template-fitting photo-z codes and methods. The dependence of the used set of templates has been studied in Bolzonella et al. (2000) or the combination of different sets of templates ( Duncan et al. 2018 ) , both aiming to improve the accuracy of the photo-z estimation. Brinchmann et al. (2017) demonstrate that template-fitting photo-z codes are reliable down to the 30th magnitude utilising the MUSE observations ( Bacon et al. 2017 ) . The need to constantly improve photo-z estimation methods has been a result of applying it to numerous photometric surveys in the past, such as the PAU survey ( Navarro-Gironés et al. 2024 ) , KiDS survey ( Bilicki et al. 2018 ) , ALHAMBRA survey ( Molino et al. 2014 ) , DESI Legacy Imaging Survey ( Zou et al. 2019 ) , miniJPAS survey ( Hernán-Caballero et al. 2021 ) , or covering the whole extra-Galactic sky ( Bilicki et al. 2016 ) . Wittman et al. (2016) point out that photo-z methods tend to be overconfident and underestimate the actual uncertainty when photo-z is compared with spectroscopic measurements, resulting in many occasions of overly optimistic estimates ( Brescia et al. 2019 ) . Comparisons between different photo-z codes have been made in various contexts. They all have allowed the conclusion to be drawn that there is no particular method or set of spectral templates that significantly outperforms others and further

Read the complete text