Giant counter-rotating oscillations on the attosecond timescale
Jakob Nicolai Bruhnke, Edvin Olofsson, Axel Stenquist, Jan Marcus Dahlström † {}^{\text{\dagger}} · 2025
Read Giant counter-rotating oscillations on the attosecond timescale by Jakob Nicolai Bruhnke, Edvin Olofsson, Axel Stenquist, Jan Marcus Dahlström † {}^{\text{\dagger}} (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-24038.txt.
Introduction
Bruhnke, Olofsson, Stenquist, and Dahlström predict a new kind of light-driven atomic dance: giant oscillations that spin against the driving field, ticking on attosecond scales. When ultraviolet light couples two atomic states hard enough, the usual back-and-forth Rabi swing is joined by counter-rotating swings of similar size.
Oddly, only the excited state joins the new dance while the ground state sits it out, making the effect one-directional. Helium's two-photon swing between its ground state and a high state looks like a realistic stage with today's pulses. Their 2025 paper checks the prediction with two theory tools against full simulations. The authors frame it as ultrastrong coupling beyond the two-level picture.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jakob Nicolai Bruhnke, Edvin Olofsson, Axel Stenquist, Jan Marcus Dahlström † {}^{\text{\dagger}} |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 31 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-24038
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Giant counter-rotating oscillations on the attosecond timescale Jakob Nicolai Bruhnke, Edvin Olofsson, Axel Stenquist, Jan Marcus Dahlström † {}^{\text{\dagger}} Abstract We predict an unexplored type of ultrastrong coupling between atoms and intense ultraviolet light that leads to giant population oscillations on the attosecond timescale. These counter-rotating oscillations can be of similar amplitude as the elementary femtosecond Rabi oscillations between the two strongly coupled states. The effect, which is beyond the two-level atom, is non-reciprocal: It only affects the excited state, while the ground state is unaffected. We propose that two-photon Rabi oscillations (1s 2 –1s3d) in helium is suitable for the generation of this type of ultrastrong coupling with realistic pulses. We use a combination of Floquet theory and effective Hamiltonian theory to test our predictions against ab initio simulations. Preprint: APS/123-QED {}^{\text{\dagger}} [email protected] The rotating wave approximation (RWA) is an important simplifying assumption in light matter interaction because it helps to circumvent quantum fluctuations by enforcing energy conservation between atoms and photons [ 1 ] . Understanding the breakdown of the RWA is at the foundation of diverse research fields, such as ultrafast strong-field physics [ 2 ] and cavity quantum electrodynamics (cQED) [ 3 ] . Historically, counter-rotating (CR) effects in two-level systems were explored in pioneering works by Bloch and Siegert [ 4 ] , and Autler and Townes [ 5 ] . In further work, Shirley introduced Floquet theory as a limit of quantum optics, with infinite photon numbers and cavity volume [ 6 ] , to derive phenomena beyond the RWA in the form of an induced energy shift (Bloch-Siegert shift) [ 4 ] , as well as sub-cycle modulations of the atomic populations (CR oscillations). Due to limits of laser technology at the time, Shirley dismissed these CR oscillations as unobservable, and calculated averaged transition probabilities that did not depend on the instantaneous electric field. In the same spirit, weak and rapid fluctuations of populations that occur in exact propagation of the time-dependent Schrödinger equation (TDSE) for hydrogen atoms in strong fields, have – if at all – been mentioned in passing [ 7 , 8 , 9 ] . In cQED, strong coupling effects are studied using the quantum Rabi model [ 10 ] . Here, “CR effects” implies a breakdown of the Jaynes-Cummings model [ 11 ] , with eigenstates being composed of energy non-conserving uncoupled atom-field states in the “ultrastrong coupling” regime [ 12 , 3 , 13 ] . Another breakdown of the RWA occurs in non-resonant interactions between atoms and intense low-frequency laser fields. Over the last decades, semi-classical treatment of such interactions has revealed novel phenomena, such as high-order harmonic generation [ 14 ] and formation of attosecond pulses [ 15 ] , which have found numerous applications in atoms [ 16 ] , molecules [ 17 ] and solids [ 18 , 19 , 20 ] . Attosecond technology has also enabled the study of sub-cycle effects of bound states, and CR oscillations in the time domain, as recently shown by polarizing Rydberg states with infrared fields [ 21 , 22 , 23 ] . Recently, the research communities of quantum optics and strong field physics have begun to intersect with researchers considering the generation of quantum states driven by strong fields [ 24 , 25 , 26 , 27 ] . Figure 1: Excited state population |b(t)|^{2} for the resonant transition (i.e. adjusted for AC Stark shift) from the ground state to (a) the 2s state in hydrogen, (b) the 1s2s state in helium, (c) the 1s3d state in helium, parametrically for different intensities. In analogy to classical mechanics, we can define a damping ratio \zeta in order to classify the overdamped ( \zeta>1 ) and underdamped ( \zeta<1 ) regime. In (a) \zeta\sim 1.5 , in (b) \zeta\sim 0.4 , and in (c) \zeta\sim$6\text{\times}{10}^{-3}$ . Strong coupling implies first and foremost Rabi oscillations. In this work, we primarily focus on two-photon Rabi oscillations (2-PRO). 2-PRO is a counterintuitive quantum process that allows for strong coupling between two atomic states of equal parity via weakly coupled states of opposite parity. The Rydberg physics community has diligently applied 2-PRO because it enables coherent transitions to highly excited metastable states in atoms using available lasers in the optical domain [ 28 ] . As it is a non-linear process, which requires high intensities sustained for long times, the process has been largely unexplored in the UV and XUV regime. One notable exception is the work of Dörr et al., where it was shown that population inversion through 2-PRO in hydrogen atoms between the 1s and 2s states is impossible due to unavoidable ionization losses induced by the laser field [ 8 ] . In cQED terminology, large losses compared to the Rabi period lies in the “weak coupling” regime, \Omega<\Gamma , with ionisation rate \Gamma and Rabi frequency \Omega . In Fig. 1 (a), we reproduce this important and unexpected result by showing that the 2-PRO of the excited 2s state in hydrogen are overdamped in the entire resonant parameter space (spanned by pulse intensity I_{0} and duration t ). Physically, this effect arises due to the similar scaling of both \Omega and \Gamma , (\Omega,\Gamma)\propto E_{0}^{2} , as can be understood from effective Hamiltonian theory [ 29 , 30 ] . While 2-PRO in the UV and XUV regime have not yet been realized, intense XUV fields produced by seeded free-electron lasers (FEL) [ 31 , 32 , 33 ] have recently been used to demonstrate one-photon Rabi oscillations (1-PRO) [ 34 ] and strong-field quantum control [ 35 ] between the atomic ground state (GS) and excited states (ES) in helium atoms. In these experiments, \Gamma<\Omega , since \Omega\propto E_{0} and \Gamma\propto E_{0}^{2} [ 36 ] . Therefore, we propose using the “strong coupling” nomenclature from cQED for this regime. In this letter, we show that two-photon Rabi cycling helium atoms, driven by intense XUV light, is a promising system to explore light-matter coupling in novel domains. The overdamped nature of the 1s-2s hydrogen UV transition [Fig. 1 (a)], does not generalize to the experimentally relevant helium atom because the 1s 2 -1s2s XUV transition is underdamped , albeit with only few weak Rabi oscillations surviving, as can be observed in Fig. 1 (b). Most importantly, the two-photon coupling between 1s 2 and 1s3d state is underdamped, with strong Rabi cycles accessible in the parameter space, as shown in Fig. 1 (c). Therefore, the 1s 2 -1s3d transition allows for ‘‘strong coupling’’ conditions over a broad range of intensities and pulse lengths, which enables us to increase the field intensity to explore physics beyond the RWA 1 1 1 While we will not present results on the following, we should briefly mention that we have found that 2-PRO can indeed be driven in hydrogen between the 1s and 3d. The degeneracy of the 3s and 3d is lifted by the field, allowing one to selectively target the 3d state [ 60 ] . In analogy with cQED, we will refer to this regime as “perturbative ultrastrong coupling”. In traditional cQED, which is concerned with ideal two-level systems, the ultrastrong coupling regime is reached when the coupling