Creation of a black hole bomb instability in an electromagnetic system

M. Cromb, M.C. Braidotti, A. Vinante, D. Faccio, H. Ulbricht · 2025

Read Creation of a black hole bomb instability in an electromagnetic system by M. Cromb, M.C. Braidotti, A. Vinante, D. Faccio, H. Ulbricht (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-24034.txt.

Introduction

Marion Cromb and four co-authors built a lab device that acts out a black hole thought experiment from the 1970s. Their 2025 paper rests on Zeldovich's idea: a spinning body can boost waves that graze it, drawing energy from the spin. Pair that gain with a trap for the waves, and the loop runs away, much like the black hole bomb that Press and Teukolsky described.

Earlier work had shown hints, such as gain in sound setups, but never a true runaway with light. Here a spinning metal cylinder boosted a rotating field mode. Coupled to a low-loss resonator, the system turned unstable and made its own waves from noise alone. The signal grew exponentially, as theory predicts. The result backs studies of black hole stability and may seed tests of quantum friction.

Catalog record

CREATORM. Cromb, M.C. Braidotti, A. Vinante, D. Faccio, H. Ulbricht
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE54 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-24034

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Creation of a black hole bomb instability in an electromagnetic system M. Cromb, M.C. Braidotti, A. Vinante, D. Faccio, H. Ulbricht Abstract The amplification and generation of electromagnetic radiation by a rotating metallic or lossy cylinder, first theorized by Zel’dovich in the 1970’s, is tightly connected to the concepts of quantum friction, energy extraction from rotating black holes and runaway mechanisms such as black hole bombs. Despite recent advances including acoustic analogues of the Zel’dovich effect and the observation of a negative resistance in a low-frequency electromagnetic model, actual positive signal amplitude gain, the spontaneous generation of electromagnetic waves and runaway amplification effects have never been experimentally verified. Here, we demonstrate experimentally that a mechanically rotating metallic cylinder not only definitively acts as an amplifier of a rotating electromagnetic field mode but also, when paired with a low-loss resonator, becomes unstable and acts as a generator, seeded only by noise. The system exhibits an exponential runaway amplification of spontaneously generated electromagnetic modes thus demonstrating the electromagnetic analogue of Press and Teukolsky’s ‘black hole bomb’. The exponential amplification from noise supports theoretical investigations into black hole instabilities and is promising for the development of future experiments to observe quantum friction in the form of the Zel’dovich effect seeded by the quantum vacuum. Introduction. In 1971 Yakov Zel’dovich predicted that an absorbing axially-symmetric body rotating at rotational frequency F and scattering incident waves of angular momentum order m could somewhat counter-intuitively amplify those waves if their frequency f satisfies [ 1 ] f<mF. (1) This condition is equivalent to the rotational Doppler-shifted co-rotating mode frequency ( f_{-}=f-mF ) becoming negative in the body’s rotating frame. While Zel’dovich considered the case of a metal cylinder scattering electromagnetic waves [ 2 , 3 ] , he emphasised that this amplification (also known as rotational superradiance [ 4 ] ) is a general effect rooted in thermodynamics and should therefore hold true for any rotating absorber. Indeed, his prediction was directly inspired by the Penrose process, a means of extracting energy from the ultimate absorber: a rotating black hole. The rotating spacetime creates an ergoregion around the black hole horizon where matter and waves can have negative energy. Penrose envisioned that an object scattering with this ergoregion, could split into two and lose a negative energy component into the black hole, while the positive energy part escapes having gained energy from the black hole rotation [ 5 , 6 ] . This Penrose superradiance has been tested recently in analogue systems in the laboratory [ 7 , 8 , 9 ] and has been proposed as part of a mechanism producing relativistic jets of quasars [ 10 ] . This link between the Zel’dovich effect and black hole thermodynamics holds also in the quantum realm. Zel’dovich predicted that a rotating absorber could spontaneously amplify electromagnetic (EM) fields out of the quantum vacuum [ 3 ] , ceding its rotational energy and slowing down. This implication directly inspired [ 11 ] Hawking’s famous prediction that even without rotation, any black hole should slowly radiate its energy away [ 12 , 13 ] . However, this quantum vacuum rotational amplification is very weak and hence difficult to observe. For this reason, Zel’dovich speculated that forming a low-loss resonator by encircling the cylinder with a mirror could amplify this very weak signal [ 1 , 2 ] . This generation mechanism was detailed further in 1972 with Press and Teukolsky’s ’black-hole bomb’ concept [ 14 , 15 ] . A rotating black hole scatters and superradiantly amplifies the impinging modes that satisfy Eq. ( 1 ). Surrounding the black hole with a mirror will reflect scattered modes back towards the hole to be re-amplified. If the mirror is sufficiently reflective, the energy lost at the mirror can be smaller than the energy gained from the black hole. With this positive feedback, such amplified signals grow exponentially, and the system becomes unstable to any random noise seed. The field energy trapped by the mirror grows until it is either released through a controlled opening (another proposed power source), or if unchecked, until the mirror can no longer take the pressure and explodes. A third mechanism is also possible: Cardoso et al. showed that the exponential amplification can also be switched off, if the black hole loses too much angular momentum before the mirror explodes, at which point the system is no longer unstable and the condition in Eq. ( 1 ) is no longer satisfied [ 15 ] . The same instability conditions and behaviors can also occur with Zel’dovich’s electromagnetic cylinder case [ 15 ] . Figure 1: Concept and schematic layout of experiment. a) Diagram showing the Zel’dovich amplification condition. For a given input field, the measured output amplitude depends on the presence of the (absorbing) metal cylinder and its rotation speed: with no cylinder, there is no effect; with the internal cylinder in place and rotating slower than the rotating EM field, absorption is increased; if the cylinder rotates faster than the EM field, amplification occurs. b) Schematic overview of the full experiment. Three sets of external coils surround the internal aluminium cylinder. Each coil is driven by an RLC circuit (P1, P2, P3) with a variable resistor that is used to tune the losses. We plot the numerically calculated magnetic field lines (at a given instant) in purple on the cylinder. Red and blue areas indicate North and South magnetic poles, respectively. Amplification from a rotating absorber was successfully demonstrated for acoustic waves [ 16 , 17 ] . For the case of EM waves, notwithstanding the significantly more prohibitive experimental conditions, a recent work measured Zel’dovich amplification by showing that the rotation of a metallic cylinder induces a negative resistance in an electromagnetic circuit (indicating that amplification is occurring, even if losses still dominate the overall behaviour) [ 18 ] . In this work, we present an experimental study that relies on a rotating magnetic field generated by a 3-phase stator with an internal spinning metallic cylinder. The 3-phase arrangement allows us to generate a magnetic field on the internal cylinder that has a definite rotational direction. At the same time, the external circuit with the stator also acts as a reflector. Thus, the system satisfies the experimental conditions speculated by Zel’dovich for the observation of spontaneous generation and also the conditions outlined by Press et al. for black hole bombs. Indeed, the experimental conditions implemented show net amplification, despite the internal losses of the circuitry. We also observe the spontaneous generation of waves, seeded only by background noise. This generation exhibits a runaway exponential growth, also known as self-oscillation, of the EM waves in analogy to a black hole bomb. Finally, by modifying the operating conditions of the rotating cylinder, we also observe the regime, described by Cardoso et al. [ 15 ] , where this instability and the exponential amplification switches off due to loss of rotational energy in the cylinder. Experimental Setup. Figure 1 a) shows a visualisation of the Zel’dovich amplification condition, Eq. ( 1 ). There is: no effect in the absence of the cylinder; an increased absorption if the cylinder rotates slower than the angular phase velocity of

Read the complete text