On the origin of Jupiter’s fuzzy core: constraints from N-body, impact, and evolution simulations Facilities: Swiss National Supercomputing Centre (Piz Daint, Alps.Eiger)

Thomas Meier, Christian Reinhardt, Sho Shibata, Simon Müller, Joachim Stadel, Ravit Helled · 2025

Read On the origin of Jupiter’s fuzzy core: constraints from N-body, impact, and evolution simulations Facilities: Swiss National Supercomputing Centre (Piz Daint, Alps.Eiger) by Thomas Meier, Christian Reinhardt, Sho Shibata, Simon Müller, Joachim Stadel, Ravit Helled (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-23997.txt.

Introduction

Thomas Meier and co-authors test whether a giant impact gave Jupiter its fuzzy core, in their 2025 arXiv paper. Spacecraft data suggest Jupiter's core is dilute, spread through much of the planet rather than compact. An ancient collision is one popular explanation. The team first simulated planetary dynamics to get realistic impact conditions, then ran impact hydrodynamics and long-term thermal evolution models.

Realistic impacts are mostly oblique; head-on hits are rare. Even a head-on collision failed to produce an extended dilute core, and post-impact heat erased what mixing occurred unless temperatures were implausibly low. The authors conclude the fuzzy core records Jupiter's formation process, not a later crash.

Catalog record

CREATORThomas Meier, Christian Reinhardt, Sho Shibata, Simon Müller, Joachim Stadel, Ravit Helled
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE115 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-23997

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

On the origin of Jupiter’s fuzzy core: constraints from N-body, impact, and evolution simulations Facilities: Swiss National Supercomputing Centre (Piz Daint, Alps.Eiger) Thomas Meier, Christian Reinhardt, Sho Shibata, Simon Müller, Joachim Stadel, Ravit Helled Abstract It has been suggested that Jupiter’s fuzzy core could be a result of a giant impact. Here, we investigate the expected impact conditions from N-body simulations. We then use state-of-the-art SPH simulations to investigate the results of impacts with different conditions including various impactor masses and composition, different formation stages in Jupiter’s growth, and different resolutions. We next simulate the long-term thermal evolution of Jupiter post-impact. We find that 3D N-body simulations predict rather oblique impacts, and that head-on collisions are rare. Moreover, our results show that even under a head-on collision, Jupiter’s fuzzy core cannot be formed. We next simulated Jupiter’s thermal evolution and showed that unless post-impact temperatures are extremely low, a giant impact would not lead to an extended dilute core as inferred by interior models. We conclude that Jupiter’s fuzzy core is not caused by an impact and is likely to be an outcome of its formation process. Journal: ApJ pkdgrav3 [ 73 ] , ballic [ 79 ] , eoslib [ 49 , 50 ] , tipsy [ 66 ] , numpy [ 27 ] , scipy [ 107 ] , matplotlib [ 33 ] , GNU parallel [ 96 ] , ImageMagick [ 35 ] I Introduction The Juno mission provided accurate measurements of Jupiter’s gravitational field, providing tighter constraints for interior models (e.g. Folkner et al. 20 , Iess et al. 34 , Durante et al. 18 ). Jupiter structure models that fit Juno data find that the planet is inhomogeneous in composition and consists of a fuzzy (dilute) core (e.g. Wahl et al. 108 , Vazan et al. 103 , Debras & Chabrier 14 , Nettelmann et al. 67 , Militzer et al. 57 , Miguel et al. 55 ). Several scenarios for the formation of Jupiter’s fuzzy core were proposed. The first is related to Jupiter’s formation process and the concurrent accretion of heavy elements and H-He gas [ 102 , 106 ] . The second scenario suggests that Jupiter’s primordial compact core was eroded by large-scale or double-diffusive convection [ 26 , 58 ] . Finally, the third scenario argues that a giant impact mixed the primordial heavy-element core, distributing the heavy elements beyond the central region [ 43 ] . A comprehensive discussion of these aspects can be found in Helled et al. [30] . While the possibility of forming Jupiter’s fuzzy core via a giant impact has been studied in prior work, further investigations of this scenario are required, as each study was limited in several aspects. Liu et al. [44] identified a scenario where a 10\text{\,}\mathrm{M_{\oplus}} body collides head-on with a nearly fully formed proto-Jupiter of 306.7\text{\,}\mathrm{M_{\oplus}} which sufficiently disrupts the compact core to create a dilute core that is stable over time, also when accounting for Jupiter’s post-impact thermal evolution. However, their N-body simulations were only 2-dimensional, skewing the impact distribution towards head-on impacts. In addition, it remains unclear to what extent the mixing between the core and envelope is caused by the diffusive nature of the Eulerian grid method used in their study [ 88 , 80 ] . In addition, Liu et al. [44] used rather simplified equations of state and treatment of self-gravity. Recently, Sandnes et al. [83] used a newly developed extension to the Lagrangian hydrodynamics method SPH called REMIX [ 82 ] . This method does not suffer from the spurious mixing that large bulk motion introduces in Eulerian methods with improved mixing compared to traditional SPH. Using this improved method, it was shown that although impacts can lead to mixing in the deep interior, settling takes place quickly, leading to a layered structure. It was therefore concluded that Jupiter’s fuzzy core was not created by a giant impact. However, unlike in Liu et al. [44] , Sandnes et al. [82] have not considered the post-impact thermal evolution which is critical for assessing the outcome of the impact on longer timescales. Currently, it remains unclear whether a giant impact can indeed lead to the formation of Jupiter’s fuzzy core. In this study, we re-assess the giant impact scenario while considering the constraints imposed by using 3D N-body formation simulations with tidal damping, high resolution smoothed particle hydrodynamics (SPH) impact simulations with state-of-the-art equations of state and proper treatment of self-gravity and post-impact thermal evolution simulations. Our paper is structured as follows. In Section II we show the results of the N-body simulations and identify the most likely impact conditions. In Section III we present the SPH simulations of the impacts on Jupiter. In Section IV we show the results of the long-term evolution simulations of the post-impact states. In Section V we discuss how our results compare to prior studies, collisions on early Jupiter and challenges for modeling mixing in SPH. Finally, in Section VI we present our conclusions. In Appendix A we propose several mixing metrics to measure mixing in SPH and discuss the challenges. In Appendix B we explore the challenges in modeling mixing in SPH. In Appendix C the parameters of all SPH simulations are listed. II Expected impacts onto Jupiter Liu et al. [44] investigated the impact conditions of four 10\text{\,}\mathrm{M_{\oplus}} embryos during the growth of proto-Jupiter using N-body simulations. They found that in 4060\text{\,}\mathrm{\%} of their simulations a head-on collision (with an impact parameter \theta\lesssim$30\text{\,}\mathrm{\SIUnitSymbolDegree}$ ) is the most probable collision outcome. However, in these simulations the embryos were distributed on the co-planar orbit of proto-Jupiter (2D N-body simulation). This assumption is rather unrealistic because mutual scattering between embryos inclines their mutual orbits. In the case of embryos with inclined orbits, the collision probability decreases and the impact angle increases. We therefore re-assess the expected impact conditions between proto-Jupiter and large embryos using 3D N-body simulations. II.1 Numerical setup Figure 1: Initial mass distribution of embryos with initial orbital separation between the embryos of k=5 (blue) and k=8 (green) mutual Hill radii. The dashed lines show the planetesimal isolation mass calculated with the surface density. The error bars on the dots show k mutual Hill radii on each side. The dotted line shows the surface density of planetesimals which has a Gaussian profile with \mu=$6\text{\,}\mathrm{ua}$ and \sigma=$1.13\text{\,}\mathrm{ua}$ . The total mass of the planetesimal ring is 40\text{\,}\mathrm{M_{\oplus}} . We use the N-body simulation code developed in Shibata & Helled [85] , which uses the IAS15 integrator algorithm [ 76 ] . We distribute 10 embryos around Jupiter’s formation location at \sim$6\text{\,}\mathrm{ua}$ . The mass of each embryo is set to the planetesimal isolation mass, assuming a Gaussian profile for the planetesimal ring [ 5 , 109 , e.g.] . The total mass of the solid and the highest surface density are set to 40\text{\,}\mathrm{M_{\oplus}} and 10\text{\,}\mathrm{g}\text{\,}{\mathrm{cm}}^{-2} , respectively. Our Gaussian profile has the mean location at \mu=$6\text{\,}\mathrm{ua}$ and the standard deviation of the distribution \sigma=$1.13\text{\,}\mathrm{ua}$ . Figure 1 shows the surface density of planetesimals (dotted line). We assume that proto-Jupiter forms in the location where the isolation mass is the highest. The other embryos are distributed assuming an orbital separation of

Read the complete text