Network topology effects on the social circle polls

Giovanni Palermo, Emanuele Brugnoli, Ruggiero D. Lo Sardo, Vittorio Loreto, Giulio Prevedello, Pietro Gravino · 2025

Read Network topology effects on the social circle polls by Giovanni Palermo, Emanuele Brugnoli, Ruggiero D. Lo Sardo, Vittorio Loreto, Giulio Prevedello, Pietro Gravino (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-23879.txt.

Introduction

Giovanni Palermo and five co-authors study how social network shape affects a newer kind of election poll, in a research paper from 2025. Social circle polls ask voters not only their own choice but also how their contacts will vote. This taps collective knowledge and can sharpen forecasts.

Simulations of voter networks show these polls usually beat standard ones. But packed, polarized networks can bias them. The authors propose an estimator that blends both poll types to correct for that. They test it on real data from the twenty sixteen United States presidential election. The method also yields an estimate of how polarized that electorate was.

Catalog record

CREATORGiovanni Palermo, Emanuele Brugnoli, Ruggiero D. Lo Sardo, Vittorio Loreto, Giulio Prevedello, Pietro Gravino
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE51 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-23879

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Network topology effects on the social circle polls Giovanni Palermo, Emanuele Brugnoli, Ruggiero D. Lo Sardo, Vittorio Loreto, Giulio Prevedello, Pietro Gravino Abstract Election polls play a critical role in political discussions by probing public opinion and enabling political parties to assess their performance before elections. However, traditional polling methods sometimes fail to predict election outcomes accurately, leading researchers to explore new methodologies. One such approach is the “social circle” question, which asks respondents about the voting preferences of their social contacts. This method leverages collective intelligence and has shown promise in improving predictive accuracy. Nevertheless, the influence of the social network’s topology on the effectiveness of social circle polls remains unexplored. In this study, we develop a theoretical framework to analyse how social network structure affects polling accuracy. By simulating voter networks with varying levels of polarisation and connectivity, we assess the performance of both standard and social circle polling methods. Our findings indicate that while social circle polls generally outperform traditional approaches, certain network characteristics can introduce biases and undermine their performances, particularly in polarised situations, which are increasingly frequent in the current political landscape. To address these challenges, we propose a new estimator that combines information from both standard and social circle polls, improving election outcome predictions. We demonstrate the applicability of our method using real-world polling data from the 2016 U.S. presidential election, showcasing its practical utility and providing an estimate of the polarisation level in that society. This work establishes a foundation for enhancing polling methodologies by assessing and integrating network features, which has significant implications for social and political research. 1 Introduction The first known example of an opinion poll dates back to 1824, when a tally based on a small sample correctly predicted the election of Andrew Jackson as President of the United States of America Tankard (1972) . Since the outcome was successful, such straw votes gradually became more popular, but they remained local, usually citywide phenomena. The first structured polls on a national sample were carried out only in 1916 by the weekly magazine The Literary Digest , which managed to predict the outcome of the U.S. Presidential elections five times in a row. [ 2 ] . Later, polls became increasingly popular and became a standard tool of political analysis in the 20th century. They were used by the media to probe the population’s leanings and by parties to assess their performance before the elections and during their mandate. Their reliability has thus important consequences on information and decision-making. While survey methods have evolved over the years, polls still occasionally fail in predicting the outcome of the elections Kennedy et al. (2018) ; Zhou et al. (2021) , especially when the difference of votes between the winner and the runner-up is small. Inaccuracies result from many factors. First, the limited number of respondents that pollsters can interview creates uncertainty in predictions Kennedy and Hartig (2019) . Second, the reluctance among individuals to disclose their actual voting intentions Bradburn et al. (2015) , particularly when it involves controversial candidates. Additional factors include the lack of representativeness of survey samples Battaglia et al. (2004) and the adoption of complex electoral systems, in which election results differ significantly from a simple vote count. For instance, in the so-called “first-past-the-post” system used in the UK, where voters elect candidates at the district level, a party with much less than 50% can still gain the majority of seats in the Parliament, as long as it wins in most districts. In such cases, guessing the total share of votes for each candidate or party is not enough. A notable occasion in which this resulted in an issue is the election of Donald Trump as President of the USA in 2016. Most polls correctly predicted Clinton would get the majority of votes, and even pollsters working in Trump’s campaign confirmed he would have lost the election Jacobs and House (2019) . Nevertheless, Trump was finally elected President because of most states’ winner-take-all system. In such cases, being accurate at a local level or with a smaller population is crucial. To enhance predictive accuracy, pollsters have been formulating new question formats to extract more information from the survey and mitigate sample size limitations. The “Election winner” question is one of these attempts. It asks participants who they think will be elected Rothschild and Wolfers (2011) , replacing the usual inquiry about their voting intention. In this way, by collecting the persons’ perceptions about the vote, the pollsters virtually increase the sample size and exploit a wisdom of the crowd effect Galton (1907) to predict the winner. While this approach has been successful in certain cases Lewis-Beck and Skalaban (1989) ; Graefe (2014) , it also presents some limitations. Notably, it focuses on the election outcome rather than vote percentages, provides results at the national rather than local level, and relies exclusively on public perception, which may be influenced by media and other external factors Irwin and Van Holsteyn (2002) . In fact, the wisdom of the crowd is susceptible to biases and correlations in population responses Davis-Stober et al. (2014) ; Lorenz et al. (2011) . The “Social circle” question was introduced to overcome these limitations Nisbett and Kunda (1985) ; Dawtry et al. (2015) . An illustrative example of such a question is: “Of all your social contacts who are likely to vote, what percentage will vote for [party/candidate]?” Galesic et al. (2018) . This approach offers several advantages: it provides estimates of vote distribution, enables local-level analysis, and is less susceptible to biases introduced by external influences Galesic et al. (2018) . Moreover, this estimator is less affected by individuals’ reluctance to disclose their voting intentions, as previous studies have shown that estimates based on social circle align more closely with the actual population than self-reported perceptions Galesic et al. (2012) . Initial trials of political surveys indicate that social circle polling may surpass traditional polling in accuracy Galesic et al. (2018) , even in multi-party systems Bruine de Bruin et al. (2022) . However, for the methodology to become a new standard, it requires validation across a broader range of contexts and support by a robust theoretical framework. The existing literature has focused on studying the network of voters at the scale of the individual participant connections Lee et al. (2019) ; Ahlstrom-Vij (2022) . We argue that, since this methodology leverages social connections, understanding the impact of the entire network structure is of paramount importance. In this work, we evaluate social circle polling on a network of voters, examining the impact of topological features on performance and identifying ways to improve estimates. We introduce a theoretical framework that employs a stochastic model to generate networks with varying structural properties, enabling simulations of both classic and social circle polls under different configurations. By calculating the risk and accuracy of these estimators, we measure how much topological polarisation can decrease the performance of social circle polls compared to standard polls. By leveraging our theoretical framework, we could estimate the network’s polarisation with high accuracy. Using this new information, we developed an improved estimator that outperforms both classic and social circle poll estimators. Finally, we demonstrate our

Read the complete text