Detection of an extraterrestrial technical civilisation on the extrasolar planet GJ 1132 b

Frederic V. Hessman, Andrew Collier Cameron, Keith Horne · 2025

Read Detection of an extraterrestrial technical civilisation on the extrasolar planet GJ 1132 b by Frederic V. Hessman, Andrew Collier Cameron, Keith Horne (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-23788.txt.

Introduction

Frederic Hessman, Andrew Collier Cameron, and Keith Horne present a deliberately playful detection claim about the exoplanet GJ 1132 b. Their 2025 paper reports, with a straight face, whisky in the atmosphere of the rocky super-Earth, seen in both absorption and emission spectra. Natural sources of alcohol, the authors deadpan, cannot explain the signal.

The paper therefore credits a technically advanced civilization, possibly from the neighboring planet, running vast distilling operations. Rocket fuel for an interplanetary economy is offered as one motive, and unusually heavy personal consumption as the likelier one. The piece closes by tying the joke to the Fermi paradox, in the tradition of humorous astronomy papers.

Catalog record

CREATORFrederic V. Hessman, Andrew Collier Cameron, Keith Horne
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE35 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-23788

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Detection of an extraterrestrial technical civilisation on the extrasolar planet GJ 1132 b Frederic V. Hessman, Andrew Collier Cameron, Keith Horne Abstract We report the detection of whisky in the atmosphere of the extrasolar super-Earth planet GJ 1132 b from transmission spectroscopic data. It is seen both in atmospheric absorption as well as in chromospheric emission, the latter probably due to the intense heating of the co-rotating planet’s day-side surface. This detection cannot be explained using natural sources of alcohol, implying that there must be a technically advanced civilisation – possibly originating from the neighboring habitable planet GJ 1132 c – that is engaged in massive distilling operations accompanied by high levels of industrial pollution. The reason for the necessarily vast scale of production is either to produce rocket fuel for an interplanetary economy or, more likely, for an unusually high level of personal consumption. The latter hypothesis suggests a novel explanation for the Fermi Paradox (the lack of indirect or direct contact with extraterrestrials): a technically versed civilisation would be incapable of achieving the higher technical levels necessary for the development of a detectable radio signature – much less interstellar travel – at the suggested rates of consumption. 2025 Detection of an extraterrestrial technical civilisation on the extrasolar planet GJ 1132 b – A 1 Introduction Transmission spectroscopy, a pivotal tool in astrophysics, elucidates the atmospheric compositions of exoplanets by analyzing the light passing through or around these distant worlds during transits. Charbonneau et al. (2002) initiated this field with the groundbreaking observation of the first exoplanetary transit, opening the door to subsequent studies such as Kreidberg et al. (2014) , who explored the atmosphere of GJ 1214 b using the Hubble Space Telescope. The imminent launch of the James Webb Space Telescope ( Beichman et al., 2014 ) promises further advancements, highlighting the continuous evolution of this technique. In addition to deciphering atmospheric compositions, transmission spectroscopy plays a crucial role in the search for signs of life beyond our solar system. Seager et al. (2005) investigated the detectability of biomarkers like oxygen and ozone, presenting the potential for identifying habitable environments. Kaltenegger & Traub (2009) extended this concept to habitable zones, emphasizing the significance of transmission spectroscopy in characterizing life-friendly conditions. As technology advances, the possibility of detecting biosignatures becomes increasingly feasible, marking transmission spectroscopy as a key player in the exploration of extraterrestrial life. Beyond the search for life, transmission spectroscopy has ventured into the realm of technosignatures—indicators of advanced technological civilizations. Schindler & Kipping (2018) proposed using transmission spectroscopy to identify artificial pollutants in exoplanet atmospheres, while Wright et al. (2014) discussed the potential of large telescopes to survey for technosignatures. This pioneering approach adds a fascinating dimension to the quest for intelligent extraterrestrial life, showcasing the versatility and expanding applications of transmission spectroscopy in the ever-evolving field of exoplanetary science. As part of the Scottish-German research project “Buaidh Astrofiosaig Uisge-Beatha Braiche”, we have considered whether distilled alcohol might be detected in the atmospheres of extrasolar planets. 2 The absorption coefficient of distilled alcohols In the commercial literature, there have been many attempts at characterizing the wavelength-dependent absorbance of distilled alcohol (hereafter abbreviated as “A”), primarily for the purpose of quality control and authentication ( Wójcicki, 2015 ; Okolo et al., 2023 ) . The mass-absorption coefficient of distilled alcohol \kappa_{\lambda}^{A} can be derived from the published absorbance \cal{A}_{\lambda} or transmission \cal{T}_{\lambda} data via ~~~~~~~~~~~~{\cal{A}}_{\lambda}\equiv\ln{\cal{T}}_{\lambda}=\rho_{\rm A}\,\kappa_{\lambda}^{A}\,L\ , (1) where \rho_{\rm A} is the mass-density of the probe, \kappa_{\lambda}^{A} is the absorption coefficient to be determined, and L is the path length through the probe. The mass-density of all alcohols in the laboratory are assumed to be that of ethanol: 0.789 g/cm 3 (wikipedia). The opacity in the gaseous phase is assumed to be identical to that in the liquid phase. We extracted the mass-absorption opacity of pure ethanol from a figure found in the Wikimedia Commons (2020) . The contributor used a fibre-feed Ocean Optics spectrometer (NIR-512) with a temperature-regulated InGaAs detector; the light from a halogen light bulb was shown through a beaker of liquid ethanol ( L =2 cm). The result is shown in Fig. 1 : the opacity is very high compared with that of a dry planetary atmosphere (also shown in Fig. 1 ); the opacity drops dramatically below 1.2 \mu m but remains high for \lambda>1.4\,\mu m; and there is a local minimum around 1.3 \mu m. For alcohol subjected to additional technical processing, we use the NIR spectra of Mignani et al. (2011) covering a range of whiskys. A Perkin Elmer spectrophotometer in the wavelength range 290-1880 nm at 5 nm resolution. The whisky probe was contained in a Hellma QS quartz cuvette ( L=1\, mm). The opacity is even higher than before (Fig. 1 ) but this time the spectrum shows a prominent broad peak around 1.4 \mu m instead. We adopt the highlands probe over the islands probe; the differences are small in the NIR. The relatively high opacities relative to that usually expected imply that searches for distilled alcohol are quite sensitive to small quantities, and the peaks/drops in the opacities between 1.2 and 1.5 \mu m provide distinct spectral features to search for. Figure 1: Mass-absorption coefficients for whisky (top), ethanol (middle) and a dry planetary atmosphere (bottom; from Swain et al. (2021)). 3 Adding distilled alcohol to models of exoplanet transmission spectra The effort needed to produce a good opacity model for transmission spectra is considerable. However, since we only desire to add a minor chemical constituent – distilled alcohol – we present here a genial method for perturbing a known model. Heng & Kitzmann (2017) presented an analytic model for the effects of an isothermal planetary atmosphere on the transit lightcurves of exoplanets. The effective transit cross-section of the atmosphere at a wavelength \lambda is ~~~~~~~~~~~~{\tt A}_{\lambda}=\pi\,R_{0}^{2}+2\,\pi\,\int_{R_{0}}^{\infty}\left(1-\frac{I_{\lambda}(R)}{I_{\lambda,*}}\right)\,R\,dR=\pi\,R_{\lambda}^{2}\ , (2) where R_{0} is a reference radius roughly corresponding to that of the opaque surface, I_{\lambda}(R)/I_{\lambda,*} is the fractional reduction in transmitted stellar intensity – for a simple two-stream model e^{-\tau_{\lambda}} – and R is the cylindrical impact parameter centered on the planet. For an isothermal atmosphere, this equation can be solved for the effective radius of the star at wavelength \lambda , \displaystyle~~~~~~~~~~~~R_{\lambda} \displaystyle\!\approx\! \displaystyle R_{0}+H\,\left(\gamma+\ln(\tau_{0})+E_{1}(\tau_{0})\right) (3) \displaystyle\tau_{0} \displaystyle\!\approx\! \displaystyle\frac{P_{0}\,\kappa_{\lambda}}{g_{0}}\sqrt{\frac{2\,\pi\,R_{0}}{H}} where R_{0} , P_{0} , and g_{0} are the atmospheric reference radius, pressure and surface gravity, H is the effective atmospheric scaleheight, \gamma is the Euler-Mascheroni constant (approximately 0.5772), \kappa_{\lambda} is the effective mean mass-absorption coefficient, and E_{1}(\cdot) is the first elliptical integral ( Heng & Kitzmann, 2017 ) . There are substantial parameter degeneracies in interpreting transmission spectra, but here we are only interested in detecting minor trace components of the atmosphere. Given values of R_{\lambda} and R_{0} one can invert Eqn. 3 to obtain the opacities used to model the transmission spectra from the published model. Since the choice of R_{0} is arbitrary – other than the fact that the broadband optical depth \tau_{0} of a line-of-sight at R_{0} should be large – we set R_{0} equal to the radius at which \tau_{0}=10 for the purpose of re-construction the opacities, i.e. R_{0}=R_{\rm p}+H(\gamma+1) . However, we will leave it as a free parameter

Read the complete text